GROCERY MEGA-MERGER: Day after court rulings, Albertsons/Safeway bags the plan

One of the biggest national stories on Tuesday was a pair of court rulings – including one in our state – against the proposed Kroger (QFC, Fred Meyer, etc.)/Albertsons (Safeway) merger. One day later, Albertsons has announced it’s officially canceling the merger. From the company’s announcement:

Albertsons Companies, Inc. today announced it has exercised its right to terminate its merger agreement with Kroger after the U.S. District Court in Oregon and the King County Superior Court for the State of Washington issued injunctions with respect to the proposed merger on December 10, 2024.

Vivek Sankaran, CEO, commented: “Given the recent federal and state court decisions to block our proposed merger with Kroger, we have made the difficult decision to terminate the merger agreement. We are deeply disappointed in the courts’ decisions.”

In a separate announcement, Albertsons announced it’s suing Kroger, with this accusation:

Kroger willfully breached the Merger Agreement in several key ways, including by repeatedly refusing to divest assets necessary for antitrust approval, ignoring regulators’ feedback, rejecting stronger divestiture buyers and failing to cooperate with Albertsons.

In its own announcement, Kroger says the lawsuit is “baseless and without merit.”

If the merger had gone through, three West Seattle grocery stores were slated for divestiture to a third entity, as reported here in JulyAdmiral Safeway and both QFCs (Westwood Village and West Seattle Junction). The mega-merger plan was first announced more than two years ago.

27 Replies to "GROCERY MEGA-MERGER: Day after court rulings, Albertsons/Safeway bags the plan"

  • Marcus December 11, 2024 (11:41 am)

    Good!

  • Joan December 11, 2024 (11:49 am)

    This is  good news for us. Who would shop at Albertsons?  I went in one once in Burien and the prices were ridiculous.  So many other options.  Fred Meyer is great, I don’t mind QFC either. But I love our PCC and TJs the most.

    • West Seattle Mad Sci Guy December 11, 2024 (12:31 pm)

      You probably know this, but just in case – Albertsons owns Safeway.  Folks in West Seattle were primarily worried about QFC and Safeway becoming one (and that several of the west seattle Safeway and QFCs were supposed to be sold off as part of the agreement, and the buying 3rd party grocery store was under no obligation to keep the sold off locations open).  I think the 3rd party was the owner of the brand piggly wiggly? (An east coast chain, I think)

    • Brian December 11, 2024 (12:40 pm)

      Fred Meyer and QFC are both owned by Kroger. 

  • Jen December 11, 2024 (11:57 am)

    This is GREAT news!

  • JayDee December 11, 2024 (12:04 pm)

    The proposed merger between Kroger and Albertsons didn’t pass the straight face test. Back in 2015 Albertsons essentially sunk Haggens after that chain couldn’t digest the divestiture stores it inherited from Albertsons. Haggens went bankrupt and eventually became part of the greater Albertsons brand family. 

    The idea that C&S Grocers that currently operates 32 grocery stores, could somehow manage to successfully integrate 579 newly divested stores across multiple states was ludicrous idea given the failure of Haggens to accomplish a similar but much smaller attempt.

    And lastly, while it could be argued that West Seattle has too many grocery stores (not to mention stores in our neighbor Burien), having a number of them being turned into C&S stores would’ve been a disaster for our communities. 

    • Gibby December 11, 2024 (3:16 pm)

      Exactly this. I was living in Southern California at the time of this happening and I remember some of the Vons stores turning into Haggens and then not long after they were back to Vons. Apparently Albertsons sold them to Haggens at a certain price and bought them back for less when Haggens went bankrupt. Wild. There’s no way that that wouldn’t have happened again with this merger. So glad that it’s been blocked.

    • Adam December 11, 2024 (8:47 pm)

      It’s still no reason to yell, JayDee

      • WiseWoman December 16, 2024 (10:20 am)

        Probably a transfer from notes app large print bc you cannot change it

  • West Seattle Mad Sci Guy December 11, 2024 (12:32 pm)

    So happy about this.  A victory for the consumer for sure. 

  • Richard December 11, 2024 (12:38 pm)

    As an eighteen year veteran of the grocery industry, this merger would’ve been disastrous not only for our area but also regionally and nationally.

    It would’ve opened the doors (pun intended) to increased price gouging, longer checkout lines, less employable staff, less product availability, weaker safety/cleanliness issues and an abundance on poor overall satisfaction.

    This is not only a HUGE win for the industry but the staff and customers as a whole. I’m glad this merger is dead and that Kroger Inc’s wanting disregard for their employee/customer base is also dead. 

  • Watertowerjim December 11, 2024 (12:57 pm)

    So, they won’t get the scale they need to compete with the Costco, Targets and Wal-Marts of the world. This is NOT good news for the consumer.

    • Bbron December 11, 2024 (2:19 pm)

      Myopic take. You really want less and bigger companies? So they have even more price fixing power to gouge us like what happened during the pandemic and after…

      • The King December 11, 2024 (6:01 pm)

        Like government monopolies on electricity, water, garbage or ferry passenger services. You can’t even cancel garbage due to laws the government has passed. Voters want natural gas as a choice based on I-2066 yet Inslee wants to challenge it in court to take that option away. Late 90’s an entrepreneur in Tacoma tried to establish a passenger boat shuttle service to Seattle but was met with every roadblock the state could throw at him. Apparently government monopolies good, private bad. 

      • Watertowerjim December 12, 2024 (2:29 pm)

        Grocery store margins have been flat for decades.  It is a lie that they increased margins during covid.

        Higher wholesale = higher retail.

        Lower wholesale (via scale) = lower retail

  • brewcity December 11, 2024 (1:12 pm)

    Nice bag pun headline. Gave me a chuckle     

  • SuperShopper December 11, 2024 (1:18 pm)

    This is good news. I track pricing pretty closely between Safeway and QFC/Fred Meyer, and while of course everything has become more expensive everywhere, Safeway’s prices have really jumped in the last year or so and I find it harder and harder to find good deals there. There’ll be a good coupon here and there at Safeway but overall I can get much better pricing on dinner items at QFC with their promos such as “Buy 5 Items, Save $2 on Each.” My sister shops at Safeway quite a bit and I tell her she’d be much better off shopping at Costco if she doesn’t want to bother hunting for deals. Costco can be beat pricing-wise sometimes but if you’re busy and don’t want to put the work in to shop the sales locally, it’s the best option for a busy family. Safeway’s everyday shelf prices are a rip-off now. At Winco they’ll post competitor’s pricing in-store for customers to compare, and I noticed Safeway is often the highest listed. It’ll be interesting to see if Safeway’s prices remain the same after the dust settles. (And it’s sorta hilarious that they’re suing Kroger now.)

    • GHO December 11, 2024 (3:41 pm)

      I also consider myself a “supershopper” and I have the exact opposite view/experience, ESPECIALLY with the vastly different rewards program (Safeway offering not just gas discounts, but grocery as well). I rarely shop for much at QFC anymore, mostly loss-leader items, some sales. I compare prices, so am thrilled that we won’t lose two options (Safeway & QFC) to one (Piggly Wiggly).

      • Ken December 11, 2024 (5:18 pm)

        @ GHO, I feel the same. Typically shop at Safeway because of their rewards program. Before and shortly after Kroger’s acquisition of Fred Meyer and QFC, I was a relatively frequent shopper of both chains. Slowly, but surely however, both of them have declined significantly in the form of higher prices and less selection. Incredibly happy the merger was blocked. No desire whatsoever to shop at or support anything related to Kroger. 

  • Rhonda December 11, 2024 (1:32 pm)

    Consumers dodged a nuclear missile. The disastrous Bartells/Rite Aid merger would’ve looked like Disneyland compared to this poop sandwich. Food deserts actually lead to obesity and ill health as affected residents are forced to live off of junk food from convenience stores, mini marts, fast food, etc.

  • Kt December 11, 2024 (2:06 pm)

    So happy for the employees.  They work so hard to keep us fed.  The pandemic showed how vital they are to our very existence 

  • anonyme December 11, 2024 (4:34 pm)

    This dragged on for far too long, but ended with the right conclusion.  I’m not sure what’s going on with Albertson’s (have never shopped there) but their lawsuit is an absurd way of dragging out a losing battle.

  • bolo December 11, 2024 (8:19 pm)

    Pretty sure they’ll try again, under a more corp-friendly political environment.

    • WS Guy December 12, 2024 (11:57 am)

      Doubt it.  It’s a bad breakup.  They are both suing each other.

      • bolo December 14, 2024 (11:44 am)

        Poor planning. Next time they’ll know to include an arbitration clause into their contract.

  • 1994 December 11, 2024 (9:56 pm)

    Shout out to King County Superior Court judge Marshall Ferguson! Thanks for ruling with common sense.

  • flimflam December 12, 2024 (6:49 am)

    Seems like the only way to really save $ at grocery stores now is to use their apps which they then turn around and sell your data from. Awesome…The new Safeway in Upper Queen Anne is more expensive than Met Market for crying out loud.

Sorry, comment time is over.