CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: ‘More to this story’ after flipped-car crash

(Reader photo from Monday, sent by Marie)

Two days ago, that flipped-car crash on California south of Brandon injured the driver. He was taken to a hospital, the scene eventually cleared, and we thought that was the end of it. But a commenter revealed last night that there’s “more to this story” – that the car was stolen. Neighbors say it was taken early Sunday, from a neighborhood near Fairmount Ravine, with another apparently stolen car left in its place. So we followed up with police, who said that after medical treatment, the 31-year-old man had been booked into jail for investigation of stolen-vehicle possession, stolen-gun possession, and unlawful gun possession. We don’t know anything about the gun, but we found out that the suspect could not lawfully possess one because he’s a convicted felon. Documents from his most recent conviction, in 2019, cited an “extensive criminal history”; that case involved a West Seattle burglary, and he eventually was sentenced to six years in prison – with credit for eight months served before sentencing. He got out of prison last December; records show this was his first jail booking since then. “Was,” we say, because after two days, he was released about an hour and a half ago. Among the various authorities we contacted today was the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office, which did not file charges by today’s deadline, so the law required his release. KCPAO spokesperson Casey McNerthney told us late today that they didn’t charge him because they couldn’t:

The information that was sent to us from police investigators was not legally sufficient to file charges, so the prosecutor handling the case wrote a detailed note to the investigating detective explaining what is needed for a legally sufficient case under state law. This is not a judgement on Seattle Police – we appreciate their continued work – it’s addressing what prosecutors can and cannot do under the law with the available evidence. It’s certainly possible that the additional elements are sent to us by the investigating Seattle Police detective for a charging decision.

In the meantime, the suspect is out of custody, for now. And the stolen, flipped car sits in an impound lot – its owner sent this photo:

They found some items that aren’t theirs inside and say they ;vehad trouble reaching police to deal with that. Meantime, personal items of theirs turned up inside the car – a blue Chevy Blazer – dumped nearby after theirs was taken.

48 Replies to "CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: 'More to this story' after flipped-car crash"

  • Yacman August 28, 2024 (10:13 pm)

    This sentence is nonsensical: “ It’s certainly possible that the additional elements are sent to us by the investigating Seattle Police detective for a charging decision.”I still don’t understand why he wasn’t charged.

    • WSB August 28, 2024 (10:55 pm)

      Translation: This doesn’t mean he’ll never be charged, if they get whatever information/evidence was missing in what they originally received.
      I’ve reported on cases where the defendant wasn’t charged by the rush-file deadline but was charged as soon as one day later. Or, it could be months later.

  • Guy August 28, 2024 (10:25 pm)

    The saggy sweatpants was a dead giveaway, extra shame points for what looked like a mint condition vehicle. 

    • CAM August 29, 2024 (3:53 pm)

      No

  • Insertname August 28, 2024 (10:34 pm)

    Jeez, already out because of course he is. What must a person do in order to face the consequences for their crimes? Apparently a convicted felon flipping a stolen vehicle while in the possession of firearms warrants no further punishment. These individuals prove time and time again that they’re unwilling to abide by the rules. And time and time again they’re released. I’m curious to see how long before this one reoffends. The judicial system is in need of a serious overhaul. Enough is enough already. 

    • WS Res August 29, 2024 (10:23 am)

      Instead of blaming “the judicial system,” maybe you want to lay the blame at the feet of the police who failed to transmit enough evidence to charge him in a timely way?

      • Al King August 29, 2024 (12:18 pm)

        WSRes. So SPD is solely to blame?? Educate us with facts please.

        • WS Res August 29, 2024 (1:53 pm)

          What, you can’t read the article yourself?”The information that was sent to us from police investigators was not legally sufficient to file charges, so the prosecutor handling the case wrote a detailed note to the investigating detective explaining what is needed for a legally sufficient case under state law.”

        • K August 29, 2024 (1:59 pm)

          You are perfectly capable of Googling state laws as well, you know.  Commenters here don’t owe you anything, just because you’re demanding it.  The legislature makes the laws.  If don’t think police should need to do investigations and turn over evidence to detain someone, talk to the legislature about that.  Until the law changes, yes, it was the police that dropped the ball here.

          • Desperately Seeking Saka August 29, 2024 (3:06 pm)

            K, try reading the entire article next time:“This is not a judgement on Seattle Police – we appreciate their continued work “

  • Alki resident August 28, 2024 (10:42 pm)

    Courts won’t keep him locked up until he kills someone. And as usual, his name is being withheld. 

    • Hipo August 29, 2024 (7:40 am)

      The official politeness aside, it sounds a lot like they wouldn’t have let him go if the cops had sent in the proper evidence to allow charges to be filed. Which is their job. Holding and charging people without evidence just opens the door to abuse, and in any case wastes funds on cases that will get tossed out. 

  • Dog Whisperer August 28, 2024 (11:20 pm)

    It might be time to do something. 

    • rme August 29, 2024 (9:00 pm)

      What on earth is that supposed to mean?

  • BDJ August 29, 2024 (2:10 am)

    Many people are frustrated by the catch and release program for criminals. If we want to change the current program we need to bombard every King County Council person and let them know how you feel about people not being detained or the do no jail time. I can’t imagine how many millions of dollars have been spent by owners of stolen cars in Seattle. Many of them get stuck with a $300 towing bill when their destroyed car gets towed away from where the suspect left it or crashed it. Then there is the insurance claims to deal with. Shopping for a replacement vehicle. If you are fed up with this happening, contact King County Council and Dow Constinten 

    • K August 29, 2024 (6:20 pm)

      King County Council did not write the laws requiring evidence to be present to detain someone past 72 hours.  That’s the state legislature.  Please do not bother your County Councilmembers with complaints about state laws.  Please instead complain to the City Council that the police are not doing their jobs.

      • Canton August 30, 2024 (12:15 am)

        “Please don’t bother your county council members”…?? They have a public facing job. Their job IS to handle the communities concerns.

        • K August 30, 2024 (8:30 am)

          About state laws?  What other concerns should we bring to them?  Frustrations with federal tax code?  International copyright law?  That lady that keeps parking in front of my driveway?  The lines at Costco?  The County Council’s job is to address county-level concerns.  Basic civics, you take the problems to the people who are in charge of that issue, which is not the county council in the case of state laws.  

        • CAM August 30, 2024 (1:22 pm)

          Please address all concerns about this person not being held without being charged to James Madison (that tricky 5th amendment!) and the Supreme Court (in the days before they took tips for favorable rulings). Those are the basis for the 72 hour rule, it’s codified in state law but that doesn’t mean it’s something that is optional in other states. 

  • Admiral Redbeard August 29, 2024 (2:17 am)

    I’m flabbergasted that this criminal wasn’t charged right away.  I mean, I’ve read these words before on this very blog, but this case is just so blatant.  In possession of a stolen vehicle.  In possession of a firearm as a convicted felon.  How can those immediately established facts not be immediately charged?!  What is the investigating detective even doing?!

  • Mellow Kitty August 29, 2024 (5:30 am)

    Not even an ankle monitor. Well done courts; he’ll be stealing more cars in no time. Well done indeed. 😡

    • CAM August 29, 2024 (3:51 pm)

      Ankle monitors for all citizens not currently charged with crimes! I demand it for safety!

      • Mellow Kitty August 30, 2024 (6:44 am)

        Yeah. This convicted felon with a long criminal history is just a misunderstood citizen. He just happened to be in a stolen car. Wrong place ,wrong time I guess. So he’s a car thief. Who cares. Just let him alone; I’m sure he’ll never break the law again. 

  • Runner August 29, 2024 (5:57 am)

    So disturbing. How are we supposed to feel safe anymore when a person like this is just allowed back on the streets? 

  • Concerned Admiral Resident August 29, 2024 (7:51 am)

    What evidence could be missing?  He was found injured in the flipped car he stole!Is there a way to find out what evidence is missing that is preventing him from being charged?

    • flimflam August 29, 2024 (6:52 pm)

      Seriously, that’s some pretty self explanatory evidence right there. Oh well, I’m sure there will be plenty of opportunities to arrest him in the future when he keeps committing crimes. Hopefully he doesn’t hurt anyone…

  • KellyM August 29, 2024 (8:09 am)

    No doubt he’s already stolen one or more vehicles and acquired one or more guns to go on his merry life of crime.

    • Eric1 August 29, 2024 (10:13 am)

      Kelly don’t scare people with the negative vibes.  He  didn’t know that the last car he was driving was stolen.  He bought the car from a guy named John for $200. I am sure he learned a lesson and is checking at a dealership for a clean title vehicle this time. We should all be safe, no way he acquired a gun yet.  It hasn’t been 10 working days for the waiting period.  Oh, wait, even better, he can’t pass the background check. I almost forgot that he is a felon. See I made people feel better with sarcasm. 

  • Eldorado August 29, 2024 (8:36 am)

    Lock these people up!!! Hundred bucks says we will be reading about this dude doing something stupid in the near future. 

  • snowskier August 29, 2024 (11:39 am)

    Maybe next time it won’t just be the car that he seriously injures.  Come on detective, get that evidence over so this guy can be put back where he belongs for a much longer period of time.

  • anonyme August 29, 2024 (12:19 pm)

    Regardless of who is to blame, the fact is that a career criminal is back on the street.  It seems like there should have been enough evidence for at least one charge to be filed – like a felon in possession of a firearm, or a parole violation -so that he would remain in jail until more charges could be fleshed out.  Once again, a gun violation with no consequences. Wish we had a picture of his face so that citizens could be on the lookout.  It would also be great if we could set up either a pillory or stocks in the Junction for these low lives; maybe they could be placed by the bus benches that are currently being used by heroin smokers.

    • Lagartija Nick August 29, 2024 (5:56 pm)

      Why stop at pillories and stocks, we could just go straight for public hangings! Though I’m not sure that even that would quell some of the blood lust exhibited in these comments.

      • anonyme August 30, 2024 (7:00 am)

        Actually, Nick, you’re the one advocating violence, not me, not other commenters.  I see no hyperbolic “blood lust” in any of these comments.  I simply and half-jokingly suggested public shaming as a deterrent, which made the bat cave in your head explode.   One thing is certain: our justice system is broken, and a lot of people are worried and frustrated with the fallout.

    • Bbron August 30, 2024 (10:24 am)

      this is such an unhinged take. if you’re hungering to humiliate and ostracize a person, all you’re saying is you want to do everything up to killing them. you support punitive punishment only and balk at the idea of trying to rehabilitate people because there ain’t no way you rehabilitate a person after keeping them in freaking stocks. blood lust mentality.

  • gatewood88 August 29, 2024 (1:27 pm)

    Wow. any chance that WSB could follow up with the Seattle Police Department to find out what’s going on with this case and if their detective plans on providing the detailed information the prosector has requested so this man can be charged?  this guy is clearly a danger to society- both the gun and his driving and he needs to be off the streets. I happened to come upon this crash right after it happened-and could tell that something was “off” as soon as he escaped the car.  He could’ve really hurt someone- next time he probably will. 

  • wscommuter August 29, 2024 (1:35 pm)

    Folks should understand that the reason why charges have not – YET – been filed has nothing to do with either the police or KCPO or a judge not thinking this is serious.  It is logistics.  Every day – 365 days a year – police arrest people and send the file to KCPO for consideration of filing charges.  Put simply, there are so many felony arrests daily that it is not possible to file charges in every felony submitted within the initial 72-hour detention period.  The worst offenses (serious assaults, sex crimes, homicides, and such) do get that attention and those folks get charged and held.  The rest – including stolen cars, shoplifting, minor drug offenses, property crimes, etc. get triaged – charges are filed when KCPO is able to get to them.  People have to understand that KCPO has about 7-8 prosecutors assigned to file felony charges on a daily basis – because the rest are in court handling those filed felony cases.  It takes about 1-2 hours to process a police report on a simple felony case (stolen car,  etc.); more complicated crimes may take all day just to prepare one case.  This means there’s only so many cases that can be reviewed and prepared for charging each day.  If that truth is unsatisfactory, don’t blame police, KCPO or judges … tell your elected leaders to increase funding for KCPO so that more cases can be processed more quickly.   This particular case, like so many others that people vent about on this blog, is not particularly remarkable – so it will be processed in due course and likely this knucklehead will get charged down the road.  I understand the frustration with justice being delayed, but do understand the reason why.  

    • Admiral Redbeard August 29, 2024 (3:09 pm)

      Reading between the lines of the KCPO’s statement yesterday, it sounds like the investigating detective didn’t provide the correct evidence to the prosecutor’s office.  The statement from the prosecutor’s office was trying to be gentle by not publicly shaming the police, but it points the finger to that.

      There are two extremely clear, big crimes that can be ascertained within minutes at the scene of the red Subaru crash:  Person in possession of a stolen vehicle.  Convicted felon in possession of a firearm.  The police did ascertain that, which is why the driver was arrested.  But there’s not much excuse for the car thief not to also be charged right away by the prosecutor’s office for those two serious crimes.

      Is there some logistical reason it’s not straightforward for the police to provide the necessary evidence for those two obvious crimes within a matter of only a few hours to the prosecutor’s office?  Shouldn’t the basic initial filing of charges be nearly automated after establishing that a convicted felon was in possession of a stolen car and a firearm?

      I understand that those crimes you list (serious assaults, sex crimes, homicides) are generally considered even more serious, but even despite the known issues of staffing shortages, there is something else broken in the system for this perpetrator to not be charged yet.

      • wscommuter August 30, 2024 (2:58 pm)

        Re your question about charging being “nearly automated”, you still miss the point, with all respect.  KCPO is handling felony cases referred daily from every police agency in King County.  Not just City of Seattle and KC Sheriff’s Office, but every municipality from Bellevue to Kent to Shoreline, and so on.  I’m years removed from this, but routinely, one can see 80-100 felony referrals daily.  This particular stolen car/illegal possession of a gun is quite unremarkable in the context of all the other felonies that occur on a daily basis in a county with a couple million people living in it.  We read this particular  story on the blog – we’re all irritated at this knucklehead – but that doesn’t put his case at the top of the file.  It’s first in-first out.  A similar stolen car/illegal possession of a gun case that happened three weeks ago in Federal Way or Kirkland is just as important as this case – but it will get filed before this one because it further in the queue to be reviewed and filed.  There isn’t someone to review every filing each day and pull out the easy ones.  Just doesn’t work that way.  

    • anonyme August 29, 2024 (3:31 pm)

      Thank you, WS Commuter.  Your explanation was quite helpful.  I do think that stricter sentencing rules for perpetual offenders might lessen that load, or perhaps longer lead times for filing charges.  I thought that rules had changed regarding chronic offenders a few years ago, but haven’t seen any evidence of that.

    • rme August 29, 2024 (9:04 pm)

      This is such an educational and reasonable comment… thank you for taking the time to write it out. 

  • CAM August 29, 2024 (3:58 pm)

    All the “catch and release” nonsense (I always love it when we dehumanize people by talking about them using metaphors for the process of hunting and killing animals) and hyperbole about no one ever facing consequences in these comments is particularly galling today because this article clearly states the man was just convicted of burglary and served 5 years in prison and 8 months of presentence time. That’s his full sentence. So please go bring your pitchforks to a different story. 

    • flimflam August 29, 2024 (6:54 pm)

      I hate to ruin your rant but he was quite literally caught and then released. That’s exactly what happened…

      • CAM August 29, 2024 (11:39 pm)

        It is really a shame that we can’t hold people in jail indefinitely when they aren’t charged with a crime. I mean what is the world coming to? I yearn for those pre Magna Carta days. Those people really didn’t know how good they had it. 

        • Admiral Redbeard August 30, 2024 (9:46 am)

          Cam, the problem here is not that he was released because of no charges.  The problem is that he was not CHARGED. 

          I don’t think anyone is saying he should be put back in prison for the past burglary and other crimes for which he already served time.  He should be charged and held or released on bail for the NEW crimes he just committed last weekend:  Stealing a car (and destroying it), using stolen plates, possessing a firearm as a convicted felon, being in possession of a stolen firearm, being in possession of other stolen property. 

          Of those crimes, at least two are immediately factually knowable for sufficient probable cause and should have been charged:  Possession of a stolen vehicle and possession of a firearm.  Instead, this criminal was literally caught (at the scene of Subaru crash), and then released two days later (with no charges).

          • CAM August 30, 2024 (1:04 pm)

            You are making the same point as everyone else despite you not wanting to admit it. You want to jail people not charged with crimes and convict them before any kind of trial. You are literally jumping through hoops to say that’s not what you mean and then (in parentheses) saying it is exactly what you mean. If you long for the criminal justice systems of authoritarian and oppressive governments there are lots of places that offer that option. 

          • flimflam August 30, 2024 (2:08 pm)

            Seriously cam? 🙄

  • zay August 29, 2024 (9:38 pm)

    is he stell wanted

    • WSB August 29, 2024 (9:46 pm)

      There were no warrants for him at the time of this arrest, or else he could have been detained even if not immediately charged.

Sorry, comment time is over.