West Seattle Junction Christmas tree gets unplanned ‘butchering.’ Who did it?

After commenter “Anonyme” – who has identified themselves previously as a former arborist – noted that the Junction Plaza Park tree that serves as The Junction’s official Christmas tree appeared “butchered,” we went over for a look. Our photo above is what we saw. Definitely trimmed – to put it mildly – in a major way, with the lighting event just a week and a half away. We checked in with the West Seattle Junction Association to see what happened – and executive director Chris Mackay says it’s news to them, though there’s been someone doing uninvited “butchering” on other trees in the area. She wanted us to ask if anyone saw it happening, or “has photos of the culprit.” (If you do have info and/or visuals, please contact WSJA – info@wsjunction.org.) Meantime, the tree lighting will proceed anyway (6 pm-ish on Saturday, December 7), because, as Chris puts it, “we have to” – the tree lighting is part of a 4-8 pm festival that night, featuring performances, a Night Market, beer garden, and more.

76 Replies to "West Seattle Junction Christmas tree gets unplanned 'butchering.' Who did it?"

  • Seattlite November 26, 2024 (3:44 pm)

    Are there any cameras in this area that could give a clue as to when this happened?  What a crying shame. 

  • momos mom November 26, 2024 (3:48 pm)

    Well WTHeck! That tree looks pretty bad towards the top anyways and now it looks even worse. I guess the lighting if it happens will have to be a Charlie Brown tree lighting.

  • J November 26, 2024 (3:57 pm)

    At least it was not topped.  
    Maybe someone desperate for free wreath boughs?

  • Anne November 26, 2024 (4:29 pm)

    There’s definitely been someone going around -butchering trees -happened to one in front of our building-about 2 months ago sometime overnight.I think he thinks he’s “ pruning” them-it’s anything but. Unfortunately we had no cameras where it happened.Had to pay someone to come out & fix what he did-which resulted in a severe pruning that  will take years to recover from. Doubt anything would happen to him even if he could be identified. Maybe WSJA could start  a fundraiser to replace this tree with one that looks more like a real Christmas  Tree .  

    • flimflam November 26, 2024 (6:38 pm)

      “He”? Why would you make that assumption?

  • Patrick November 26, 2024 (4:40 pm)

    Very strange, why would anyone do something like that?

    • Pinto November 26, 2024 (5:41 pm)

      Firewood?

    • Ruby November 26, 2024 (11:07 pm)

      I saw someone else guessing free material to sell Christmas wreaths, and I hate to say it but it kinda looks like it might be true…

      • K November 27, 2024 (7:25 am)

        There was so much free wreath material provided by the wind storm last week, pruning a tree seems like unnecessary effort.

  • John November 26, 2024 (4:55 pm)

    Idk but it seems odd to me. Where are all the cut off branches? Did they take them for a reason or did they just clean up after themselves? Or did someone else take care of the mess?

  • HS November 26, 2024 (5:08 pm)

    Maybe unrelated but there was a unhoused man last month doing the same type of thing at Westwood Village – at the pedestrian walkway behind Target. He did it to hide his belongings (a rolling trunk) under the tree limbs. He was using a small axe.

    • K November 26, 2024 (6:15 pm)

      Definitely unrelated, as what happened to this tree would provide the opposite of a hiding place.

  • Janet Scott November 26, 2024 (5:22 pm)

    Noticed this happened to the tree today! I don’t understand why someone would do this – I wonder if it’s the same person tossing rocks through nearby windows… Does anyone know what event is taking place at the park tonight? Live music and such is currently happening but I didn’t get a chance to stop and see.

  • S November 26, 2024 (5:36 pm)

    There’s a man that people in West Seattle have talked about before  who does  go around with pruning equipment and prunes the crap out of trees. He did this with evergreens/conifers on Harbor/Spokane just under/next to the bridge.  He limbed them all up and that is not the proper way to prune those. It was horrifying to see afterwards. Same with a stretch of maples off the sidewalk, limbed them all the way up. These tress are older. They are planted in areas with high traffic/pollution to provide screening and help to purify pollutants from the air around high traffic emissions. Limbing them  up is anti the intention. He seems really into it but needs training. That tree has the same look to it as the style the person I have witnessed but I don’t know his name. White guy, often pulls a yard waste bin along with tools and blondish hair/facial hair usually wearing a bandana and prunes at night.

    • AlkiRenter November 26, 2024 (8:44 pm)

      Came here to say something similar, but you said it best!

    • WSB November 26, 2024 (9:12 pm)

      I think I saw this man you’re describing within the vicinity of the tree and curb during daylight hours on one of the dry days we had. I didn’t take in the full scene, but your description matches who I saw, garbage bin behind him and sweeping up. Something struck me as odd but I wasn’t fully paying attention. Think he was wearing a red bandana and some bright colored yellow shirt. Doesn’t that intersection have a camera? 

      • WSB November 26, 2024 (9:14 pm)

        Traffic cameras don’t record, and their field of view is pretty limited.

      • Monica November 28, 2024 (4:13 pm)

        Yes, I’ve seen this same man in the Admiral junction. I thought he might have been hired to sweep the leaves before the windstorm to prevent the drains from clogging. Then I saw him in the middle of College Ave. He had a huge pile of leaves in the middle of the street blocking traffic. That’s when I really thought he was going rogue. Definitely had a shopping cart, trash bins, and wearing a red bandana.

      • Petert November 28, 2024 (9:35 pm)

        Saw this guy at 3:30pm today crosding California at Oregon, heading west. Bandana, pruning extension saw, pulling a trash can on wheels. Genesee neighborhood folks, check your trees.

    • CCrawford November 27, 2024 (11:14 am)

      We saw this guy as you describe pruning the tree.  Two cop cars  pulled up with lights flashing and and got out and spoke with the guy but I am not sure the outcome. 

  • Rebecca November 26, 2024 (5:39 pm)

    I was walking my dog and witnessed the man that goes around covering graffiti/ doing random yardwork and carries a yard waste container with him butchering this thing 😔 This man has been going around for years and usually does a good job cleaning up the community I’m sure someone knows the name of the man I’m talking about

    • J November 26, 2024 (8:49 pm)

      This sounds like the guy that was painting the poles at the crosswalk a couple of weeks ago.   He was painting them bright red. He was also toting a big green compost bin that had yard equipment in it.  Late 50s long white beard.

      • MJ November 26, 2024 (9:12 pm)

        He’s in his late 40’s and I went to high school with him. He struggles with mental health and addiction issues. I believe he lives near the Taco Time on 35th Ave.  I see him in the area almost every day. He means no harm but it looks like he’s created some. He knows not what he does anymore. 

        • S November 26, 2024 (11:05 pm)

          Thanks for letting us know. He does seem harmless and honestly has skills esp with extension pole pruners and stamina.  But recently really limbing everything up as far as he possibly can, not such a good approach. I’ve seen him doing cleanup work in the past, raking/sweeping up neglected sidewalk s buried in leaves and sludge etc.  He has done  some decent work for the community. Do you think he would work with other people? Like maybe with A Cleaner Alki? It seems like he stays completely in his own lane. It’d be sad if he got in trouble. Instead just needs learn some better pruning technique and he could carry on! 

          • D-Mom November 28, 2024 (6:40 am)

            He’s not harmless if he is hacking away at trees. And he’s not staying in his lane if he is damaging public and private property. Trees take forever to grow and are so special to the community and so needed with all the development. This is as much a crime as a robbery. I hope all these tips can get to the police to catch this guy. He needs to be stopped. 

    • Chris mackay November 27, 2024 (10:25 am)

      Rebecca, would you be willing to come in and look at a photo that we have of him and identify him? He’s obviously mentally unstable and we need to get him to stop doing what he’s doing. Perhaps we can redirect him to moving in invasive species. I’m not sure, but he is incessant and his butchering of the local plants Reach out to me chris@wsjunction.org and thank you 

      • GD WS OG Team November 27, 2024 (8:20 pm)

        Can we do a go fund me and just replace it.  I have $100 if everyone else is on board.

  • Anders November 26, 2024 (5:55 pm)

    Have noticed a man pruning trees at night for well over a year now. Also seen him very early in the morning on Calif. Ave.   He prunes trees on city property especially in commercial zones and sometimes on parking strips. Last spring  / summer he did almost all of them along the storefronts on Calif Ave. in the Junction and down at Admiral Junction. He has also worked on trees along Avalon, Admiral Way, Alaska Way and Fauntleroy.  Tends to cut them into similar shape by removing the branches at the bottom up as far as can be reached. Have been concerned about this / the trees since he apparently neither works for the city, and from viewing the cuts, do not think he is an arborist.  I think he has some experience, means well and feels he is doing a service (and sometimes he is when  branches have begun to obstruct sidewalks – but this is rare and think should be done by a city arborist.) Wanted to alert someone about it, but since it happens at night -seemed pointless. Finally got  pictures of him cutting a tree near Hamburger Habit around 7pm just a couple weeks ago.  I have NO idea if this is the same person who took a whack to the Xmas tree, but there is a similar pattern shaping the tree by cutting off all the lower branches. I will try to submit the photos to email above. Would love to see him get work or an opportunity where he can contribute his passion and work ethic, but would also like to have him stop cutting WS trees without authorization at this point in time. If anyone has ideas about how to reach out to him to stop and / or to redirect his efforts, please let us know.

  • anonyme November 26, 2024 (6:00 pm)

    I would not by any stretch call this “pruning”, nor is it legal to go around hacking away at trees that are not on your own property.  If this individual can be identified, he needs to be stopped and held accountable.  This is vandalism and property destruction.  He is doing serious damage to these trees. Contrary to popular belief, trees do not simply “grow back”. The damage is permanent. 

    • Jethro Marx November 26, 2024 (7:04 pm)

      This is a thing people do, we used to have a lady in our neighborhood who would randomly and violently hack away at bushes and trees encroaching on the sidewalk. It is not actually clear to me that this is illegal when vegetation extends over a traveled way.

      I assume, but am not actually sure, that visitors to Seattle parks are not allowed to shape trees to their own ends.

      I guess in the end, you light up the tree you have, not the tree you wish you had.

      • Big Bling November 27, 2024 (7:58 am)

        From King County/City Seattle website.  I cut back bushes when they encroach onto sidewalks as they are a hazard !

        Rules to Follow

        Our codes require that you:

        • Trim or remove vegetation that overhangs or obstructs streets, alleys, or sidewalks. Allow an 8-foot clearance over sidewalks and a 14-foot clearance over traveled roads. See the Seattle Department of Transportation’s Seattle Sidewalk Accessibility Guide for more information.
        • Trim or remove vegetation that is a fire hazard.
        • At intersections, trim so that the view of the intersection is not obstructed by vegetation. Trim any vegetation that interferes with the view of an intersection from 30 feet away.
        • Clear vegetation from obscuring traffic signs as required by the Seattle Department of Transportation.
        • Leave a 3-foot clear zone around fire hydrants as required by the Seattle Fire Department.
        • Get a street use permit to prune or remove trees in the public right-of-way.
        • Get a permit or exemption to remove vegetation from environmentally critical areas such as steep slopes or wetlands.
        • EJ November 28, 2024 (5:45 pm)

          That’s… that’s not what was happening here…

  • aRF November 26, 2024 (6:04 pm)

    The tree reminds me of that church fresco in Spain “restored” by one of the parishioners. 

    • John November 26, 2024 (6:42 pm)

      I know the one you’re talking about! Person wasn’t trained at all to deal with that kind of stuff super sad what happened

  • Oerthehillz November 26, 2024 (6:57 pm)

    Not sure if others have noticed but opioid usage is also responsible for bazaar obsessions. Spending hours staring up close at cracks in the side walks and picking at dirt, and other hyper focus activities, etc…can be seen in heavy users. I’ve seen this often. I’d advise approaching this person very carefully or calling for mental health response assistance. It’s sad, but may be why this person is seeing this as an important job he needs to do.

    • BMC November 30, 2024 (1:59 pm)

      He seems to be a bit to hyperactive to be an opioid user….

  • ACG November 26, 2024 (7:10 pm)

    Oh my. This is terrible!

  • stephen November 26, 2024 (7:24 pm)

  • Lisa November 26, 2024 (8:00 pm)

    What the? This seems pretty intentional and brazen to do right before the holiday season. Hope the culprit continues to live a long miserable existence.

    • momos mom November 27, 2024 (6:30 am)

      @Lisa, Please re-read what you just commented and can you still say you feel good about it. 🤦🏻‍♀️

    • LivinginWSSince94 November 27, 2024 (6:57 am)

      Nice attitude.  Sigh.  I guarantee this was not done in any nefarious manner so your holiday wishes for him are way over the top.  The individual has a brain injury.  In his mind, he’s doing something good for the community.  He’s unusual, but in my personal experience he is perfectly pleasant to talk with.  Unfortunately, it seems that because of his injury, his mind works differently than many which causes frustrations and leads to behavior that is oft deemed inappropriate. Please keep in mind this is supposed to be the season of compassion.  Our world could use a lot more of that right now.  I appreciate the commenters that have some suggestions on how to potentially redirect his efforts rather than wishing him misery.

      • BMC November 29, 2024 (10:11 am)

        Thanks for your compassion:)

    • BMC November 30, 2024 (1:56 pm)

      Kinda harsha don’t ya think Lisa ?

  • Karen B November 26, 2024 (8:06 pm)

    So sorry to see this!   I have no insights into this specific incident, but as someone who lives on a corner with lovely street trees on two sides, I’ve known people to comment that they worry that they will get too big and make it difficult to see oncoming traffic. I’ve also seen occasional fallout from those who express irritation on street trees in nearby blocks – broken branches and such.  So, we preemptively prune…

  • Ashley November 26, 2024 (8:07 pm)

    My husband saw him on Sunday toward the end of the farmers market, he was spray painting the big metal poles on 42nd and Alaska white as far as he could reach. He was out there for like 2 hours. Then later than evening he saw him trimming the sidewalk trees that are after the big tree going toward California. He did not see him touch the big tree, it must have been done after 5pm. If they find him he could identify him. Blond scraggly hair with blond/white goatee. Bandana and dragging a garbage can. 

  • Rhonda November 26, 2024 (8:37 pm)

    Was it this guy?

  • T Rex November 26, 2024 (8:41 pm)

    Perhaps this man finds some sort of comfort, maybe because of PTSD? This is an odd thing to do, I believe it’s not as simple as just vandalism. Just my gut feeling. 

  • Sad. But it is vandalism. November 27, 2024 (3:23 am)

    This is a crime. How sad before the holidays. Yes sad a troubled mind did this but Durant excuse it. Please submit your photos of the suspect and time say something in real time. We need all the greenery and light we can get. Don’t let WS turn into the rest of Seattle. 

  • Sigh November 27, 2024 (6:23 am)

    Any recommendations on what time do if we see this sort of thing happening? 

  • Junction Neighbor November 27, 2024 (6:55 am)

    I know this man’s patterns and he will be back to finish it. It might take a few months, but he’s not done yet. He has devastated shrubs and trees all around the Junction and by my house. I hope someone knows him and can get him to stop. He recently finished his hack job at the 7-11 by my house. It started with hacking all the sides up and leaving only small tree tops, but he went back and hacked them the rest of the way down. He also just cut our laurel back at the end of our driveway. Yes to male, white beard and dragging pruning equipment. I have even called the WS Junction Association about it as we need more eyes on stopping him when he is in action, or better yet, someone reaching out to him who knows who he is and taking his tools away. I saw him eyeing the greenery in the parking strip in front of QFC and Petco, so that area might be hit next. 

    • Chris mackay November 27, 2024 (10:22 am)

      Hi, this is Chris with the West Seattle Junction Association and I’m hoping perhaps we can meet we have a photo of the individual and if you can positively identify him as the one who’s done damage around the area, it would help. we need to build a case and find out who he is. He’s done so much damages unbelievable.

  • Bob November 27, 2024 (7:46 am)

    Might as well cut all the extra stragglers and turn it into one tree and then limb it up nicely. Then leave it alone and let it grow tall and straight. I prefer tall straight trees with limbs on the top 1/3 of the tree. But to each there own.

    • anonyme November 27, 2024 (3:21 pm)

      This species cannot be “limbed up” for a variety of reasons.  It is also lethal to remove more than 1/3 of a tree’s foliage, less for conifers like the one in question.  Trees should not be pruned as if they are big bushes, and the pruning approach depends entirely on the species of the tree.  Leaving foliage only on the top 1/3 of the tree is not only ugly and unhealthy, it makes the tree dangerous and more likely to come down in a storm.

  • SJ November 27, 2024 (7:54 am)

    It might still look a little weird, but I wonder if the empty spaces could be filled in with artificial tree pieces, just for the lighting. I did this once for my grandma after her porch camelia got an overzealous trim. Seems like artificial evergreens/branches would be easy to find this time of year. Any adventurous florists out there up for a challenge?

    (I’m remembering how Charlie Brown’s friends made the tree beautiful again 🙂)

  • LO November 27, 2024 (8:32 am)

    The earliest I noticed the butchered tree was Saturday 11/23 around 2pmish. Walked past it and said “oh wow the Christmas tree lighting this year is going to be sad, this thing looks terrible” to my husband. I usually take photos of bad pruning jobs (since I teach pruning classes) but this time I didn’t. 

  • Joan November 27, 2024 (8:58 am)

    This man is destroying public and private property. Why is he allowed to walk the streets? He needs to be housed with proper treatment.

  • Chris mackay November 27, 2024 (10:30 am)

    Hello everyone, thank you for commenting. This is Chris Mackay with the West Seattle Junction Association. I think we can all agree that this man is doing a lot of damage in West Seattle to our plants and trees and bushes. We have a photo of him. I need someone who to identify him as the man who did the damage to this tree specifically. if you saw him Cutting this tree please reach out to me so we can get a clear identification. We need to build a case against him. I have notified the parks department. In a perfect world, we could identify this man and train him to cut invasive species only. Wouldn’t that be wonderful but at the minimum we need to identify him and get him to stop what he’s doing and share this information with the parks department and SDOT so please reach out to me if you saw him chris@wsjunction.org

    • Sigh November 27, 2024 (11:44 am)

      Hi Chris, would love to contribute to a fund to replace this tree to support Alaska Juntion. Any thoughts?

    • RoodJood November 27, 2024 (7:34 pm)

       I know this person and have seen him do ‘civic pruning and garbage pickup’ many, many times.  He’s a neighbor to whom I speak weekly though briefly in passing.  

      • BMC November 30, 2024 (1:49 pm)

        Hey there – maybe you could give him a heads up that the wagons are circling ( unfortunately) and he made need to lay low. I saw him a few hours ago – no tools in hand. At least he’s not assaulting people, breaking windows or yelling at random passersby. I say give the guy a break : ) Let the cops be called on the violent types in the area. 

  • Kathy November 27, 2024 (12:21 pm)

    On a side note, property owners, please prune your parking strip trees so they don’t obscure stop signs. I’m looking at you NE corner of Fauntleroy & SW Graham.

    • My two cents November 27, 2024 (1:25 pm)

      Light on the passive, heavy on the aggressive …  ice way to blast your neighbors. The find it fix it app would be a good way to address this scenario, IMO.

  • tim November 27, 2024 (12:27 pm)

    I believe this tree trimmer had nothing but good intentions. He does a lot of work in the area. Cleaning gutters the other day near Taco time.  I think the tree looks alright and will soon grow back. Maybe it’s better to allow a better line of sight at intersections?.  It’s the time of giving. Can we stop piling on and show some compassion for a heartfelt effort.

    • Seattlite November 27, 2024 (12:47 pm)

      Tim…According to another comment the WS Junction Association is trying to stop this guy from damaging public and private property which is against the law.  Compassion should be shown to the business owners who try to keep their properties clean, neat, and unvandalized.  Tree experts aka arborists know when a tree cannot grow property after being treated badly.  The photo seems to show “stub” cuts which are very bad for a tree.

    • Paul November 27, 2024 (12:48 pm)

      Tim, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. What this guy has done is damaging to both public and private property. If he wants to pick up trash so be it—no problem. But please, do not dismiss or condone this  damage to property that’s not yours.  For public safety, I think this guy should not be roaming our neighborhood with sharp implements, as he’s exhibiting very questionable behavior.

      Plus, that tree will not grow back. It’s been destroyed.

    • Nope, stop this madness. November 27, 2024 (7:12 pm)

      No, he’s pretty much killed this tree. An important tree for our community. And he’s done damage elsewhere. So no, he needs to be stopped. Now. 

    • Orb November 27, 2024 (8:00 pm)

      You are assuming a lot here. The bottom line is that what he is doing is illegal and an absolute eyesore. He has upset more people than not, and he must be stopped. It is not okay.

  • Karen November 27, 2024 (12:41 pm)

    Maybe Parks Department?Bushes at the front of Jack Block Park were also recently trimmed up in a similar manner. 

  • Karen November 27, 2024 (12:42 pm)

    Might be Parks Department. The bushes at the front of Jack Block Park were also recently trimmed up in a similar manner.  It increases visibility. 

  • momos mom November 28, 2024 (9:32 am)

    So many commenters have said they see “him” doing this, maybe not this tree in question but other trees, bushes and so forth have any of you turned him in to the authorities or is it that no one knows who or where to go for the help? Or is it the usual “oh someone else will take care of this” I know if he was doing this on our block I would go ask him “what are you doing” and to please stop.

  • BMC November 29, 2024 (10:20 am)

    Well we somewhat affectionately call him “Bin Guy” and have seen him working on projects all around the area including good works : removing moss, cleaning drains of leaves, pulling weeds etc. I understand he does have a home and have seen him frequenting Taco Time and Starbucks. Yes perhaps he ruined a tree or a shrub but please can we tolerate a perhaps eccentric person trying to do good? 

    • EJ November 30, 2024 (12:42 pm)

      No.

  • Kate November 30, 2024 (7:55 am)

    I think the tree could benefit from a cozy yarn bombing. Maybe time for a new tree? The top doesn’t look that great.

    • anonyme December 1, 2024 (5:31 am)

      Yarn bombing is also terrible for trees.  I do agree that the tree looks diseased, and combined with the butchering, will probably need to be replaced

  • WCR December 1, 2024 (12:48 am)

    Horrific to see this. We have years of photos of the tree lighting with my kids when they were small. This is obviously vandalism. That poor tree. This guy needs to be charged with a crime for what he’s done. Make him pay for the repairs/ replacement (if this poor tree can even be saved). Seems people know this guy, so please come forward and report him to the West Seattle Junction association and SPD.

  • Scarlett December 1, 2024 (9:22 am)

    Heart-warming tale about you and the little ones, but unless you are a mind reader you don’t know if this was intentional “vandalism.”  He should be taken aside but lets wait before we roll out the guillotines, shall we? It is the holiday season, after all.   

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.