‘I want my money back!’ City Council committee hears about jail-booking crunch and other ‘significant obstacles’ in public-safety ‘ecosystem’; mayor tries to fix one

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

Moments before Mayor Harrell announced at noontime today that the city is working on getting 20 spaces at the regional SCORE misdemeanor jail, the City Council’s Public Safety Committee had heard about – among other things – the inability to book many misdemeanor suspects into the King County Jail. This, despite an 18-year contract with the county costing $22 million this year alone, which led to Council President Sara Nelson exclaiming, “I want my money back!”

That was toward the end of an information-packed committee meeting with an agenda also including Interim Police Chief Sue Rahr‘s report on her first two months on the job, plus the confirmation of Amy Smith as permanent Chief of CARE (the department that includes the city’s 911 center as well as a team of crisis responders). Here’s the video:

The meeting lasted two and a half hours, starting with public comment and Chief Smith’s confirmation (which committee members voted 4-0 to recommend to the full Council, which might vote as soon as next Tuesday), until an hour and 20 minutes in. That’s when Chief Rahr began her update (see the slide deck here).

Rahr said she’s been focused on four areas – staffing, technology, accountability, and the department’s “criminal justice partners.” The first, she said, is still “a crisis” – hiring remains “behind where we’d hoped to be”:

She presented an overview of a recent overnight shift citywide to show how those numbers translate operationally (note that the Southwest Precinct, West Seattle and South Park, had six officers that shift, four below what it should have):

She said SPD staffing “is going to be below what we need for the next two to three years,” and she said her recommendations for speeding it up include recruiting and testing changes that would result in a “large pool of candidates” with “shorter processing time.” Overall, Rahr stressed, it’s an “extremely competitive market” since so many other jurisdictions nationwide are aggressively recruiting. But she said “the officers we have are working their hearts out” and thanked the council for being “clear” in its support for law enforcement.

Rahr was first to bring in the detention situation – saying they need “a third option” because some people are “too medically fragile for jail” but also “too dangerous for the emergency room.” Other topics through which she moved included the increase in gunfire-related calls, both without and with injuries:

“There’s so much gunfire, it’s just astounding,” Rahr said. She also noted that she had recently learned about a situation mentioned here before – state law requiring that juveniles have a certain number of gun-related incidents on their record before they can be detained.

Back to the subject of detention in general, City Attorney Ann Davison‘s briefing – with Smith and Rahr flanking her – was billed as the “criminal justice ecosystem” but focused on three “significant obstacles”:

Regarding jailing people for misdemeanors, she said that the current booking restrictions (dating to the pandemic), as well as jail staffing shortages, prevent police from booking suspects in more than half of the misdemeanors in city law.

As a result – the following numbers, which show that 27 years ago, the city had five times the number of misdemeanor suspects in custody, on average, as it does now:

That’s when council president Nelson exclaimed that the city did not seem to be getting what it bargained for – saying that with the city getting far less jail space than it seemed to be paying for, she felt like saying, “I want my money back!”

As mentioned above, shortly after this meeting, the mayor’s office announced that the city is contracting with the SCORE jail in Des Moines – owned by Auburn, Burien, Des Moines, Renton, SeaTac, and Tukwila – to use up to 20 beds. You can read that detailed announcement here. (It’s also worth noting that the city-county agreement has its roots in the city’s scrapped proposal to build its own misdemeanor jail, on which we reported extensively a decade and a half ago, since two proposed sites were in West Seattle – here’s our 2011 story with the jail agreement announcement, mentioning numbers far above what Davison said the county jail is housing for Seattle now.)

As for Davison’s two other “obstacles”: The “chronic hot spots” did not involve anywhere in West Seattle, so we won’t get into that, but the toxicology lab information is of note, since we’ve reported on suspected DUI cases that have taken a long time to get to charges – if they get to that point at all. Davison said the state lab that handles toxicology for DUI is averaging one year to get a report to her office. “I can’t do anything until I get that evidence … this needs to be addressed in an urgent way.” That would be up to state government to fix, she said. (You can see her full slide deck here.)

24 Replies to "'I want my money back!' City Council committee hears about jail-booking crunch and other 'significant obstacles' in public-safety 'ecosystem'; mayor tries to fix one"

  • Anne July 23, 2024 (4:17 pm)

    Are you kidding me?“There’s so much gunfire, it’s just astounding,” Rahr said. She also noted that she had recently learned about a situation mentioned here before – state law requiring that juveniles have a certain number of gun-related incidents on their record before they can be detained.This is a freaking State Law??  Unbelievable! No wonder folks are frustrated at lack of accountability- prosecutions – no wonder LEO are frustrated when dealing with juvenile gun incidents. Looks like the voters in our state have work to do. 

  • Alki resident July 23, 2024 (4:43 pm)

    Start getting stricter with parents by fining them thousands of dollars per crime their child commits. Even go as far as jailing the parents since they won’t jail the kids. This stupidity of ankle bracelets and home detention is a joke and everyone knows it. And that is why you have the juvenile crime, they know nothing will happen to them. Just gross. 

    • WS Res July 23, 2024 (7:55 pm)

      It’s true, kids with incarcerated parents are famously less likely to go on to commit crime themselves.

    • Gaslit July 23, 2024 (9:56 pm)

      So, your solution is suspend all aspects of democracy and start arbitrarily fining and jailing people for crimes they didn’t commit? Got it. 

    • StupidIsStupid July 24, 2024 (1:50 pm)

      I ask this every time, Alki Resident…  Who do you consider the Parent when suggesting asinine penalties like this?  The people listed on the birth certificate?  The friend’s mom who took them in after they were kicked out?  The aunts, uncles, grandparents, or foster parents who stepped up to help when thing started to go wrong at home?  How many stable adults would be willing to take in a youth with behavioral issues in if they faced such steep penalties for having the gall to be a custodial caregiver to a youth who makes bad choices?  Are these kids just supposed to live on the streets when you send their parents to jail for bad parenting?  Or just hope there’s a foster parent who doesn’t mind racking up jail time for trying to help a kid with existing problems?

  • Actually Mike July 23, 2024 (4:54 pm)

    Sara Nelson said it all, and I want my money back too.

  • Person July 23, 2024 (5:17 pm)

    state law requiring that juveniles have a certain number of gun-related incidents on their record before they can be detained.🤯

  • Alki resident July 23, 2024 (6:14 pm)

    This subject only proves that we’ll make room for you if you murder someone kids, but in the meantime just keep up your target practice, you’re good. 

  • Darren July 23, 2024 (7:14 pm)

    Way too lenient/forgiving. Look at what the result is in society for all ages. Way past time to hold people accountable. I feel like it’s a rallying cry lately. I have felt like people have been getting away with all levels of crime for about 14 years. 

  • Kyle July 23, 2024 (8:18 pm)

    This is why we get poor access blocking solutions from other agencies. What a cluster.

  • Seattlite July 23, 2024 (9:40 pm)

    WSBLOG:   Slide 3 has the booking restrictions listed for misdemeanors.   Are the booking restrictions based on misdemeanors and gross misdemeanors?  I think the word quagmire describes the situation SPD finds itself in today.  In my opinion,  the quagmire is self-inflicted due to policies.  Using common sense to create new policies that will end the quagmire is in dire need.  Safety of citizens is the number one job of elected officials.

  • KT July 23, 2024 (10:29 pm)

    So, SPD is down 360 officer from the beginning of 2020 and in the past six months has hired 21 at the same time they lost another 55.  Wow.  And Rahr says SPD staffing “is going to be below what we need for the next two to three years”.  Wanna bet?  

  • Gaslit July 24, 2024 (5:49 am)

    One has to love one member of city government becoming exasperated with the inevitable failure of county government to fulfill and serve contracted needs. What isn’t easy to love is the government offficial thinking she can talk about “her money”. 

    • WS Guy July 24, 2024 (10:32 am)

      She’s symbolically expressing the dismay one would feel as if her own money were wasted.  That’s exactly what we should want.

    • Duwamesque July 24, 2024 (10:41 am)

      ☝️comment is right on the money. Worst council president I can remember.

  • Blame SPD July 24, 2024 (8:25 am)

    The SPD hiring issues- a relative of mine applied (and was qualified) to SPD and SPD declined hiring him. He is now a King County Deputy. Go figure- I’m so glad he is with a different organization that values him. SPD missed out and it’s their own fault so don’t whine about being understaffed!!!!!!!

  • Jort July 24, 2024 (10:38 am)

    Did Sara Nelson mean “our money?” Maybe it was a slip of the tongue? Hmm? “Mine mine mine?”

  • Mel July 24, 2024 (8:18 pm)

    Regarding detaining juveniles until they have multiple gun charges…is that a state law or a filing standard by the prosecutor’s office? I’m not familiar with that state law. I am however familiar with officers not being able to talk to juveniles without legal representation. I follow this pretty closely so I’m wondering if I missed something. 

    • Jort July 24, 2024 (10:23 pm)

      I am ALSO wondering if I missed something, because I have not heard of any state law changes of this nature. I am also familiar with police often blaming legislatures for “tying their hands” when the actual laws do no such thing. So I’d really like to make sure our acting chief is making this assertion with some evidence to support it. Because I am not finding it. Anywhere.

  • Dog Whisperer July 26, 2024 (8:20 am)

    Rob Saka put it best – defund the police was nothing more than a failed social experiment. 

Sorry, comment time is over.