In budget with $62 million increase, Seattle Police propose saving $230,000 by eliminating West Seattle-based Mounted Patrol Unit

(Reader photo, Mounted Patrol at Alki Beach, 2023)

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

As city councilmembers dig into Mayor Harrell‘s budget proposal, they have a West Seattle-specific cut to consider:

14 years after the Seattle Police Department last tried to disband its Mounted Patrol Unit, the last one in the region, based next to Westcrest Park in southeast West Seattle, the unit is on the chopping block again, as a way to save just under a quarter-million dollars from an SPD budget that is proposed to jump from $395 million this year to $457 million next year.

A reader called our attention to this by forwarding a letter that Mounted Patrol members have drawn up, pleading for help to save what’s left of “the last Mounted Patrol Unit in the Pacific Northwest.” More on that in a moment. First, here’s what we found in the budget itself: The proposed cut is on page 362 of the mayor’s full citywide budget plan, sent to the City Council last Tuesday:

Remove Support For SPD’s Mounted Patrol Unit
Expenditures $(230,030)

This item eliminates General Fund support of the department’s Mounted Patrol Unit (MPU), including 1.0 FTE Equipment & Facilities Coordinator, three unbudgeted part-time temporary maintenance laborers, and associated operating costs. Sworn positions currently assigned to the MPU will continue to be funded by the General Fund but will be reassigned elsewhere in the department.

(WSB photo, 2023)

The unit has only two sworn positions assigned to it; as explained to us during an “open barn” at MPU HQ last year, if they need more help, officers are temporarily reassigned from elsewhere in the department. At the time of our visit, the unit had six horses plus mini-horse Li’l Sebastian.

In the new budget proposal, this is the only SPD service/unit specifically called out for cutting, The increased spending in the SPD budget (page 359) includes $10 million more for overtime to fund “emphasis patrols” (no geographical specifics but in the past these have included extra officers for summer nights on Alki), $2 million for the “Real-Time Crime Center,” $2 million for “scheduling and timekeeping software,” and $1.2 million to add more school-zone speed-enforcement cameras (of course eventually expected to pay for themselves).

(WSB photo, Morgan Junction Community Festival this past June)

The Mounted Patrol’s mission has changed over the years; when the unit was proposed for disbanding in 2010, its crowd-control attributes were discussed; more recently, its major function has been community relations. That’s pointed out in the support-seeking letter that was sent to us. See the full letter here; the text is as follows:

Loyal Supporter,
We need your help!

Horses have been a cherished part of the Seattle Police Department for almost 150 years; with the modern inception of the Mounted Unit being established in 1973 with eight horses, seven officers, and one sergeant. Today it is diminished to 1 dedicated sergeant and 1 full time Officer with civilian support barn staff, and it is the last remaining Mounted Patrol Unit in the Pacific Northwest.

In its early years, the Unit’s primary mission was to patrol the 5,000 acres of City parks. Its secondary mission was crowd control and management during largescale events. In the 1980s the unit further evolved, with patrol duties expanded to include the downtown waterfront business districts and residential areas, in addition to the 5,000 acres of City parks.

Today the Unit’s heart and soul is its commitment to the communities of Seattle and beyond, helping build a bridge between community members and law enforcement by not only patrolling neighborhoods, parks and the downtown Seattle corridor, but also through its participation in countless community events and celebrations. As a secondary, but no less important mission, the Seattle Police Mounted Unit is an integral part of honoring fallen law enforcement officers for a myriad of surrounding agencies, providing a longtime, honored tradition of the Riderless Horse for all line of duty death memorials across the Pacific Northwest.

To the point of our letter, we are having a moment of de ja vu. The Seattle Police Department has announced its intention to close the doors of this treasured piece of heritage. It is with a heart-wrenching plea that we write to you today, begging you to help rally the troops, warm up your voices and help us save our unit, the last Mounted Patrol Unit in the Pacific Northwest. Once it is gone, there is no bringing it back, ask the Portland Police Department. You’ve done it before when budget shortfalls at the City put the MPU in jeopardy in 2010, and we need you to do it again!

Help us by spreading the word to other community members and Mounted Unit supporters. Write letters to the Chief’s office, including all the Assistant Chiefs and Deputy Chief, beseech City Councilmembers, share your stories that include the Mounted Unit and our beloved Police Horses, make them see that we are more than a line item on a budget sheet, that our impact goes beyond today, that we are an integral part of One Seattle.

Warmly,
Seattle Police Mounted Patrol Team

Various contact addresses are listed on the letter‘s second page.

Back in 2010-2011, when then-Mayor Mike McGinn‘s budget called for cutting the Mounted Patrol Unit, the nonprofit Seattle Police Foundation came forward with funding to save it. That support lasted for a few years; in 2014, as we reported at the time, then-Mayor Ed Murray‘s budget restored general-fund support, calling the unit a “valuable public service.” (The police budget for 2015 was $298 million.) We’ll be contacting the SPF about the new unit-cutting proposal; it has continued to provide some support for the MPU, as we noted in this story last year.

(WSB photo, 2023)

Other questions so far include what would happen to the unit’s headquarters in Highland Park if the Mounted Patrol is indeed disbanded. Its upkeep has included a significant amount of community volunteer work, including beautification of the grounds. We’ll be following up.

WHAT’S NEXT: The proposed budget is now in the City Council’s hands to review and shape before a final vote in November. Right now the council is hearing department-by-department overviews; SPD is scheduled to make its presentation during the council session starting at 9:30 am Tuesday (October 1). The agenda includes a public-comment period, as do most other council meetings; the first budget-specific public hearing is set for October 16.

ADDED 2:24 PM: SPD has published a statement this afternoon about its plan to disband the unit. The statement says in part that “as SPD continues to recover from loss of hundreds of officers over the past four years, we have to carefully prioritize how to use existing scarce resources. The highest priority is maintaining the ability to respond quickly to emergency calls, and effectively investigate dangerous criminal behavior so the community is protected. This requires that we reduce resources for work that does not directly support these two priorities.”

74 Replies to "In budget with $62 million increase, Seattle Police propose saving $230,000 by eliminating West Seattle-based Mounted Patrol Unit"

  • $60 million for SPD, $0 for Jaahnavi Kandula September 29, 2024 (11:53 am)

    I didn’t even know we had a mounted patrol. But this is laughable Harrell wants to give the department that he promoted an alleged sexual predator a $60 million increase. The city budget is already over. What a joke. Jaahnavi Kandula’s family never received money to cover her expenses and no settlement yet Daniel Auderer has the nerve to sue because everyone heard what a jerk he was. 

    • Maybe if you didn’t cover for police officers who killed people from their own negligence, and officers who harassed people, that leave the TAXPAYERS on the hook, the Police would have more money to do something. 
      • VOTE OUT HARRELL WHO LOOKS OUT FOR HIS COMRADES. 
    • WiseWoman October 3, 2024 (9:54 am)

      100% truth

  • Jort September 29, 2024 (11:55 am)

    The horsies cost $230k a year?!?!?!?! The ones used mostly for “community relations?” No wonder they’re the last “mounted patrol unit” (note: not actually patrolling) in Washington. YEESH!

    • Anne September 29, 2024 (1:15 pm)

      But-but-they’re not cops in cars Jort-you should be rejoicing that we have them. 

    • CarDriver September 29, 2024 (1:34 pm)

      Jort. Anti car plus anti animal equals?

      • Eric1 September 29, 2024 (4:27 pm)

        C&D, you forgot that there is always the bicycle patrol program.   However, the police can only use pedal bikes.  No way he agrees to supply them with “police interceptor” e-bikes.  The power hungry police officers cannot be trusted with high wattage e-bikes. It would be like issuing magnum caliber handguns to throttle trigger happy cops. The police must not be allowed to endanger the public with high speed pursuits on bikes. Pedal power or walking is the only solution.  

        • Daniel September 29, 2024 (11:00 pm)

          I get the joke, but if we’re being pedantic, magnum caliber handguns are a pretty bad choice for law enforcement.  Especially modern lighter pistols.  E.g. when the FBI tried to use 10mm back in the day (90s?), it was a dumpsterfire, and they got rid of it in fairly short order.

  • c September 29, 2024 (12:05 pm)

    I’d definitely prefer to invest in our schools than a set of public-relations horses (even if I do quite enjoy seeing a horse every once in a while ).

    • Sillygoose September 29, 2024 (1:45 pm)

      If the multi millions of dollars from the sale of marijuana was used for education as promised we wouldn’t have a deficit. Save mounted patrol!!!!

  • Delridge res September 29, 2024 (12:58 pm)

    Highly in favor of cutting this and reallocating the resources to other non police centered community programs.

  • Buttercup September 29, 2024 (1:05 pm)

    Double, save LOTS of money, horses can enjoy some big open fields. Good all around, run  horsies run!!

  • Rhonda September 29, 2024 (1:30 pm)

    SPD’s mounted unit is a gem. It’s should be kept no matter the cost. $230K is a bargain. Think of what it costs to repair damaged patrol vehicles due to suspects ramming SPD and speeding off due to their pursuit ban (a LOT more than $230K).

    • Bbron September 29, 2024 (2:05 pm)

      when was the last time the mounted patrol apprehended someone? they’re literally a PR tool…

    • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (2:06 pm)

      Rhonda…I 100% agree with you.  A 1,000 pound trained horse and an experienced rider are great for crowd control.  The horse’s height alone gives a rider great visibility over crowds.  A horse is also intimating due to its size allowing it to maneuver well through rowdy crowds who tend to give a horse and its rider space.  SPD would benefit in keeping their Mounted Patrol Unit.

      • Oakley34 September 29, 2024 (2:26 pm)

        The last thing SPD needs is more tools to intimidate the public. Thanks for making the case for giving them the axe. 

        • Anne September 29, 2024 (2:44 pm)

          What a load of baloney. 

          • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (7:32 pm)

            Anne…Could explain what the “load of baloney” is in having a Mounted Police Unit?

        • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (7:30 pm)

          Oakley34…Do you know the purpose of SPD’s or any other city’s use of a Mounted Police Unit?   How would you control large crowds of people that become rowdy, destructive and completely out-of-control in major cities across the USA?  What “tools” would you use?

          • K September 29, 2024 (8:34 pm)

            Historically, SPD has used riot gear, rubber bullets, and tear gas with crowds much smaller than that, even ones who are completely peaceful and compliant.  Horses are for cops who understand restraint.  That is not who SPD is.  The horses are there for PR.

    • Bubbleator September 30, 2024 (12:01 pm)

      Horses are indeed useful during major events (think sports) and during incidents for crowd control – as I understand it they are stationed in WS but are used citywide as needed.  It’s a small line item in the overall scheme of things, and will be way more expensive to reinstate when (not if) it gets restored in a future budget. 

      • Bbron September 30, 2024 (1:39 pm)

        when have mounted cops been used in that capacity?

        • ARPigeonPoint September 30, 2024 (2:12 pm)

          I haven’t witnessed it here, but in New Orleans, mounted horses are absolutely used for crowd crontrol, even during Mardi Gras. It can be done, and it is done, at least elsewhere. 

          • Bbron September 30, 2024 (2:50 pm)

            I made a mistake not clarifying: I’m not arguing the use specifically of horses, rather SPD’s history using their mounted cops. I don’t care about other PDs’ abilities to operate with horses, as this is a conversation about our local PD. To rephrase: “when have the SPD mounted cops been used in that capacity?” with our particular historically brutal PD, we should only be pushing in the direction of having them focus on de-escalation that they desperately need.

  • anonyme September 29, 2024 (1:52 pm)

    The best use of mounted patrol I ever saw was in Portland.  A perp was running down the center of the park blocks, and a mounted patrol officer galloped up behind him and  quickly ended the pursuit.  But we don’t really have an environment where mounted patrols are practical, and I’m not big on animal servitude – so I’m for giving these horses a nice retirement.

  • Derek September 29, 2024 (1:59 pm)

    Animal abuse. Get rid of this outdated program.

    • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (2:11 pm)

      Mounted Patrol Unit horses have intensive training and are highly skilled in doing their jobs.  Could you please give us examples of the form of  “animal abuse” done to trained Mounted Patrol Unit horses?  Are dogs that herd cattle, sheep also abused?

    • Anne September 29, 2024 (2:45 pm)

      You are seriously uninformed. Go spew your lies elsewhere. 

      • Pete September 29, 2024 (7:00 pm)

        I reckon the horse would rather be chilling in a field to be fair.  

    • CarDriver September 29, 2024 (3:10 pm)

      So is owning ANY pet. Don’t you agree?

    • raywest September 29, 2024 (4:44 pm)

      Animal abuse? How? They are service animals that are well cared for. If the unit is disbanded, I hope these hard-working horses get a comfortable and safe retirement and aren’t just sold off at some auction where their fates are questionable at best. Many horses end up in auction kill pens, getting sent off to Mexico for slaughter.

      • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (7:35 pm)

        RayWest…You are 100% correct.

      • Derek September 29, 2024 (9:13 pm)

        Thank you for the straw man about additionally abused horses but yes it’s animal abuse. Horses shouldn’t be animal slaves to property protectors. 

        • bradley September 29, 2024 (11:10 pm)

          How do you sleep at night, after drumming up all this drama?

        • Bubbleator September 30, 2024 (12:03 pm)

          You’re a laugh riot, scooter.

          • Derek September 30, 2024 (12:43 pm)

            Animal slaves don’t have even remote autonomy in your world, yep, I get it Scooter. And I’m sure more comments get published doing straw men to other abused animals or pets (domesticated pets are fine—maybe you should look up police horses that get confronted by off leash dogs and how chaotic behave, or you know, do any research at all before popping off at me)

        • Seattlite September 30, 2024 (12:58 pm)

          Derek…How are the horses abused?

    • Eric 43 September 30, 2024 (11:59 am)

      100% agree and then she get rid of the k9 unit too it’s animal abuse

  • Wendell September 29, 2024 (3:45 pm)

    My first thought after reading this article is that using animals to teach empathy to at-risk youth, as well as helping the rehabilitation of our incarcerated population are two examples in favor of keeping the mounted unit funded. Perhaps adding more of these community-building assignments, or something similar could sway the funding vote in favor of keeping SPD’s MPU. 

  • Tracey September 29, 2024 (3:58 pm)

    $230,000 is what me pay one firefighter earning OT in Seattle.  Drop in the bucket.   Don’t pretend this is a significant budget issue.

  • Jarvis Purvis September 29, 2024 (5:06 pm)

    Okay… Check it:What if we go the other way, and all cops are horse cops? Who’s with me?

  • WSzombie September 29, 2024 (6:13 pm)

    If there is a budget surplus due to being understaffed, why make cuts to a program that is actually useful AND staffed? 

    • Bbron September 29, 2024 (6:50 pm)

      how is the mounted patrol useful to the community? Being PR for SPD isn’t useful for the community.

  • Moi September 29, 2024 (6:29 pm)

    SPD does not use their mounted unit for crowd control, they haven’t for a long time.They’ll claim they do, but the unit isn’t big enough to be used for crowd control.While the horses are cool to see, they’re nothing but an expensive PR unit.I want SPD to focus on basic policing, no frills.  We’re in a citywide budget crunch and now is the time for hard choices to be made.

  • Seattlite September 29, 2024 (7:48 pm)

    MOI…Do you know the last time SPD used their Mounted Police Unit for crowd control?  The horses go through thousands of hours of training to become highly skilled at crowd control while in crowds of rowdy and violent people.  What would you use to control large crowds…say more than 5,000 people…who are causing mass destruction in a city?

    • Frog September 29, 2024 (11:19 pm)

      If the horses go through thousands of hours of training, they are taking up a lot of officer time and costing a lot more than $230,000.  They sound like a major boondoggle.

      • Seattlite September 30, 2024 (8:47 am)

        “The Seattle Police Mounted Patrol Unit trains its horses using the Buck Brannaman style of natural horsemanship. The unit has been using this style since 1999, when all members attended a clinic by Dennis Reis. In 2005, the unit’s sergeant found a clinic by Buck Brannaman in Dayton, Washington, and the unit began attending his clinics. The Buck Brannaman style of horsemanship originated in the Pacific Northwest with brothers Tom and Bill Dorrance, who are considered founders of the natural horsemanship movement. Buck Brannaman was a student of Ray Hunt and is known for his ability to calm unruly horses. In 2023, the unit invested in specialized horsemanship training for its members and auxiliary riders from expert clinician Joe Wolter. The unit continued to work with Wolter in 2024.”

    • Bbron September 29, 2024 (11:50 pm)

      “Do you know the last time SPD used their Mounted Police Unit for crowd control” i mean, do you? you’re in this thread advocating a use of horses that SPD has never done (or at least in recent memory).

      • Seattlite September 30, 2024 (12:09 pm)

        BBron…If SPD cannot use tear gas, pepper spray, flash bangs, sound cannons, rubber bullets to control rioters, unruly crowds, unruly protestors in Seattle, what do you propose SPD use for crowd control to limit destruction to private/public properties and harm to people by an out-of-control crowd?  

        • Bbron September 30, 2024 (1:36 pm)

          SPD is still allowed to use tear gas. protests, particularly in 2020, were never “unruly” until SPD escalated the situation. in those cases, no SPD presence would’ve resulted in a better outcome. maybe instead of looking for what opportunities we should have for SPD to squash crowds they deem needing to be dispersed, how about we ask “which tools can be used to de-escalate?” that’s what we should be wanting from a PD. mounted cops wouldn’t be a tool for that (from your own words, they’re an intimidating presence). also, when SPD was arguing to be able to use those crowd control techniques never once were mounted cops brought up showing that they aren’t viewed as useful in those situations what-so-ever.

        • K September 30, 2024 (2:11 pm)

          SPD doesn’t WANT to move away from violent confrontation to something like horses.  That’s exactly why it doesn’t make any sense to keep funding them.  By SPD’s own admission, the horses have just been used for PR for quite a while, regardless of training.  If you are looking to reform the police department, there’s a lot of folks right there with you, but there is a lot of work to be done before we can even start to talk about using horses for crowd control.  And in the meantime, we’re paying for a bunch of horses and horse cops that do nothing but PR.

  • West Seattle Mad Sci Guy September 29, 2024 (8:12 pm)

    I’m still convinced that most the regular personalities here are all bots. Especially myself.

    • momosmom September 30, 2024 (7:25 am)

      @WSMSciGuy! LOL!

    • Seattlite September 30, 2024 (1:01 pm)

      WS Mad Sci Guy…The people that run the WSBLOG know for a fact that I am not a “BOT.”  Why do think the commenters on the WSBLOG are “BOTs”?

  • Ferns September 29, 2024 (11:04 pm)

    230k sounds like the cost of 1 retired officer on pension. Or one mid-career cop with overtime. A drop in the financial bucket. I’d say it’s better to look at the utility of mounted policing. Could even be valuable for community relations- I don’t know. 

  • TnE September 30, 2024 (12:36 am)

    These are highly trained horses. They should be allowed to do crowd control on Alki. 

  • YellowPup September 30, 2024 (6:38 am)

    The police are taking their truckloads of cash and shifting it into pay increases and further militarization, in order to implement Harrell’s new budget for harassing people and throwing away their stuff,, and the special supplemental funding for wellness checks with military guns drawn. Harrell’s vision for quality of life in the Northwest. What great times we live in.

  • NotaNaySayer September 30, 2024 (7:48 am)

    If the budget is ballooning to 457 million next year, the cost per year of the horses is a mere 5% of that budget…this all seems a bit bait and switch as the conversation is now over 5% of an otherwise GIANT budget…Let them ride the horses, they are well cared for and lots of folks like them, even if it’s for pomp and circumstance; at the end of the day it isn’t going to make or break the budget.

    • Daniel September 30, 2024 (9:07 am)

      Note that 5% of 457 million is like 23 million.  I think you might have meant 0.05%

      • NotaNaySayer September 30, 2024 (10:34 am)

        Whoops pardon the typo!! Even more of a reason that it isn’t really something that is going to “save” so much haha

    • SA Eng September 30, 2024 (9:14 am)

      The $230,000 is actually only 0.05% of the $457M budget. 

  • KT September 30, 2024 (8:46 am)

    In a city starved for uniformed police officers on patrol, what good is a two person PR unit?  Let’s be realistic.  Use the money elsewhere.

  • platypus September 30, 2024 (10:30 am)

    Sounds like a perfect job for ebikes. Plus they dont need food

  • SeattleSteve September 30, 2024 (10:50 am)

    At first I thought this was a satirical IG post on The Needling….

  • Watertowerjim September 30, 2024 (11:07 am)

    Why not?  Reducing police presence worked so well last time……..

  • WSB September 30, 2024 (2:24 pm)

    Adding this link above too but for anyone checking in on the discussion, SPD’s statement published this past hour:
    https://spdblotter.seattle.gov/2024/09/30/seattle-police-department-discontinues-mounted-patrol-unit-2/

  • watertower September 30, 2024 (6:20 pm)

    keep the SPD horse unit. they could use the empty bike lanes.

  • Moi September 30, 2024 (8:35 pm)

    The SPD Mounted Unit is not large enough to be used for crowd control.  They only have 6 horses, that isn’t enough to do crowd control, and they have not been used as crowd control for years and years.                                                                                                                                                                    They don’t claim they’re used for crowd control and the laughable statement that they respond to 911 calls is ridiculous.   I’d love to see how many 911 calls they responded to in 2023.  For a unit with 4 officers and 1 sergeant that’s 5 cops could be in patrol cars responding to emergency calls, not riding horses around the Junction during Summer Fest or any other community event they saddle up for.

  • Jort October 1, 2024 (8:01 am)

    Neeeeiiggghhhhhh!!!! Whhooaaaaaaaaaaa, pardner! These horsie-horses are using up our taxpayer greenbacks! I think it’s high time we saddle up and dosie-doe our way into some better uses of funding!!! Yeeeeeee hawwwww, pardner!!! This cowboy might be OK with throwing a few bucks to some more horsey-times  ….. if the city hadn’t already spent millions and millions of dollars to settle claims against officers for harming citizens! Move along, little dogies! Move along! 

  • sherry October 2, 2024 (6:04 am)

    After reading all the comments here, I find that only a few really understand what the mounted patrol are or what they do. Mosts of the reply’s are absolutely insane comments, with no substance, just rants.  The mounted police unit should absolutely be kept.  Everyone should go to the WS complex when they have an open house, and see for themselves just how well these horses are trained and used in society. They serve in more ways than just police. As for the budget they consume less money than the average cop in a car. And a cop on a horse is less of a threat to most people, they can patrol areas where a car can”t go. Would love to see more of them in our parks and neighborhoods. 

  • Actually Mike October 4, 2024 (10:17 am)

    It’s worth considering the rare but entirely possible event of a far-worse-than-anticipated natural disaster like what’s just happened in Western North Carolina. Roads and bridges are destroyed, emergency vehicles can’t get around, they’re still counting the dead. We all hope not, but something like that could happen here, too. And folks there aren’t using electric bikes to deliver insulin to those who need it: Yep, horses. There are times and places when it’s almost impossible to get around any other way. Worth thinking about.

Sorry, comment time is over.