FOLLOWUP: More than a year after car-into-water Alki crash, allegedly speeding, drunk driver is charged

(Reader photo, July 16, 2023, 1300 block Alki Avenue)

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

One year and three months after an Alki crash that left a woman fighting for her life after bystanders pulled her from her submerged car, we’ve learned that the driver accused of hitting her is charged.

We discovered during a routine periodic check of online court files that the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has filed three charges against Angel I. Godoy Cruz, now 24 – vehicular assault (a Class B felony), reckless driving (a gross misdemeanor), and “no valid operator’s license” (a misdemeanor).

Here’s how the charging document summarizes the allegations:

On Sunday, July 13, 2023, at approximately 5:46 p.m., the defendant, 23-year-old Angel Godoy Cruz, an unlicensed driver with suspended driver’s license privileges, was speeding on northbound Alki Ave SW in a 2011 Infiniti G37 sedan, traveling at approximately 83 miles per hour in a 25 mph zone along Alki Beach. Alki Ave SW is a two-way arterial street consisting of one northbound lane and one southbound lane, with the lanes separated by a single dashed yellow line. The defendant then weaved around a vehicle by traveling into the southbound lane and back into the northbound lane.

At the same time, 24-year-old Madison Kelly was driving southbound in a 2005 Toyota Corolla and began to make a left turn from Alki Ave SW into a parking lot. Less than two seconds into her turn, the defendant crashed into Kelly’s vehicle at approximately 83 mph, causing the Toyota to roll northbound and fall into Elliott Bay. It is only because of the heroic efforts of witnesses who jumped into the bay to rescue Kelly from her submerged vehicle by cracking a car window open with a rock that she survived the collision. Witnesses then performed CPR on Kelly until medics arrived, who transported her to Harborview unconscious and in critical condition, suffering from extensive traumatic brain injuries and internal injuries.

As people gathered to perform life-saving efforts on Kelly, the defendant exited his vehicle. One witness confronted the defendant and stated that the defendant would be going to jail. According to the witness, the defendant replied, “Why would I be going to jail?” to which the witness responded that he may have killed the driver. The defendant then stated, “I don’t give a s–t,” and went back into his car. Law enforcement then contacted the defendant and observed a strong odor of intoxicants from the defendant’s person and observed an open can of IPA beer in plain view on the rear floorboard of the vehicle. After being read his Miranda rights, the defendant claimed the beer was from several days prior and that he had not drank alcohol that day but admitted to consuming marijuana that morning. He admitted to driving around the first vehicle because “it was going slow” and admitted that the speed limit for the area was 25 MPH. A search warrant was issued authorizing a blood draw for the defendant’s blood to determine his BAC. The toxicology report determined the defendant’s BAC was .011 three hours and 14 minutes after the collision, well above the per-se legal limit. …

Notably, the defendant has never possessed a valid driver’s license, but has a history of repeated disregard for traffic safety laws: Speeding, No Valid Operating License (08/31/2022), Expired License (06/20/2022), Vehicle Plates Expired (02/28/2019), Speed Too Fast for Road Conditions, Expired License, Vehicle Plates Expired (11/20/2015)

According to the documents, police submitted the case to the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office this past August; the charges were filed four weeks later, on September 20, with a request for $150,000 bail. However, when Godoy Cruz appeared for arraignment on October 3, Judge David Keenan set bail at $25,000, with electronic home monitoring as a condition, and gave him a week on personal recognizance to post bond. Godoy Cruz is required to do that, and to start electronic home monitoring, by the end of the day tomorrow (Thursday, October 10). If he fails to do so, prosecutors can seek an arrest warrant. (He had a North Seattle address at the time of the crash but has told the court he is now living in West Seattle. After the crash, he was taken to the hospital, rather than jail, because of injuries.)

We asked the KCPAO why the case took so long to file. Spokesperson Casey McNerthney confirmed that they received it four weeks before filing it, which was 13 months after the crash (we will be following up separately with SPD); those four weeks were spent reviewing the evidence, which, the office says, included a lot of video. (The court documents indicate that’s part of how they determined the 83 mph speed.)

As for the victim, we have sent inquiries to family/friends multiple times since the crash to ask how Ms. Kelly is doing, but have not received a reply. Regional TV reports said she was out of the hospital and inpatient rehab and back home two months after the crash.

THURSDAY UPDATE: Godoy Cruz did report for the home-monitoring placement, according to Department of Adult Detention records.

49 Replies to "FOLLOWUP: More than a year after car-into-water Alki crash, allegedly speeding, drunk driver is charged"

  • flimflam October 9, 2024 (1:33 pm)

    Wow. First of all, what a bad human this guy is. Second, I still don’t understand why this took so long to file charges.

    • Dog Whisperer October 9, 2024 (4:58 pm)

      The police are shorthanded. Perhaps that’s part of the problem. The city attorney cannot act until they have all the evidence from the police. 

      • 1994 October 9, 2024 (9:45 pm)

        Dog Whisperer – the article does not say city attorney filed the charges…..read above which legal office filed charges:  the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has filed three charges against Angel I. Godoy Cruz

    • Rod October 10, 2024 (7:15 am)

      Hopefully, some action is in process to sue for the pain & suffering she is encountering

  • SeattleSteve October 9, 2024 (1:45 pm)

    Hope they lock him up for a long long time. Need to set standards for how to wreckless drivers like this guy, and sounds like he has no remorse for what he did.

    • Ferns October 9, 2024 (5:28 pm)

      Exactly. We need ZERO  of these *-holes on the street ruining the lives of others, remorseless, repeatedly offending. 

  • EVGuy October 9, 2024 (1:58 pm)

    Next time Judge David Keenan is up for a vote, vote his butt out. No more kids gloves for these crazy criminals. 

    • Dog Whisperer October 9, 2024 (5:01 pm)

      For a first time offender leniency might be considered. A repeat offender with his track record of disregard should be kept away from society. 

      • onion October 9, 2024 (5:52 pm)

        Just as the police department is understaffed, perhaps the prosecutors office, judges staffs, and jails are understaffed as well. And the jails are overcrowded, so judges have to make some really difficult choices on who to lock up while they await trial. We may not like ‘lenient” handling such as this individual is receiving, but I suspect that’s the uncomfortable type of decision a judge needs to make every day.  Food for thought before calling for the judge to be tossed out of office. The next guy might end up making the same types of calls.

        • Clay October 10, 2024 (7:39 pm)

          a crowded, uncomfortable jail is probably just what this guy needs.

    • Marie 47 October 9, 2024 (5:26 pm)

      Absolutely! I’m going to start writing the names of judges when aware. The avg person doesn’t know who to vote out when we’re not in the know! 

      • Plf October 9, 2024 (8:46 pm)

        Here is the challenge, often these judges have no one running against them so win by default that has been my experience when tracking their performance, no one to vote for

  • PDiddy October 9, 2024 (2:00 pm)

    Finally!

  • Clay October 9, 2024 (2:03 pm)

    I cannot believe this unlicensed, intoxicated, extremely uncaring, reckless driver who caused a critical condition accident is not in a Federal Prison by now.  “He’s supposed to get a call to get a bracelet tomorrow”?  “His bail was reduced to $25,000”?  “They don’t know exactly where the offender is living but was told he lives in West Seattle”? What’s the world coming to? We live in a very dangerous city with no criminal prosecution or protection —  over and over again.

    • WSB October 9, 2024 (2:51 pm)

      Hi, just to be clear, I did not write that they don’t know where he’s living. The address was provided to the court. I only mention that he was a North Seattle resident at the time, West Seattle resident now, because people often ask, especially in Alki incidents – TR

  • JO October 9, 2024 (2:14 pm)

    what a joke these “judges” are oin Seattle. This unlicensed drunk driver should be ion JAIL, NO bond. Judge David Keenan – does not care about citiozens in his country. Need to step down now.

  • DenDen October 9, 2024 (2:31 pm)

    The judge is up for re-election. His term is up January 13, 2025. Let’s keep this in mind. Totaly crazy stuff!
    https://ballotpedia.org/David_Keenan

    • Clay October 9, 2024 (3:06 pm)

      Please, let’s not vote for this judge again.  I will vote for his competition no matter what.

      • Plf October 10, 2024 (11:27 am)

        Often there is no one running against these judges so they are elected by default 

    • Clay October 9, 2024 (3:11 pm)

      Yes, let’s vote for another judge, not David Keenan.   Please tell all your neighbors how this criminal was treated so lightly!

      • Del Griffith October 9, 2024 (4:28 pm)

        You all understand the difference between an arraignment and a sentencing, as well as the criteria judges have to use for each right? These posts calling for the judge to lose next election suggest a lot of confusion. Also, I’m pretty sure Keenan is running unopposed, so best of luck with the effort!

    • anonyme October 9, 2024 (3:39 pm)

      Unfortunately, most judges run unopposed.  We need a better way to hold them accountable, as voting them out is an ineffective option – if an option at all.  I would also add that we have to start getting tough on unlicensed, uninsured drivers, as well as vehicles without plates.   As for the POS in this case, he should be in jail now, and prison later.

  • Justducky October 9, 2024 (2:52 pm)

    Do you have any updates on the man that murdered Leticia? I thought his case was supposed to go to trial this year. 

    • WSB October 9, 2024 (5:45 pm)

      Murder cases often take a long time to get to trial (or plea bargain). This one’s winding its way through the system, next scheduled hearing in early November.

  • DenDen October 9, 2024 (3:35 pm)

    Mr Keenens email is keenan.court@kingcounty.govI asked him what was his reasoning was. I will waite with bated breath for a replay. I sugest you all send him a note as well. 

  • ITotallyAgreeWithYou October 9, 2024 (4:22 pm)

    Sounds like a lot of trolling to push an agenda to try and influence voting, which I’ve seen in many crime report comment sections here.  Seize the moment to push a political agenda. There is nothing “totally crazy” in the ballotpedia link, Denden themselves shared. Just a judge who won over his opponent in the 2016 election overwhelmingly (76.25%) and endorsements from officials elected many times over themselves and other progressives. So crazy! Part of Judge Keenan’s statement in that election: “I’m grateful for broad, bipartisan endorsements, including from the entire Washington State Supreme Court, former Governor and Attorney General Christine Gregoire, Attorney General Bob Ferguson, former Attorney General Rob McKenna, King County Executive Dow Constantine, Sheriff John Urquhart, Seattle Mayor Ed Murray, and over 60 judges and elected officials.I’m also honored with numerous community endorsements, including the King County Labor Council, King County Democrats, and many others.”

    • Anne October 9, 2024 (6:01 pm)

      Exactly-look at who endorsed him- -those names alone would be enough for me to NOT vote for him. Yes-let’s definitely make his  decisions public to -educate-not “influence” -there’s a difference . ‘Don’t most look at a candidates record -if not they should.Its not pushing a political agenda -it’s called being an informed voter. We should all know who we’re voting for-looking at a judges record  &  sharing it is imperative. 

  • ColumbiaChris October 9, 2024 (4:53 pm)

    So why did Kevin Dave, the SPD officer who ran down and killed a woman while doing 74 in a 25mph zone, get off scot-free? He was also driving on a suspended license.

    • WiseWoman October 11, 2024 (2:12 pm)

      A cop driving on a suspended license should definitely pay more to the family. SPD administration always sucked.

  • Joan October 9, 2024 (5:09 pm)

    Ridiculous that his bail was reduced and this guy needs to be in jajl for life. I will definitely vote this judge out.

  • Jim October 9, 2024 (5:49 pm)

    Inexcusable that he’s been walking around free all this time

  • K October 9, 2024 (5:50 pm)

    Bail is not a punishment.  It is a cash surety to make sure someone shows up for court.  The dollar amount’s impact has more to do with the financial means of the person than anything else.

    • Del Griffith October 9, 2024 (10:54 pm)

      This person gets it. Anyone who knows anything about our King County courts knows Keenan is a solid judge. 

  • Purple Pilot October 9, 2024 (6:37 pm)

    What kind of dysfunctional civilization would allow this individual to live amongst society  for more than a year without facing consequences?  

  • Insertname October 9, 2024 (6:56 pm)

    Remember the name: Angel I. Godoy Cruz. I guarantee this clown reoffends in no time. It continues to blow my mind how these individuals never face any real justice. I understand the judicial process takes time. And that there is a lot involved when building/trying a case. But there is clearly enough evidence against this guy to punish him to the fullest extent of the law. I hope the poor gal this guy hit has recovered. 

  • WSzombie October 9, 2024 (9:38 pm)

    I wonder how many times this guy has driven drunk since this has happened. I’m fairly confident the number is not zero. 

    • anonyme October 10, 2024 (6:01 am)

      You’re right, and he’s probably still driving without a license, and speeding as well.  Wish we had a photo of this guy so we could show him just how welcome he and his ilk are in West Seattle.

  • Runner October 10, 2024 (7:24 am)

    I saw this accident and the amazing life saving rescue of the young woman. This whole thing is so tragic and never should have happened. Unfortunately I see reckless driving, and speeding every single day on Alki, and a lot of the time it’s the same vehicles. If we don’t punish the offenders, and have support from the city to address these issues, something like this will happen again. This is a well known serious problem that puts every person driving, walking, jogging, biking, etc. along Alki at risk! Come on Seattle government do something!

  • Wallace Grommet October 10, 2024 (2:09 pm)

    Until Washington joins the 21st century, and imposes a progressive income tax, prisons will be grossly overcrowded, and excessively dangerous for corrections officers.  

  • Beachdriver October 10, 2024 (2:14 pm)

    Small point, but I’m curious if the stated BAC of .011 is a typo. Per-se limit is .08. Three hours later the BAC would drop by around .015 per hour. Anyway the individual’s BAC was likely twice the legal limit at the time of the crime (not calling it an “accident”). 

    • WSB October 10, 2024 (2:24 pm)

      Yes, it’s a typo. This is a cut and paste from court documents, and sometimes they have typos.

      • Bobby Jo October 10, 2024 (6:29 pm)

        I was told by someone from the mayors office  that the ridiculously long delay was due to the fact that only state sanctioned labs could process the blood alcohol level and they were backed up by 900 DWI cases!She went on to say that our state legislatures are out of touch with what’s going on in Seattle and we need new representation. They make these laws that govern us in Seattle.

  • WSEnvironmentalist October 10, 2024 (6:31 pm)

    Traffic cameras are needed on Harbor Ave SW and Alki.  Speeders and drunk drivers know they can get away with endangering lives for a racing high because SPD is so understaffed that there is little to no police presence.  City Council and police staff should use unmarked cars and park in the area with speed cameras and decibel monitors to witness what we residents suffer through night after night and sometimes in broad (or rainy) day light. 

    • TAnderson October 11, 2024 (12:56 pm)

      Three Thumbs Up!!!

  • Ws prayers October 10, 2024 (8:42 pm)

    I moved to lake forest park for these reasons. There are cameras and police legit pull people over all the time. The community won’t tolerate criminal behavior of any kind it’s different vibe when community and  police prescence sets expectations and standards. Kenmore and bothel too. Period.

  • Kat October 15, 2024 (12:45 am)

    Thank you, WSB, for following up on this. 

  • Mom October 16, 2024 (5:30 pm)

    I am Madison’s mom and I wanted to share that in the greater scheme of things, she is doing ok, however, her life will NEVER be the same.  She continues to fight to improve each day and I ask for continued prayers, support and privacy for her.   I cannot express the overwhelming frustrations of the injustice we experience each day, including what insurance will or will not cover.  I ask if anyone can make a change to our health care, social services and justice system; please help because I would never wish this upon anyone.  The after care is just as hard. I do want to thank the West Seattle Blog community for providing an update on this case.

    • WSB October 16, 2024 (5:49 pm)

      Thank you so much for the update. Many of our readers asked for updates over the months. Wishing strength to you both. – Tracy (editor)

      • Mom October 25, 2024 (5:02 pm)

        Thank you for providing an update to the story.  We have struggled with when and how to provide updates, yet still provide Madison some privacy thru her healing journey.  Keep up the great work in the community and staying on top of this horrific incident.

Sorry, comment time is over.