FOLLOWUP: Homestead Community Land Trust chosen as affordable-homeownership developer for ex-substation site at 16th/Holden

11:59 AM: Above, that’s what the southwest corner of 16th/Holden looks like today, a 9,425-square-foot former Seattle City Light substation originally declared as “surplus” more than a decade ago … and below is a “massing” rendering of its potential future with newly chosen prospective “affordable homeownership” developer Homestead Community Land Trust.

The city Office of Housing has just announced that it’s chosen Homestead CLT – which is also working on the Admiral Church project – to develop “permanently affordable” homes on the site. We’ve been following this process; most recently, the city told us in June that two developers were in the running, and one would be chosen by summer’s end. From the city announcement:

The City of Seattle’s Office of Housing (OH) is proud to announce a significant investment of up to $3 million in the future of affordable homeownership in West Seattle. This funding will be awarded to Homestead Community Land Trust (Homestead CLT) for the redevelopment of the former Dumar Substation site at 1605 SW Holden Street and will support the creation of 21 permanently affordable homes, marking a critical step forward in the City’s ongoing efforts to provide affordable housing options for low-income families.

Homestead CLT, partnering with the Cultural Space Agency, submitted a winning proposal through a competitive Request for Proposals (RFP) process that not only increases the supply of affordable homeownership units but also integrates ground-floor commercial space to enhance community vibrancy.

Homestead CLT’s proposal garnered strong community backing, with local organizations like the Highland Park Action Committee and the Highland Park Improvement Club voicing their support. Once complete, the development will feature a four-story building with a mix of studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, and three-bedroom homes, all of which will be available to buyers earning at or below 80% of the Area Median Income (AMI). In addition to providing affordable homeownership opportunities, the development will also include ground-floor commercial space.

The commercial space is something that community groups long had advocated for, as well as supporting zoning at the site – at an intersection with businesses on two corners and a fire station at the third – so it could support a project like this. We’re following up with Homestead regarding timeline and what happens next.

ADDED 1:03 PM: Here’s the response we received from Homestead CLT’s CEO Kathleen Hosfeld:

First, I want to give big props to [former City Councilmember] Lisa Herbold, because making sure this property was set aside for affordable housing was one of her top priorities before she left office. This was something I’d been hearing about for years directly from community leaders, and she got it done. Let’s make sure we give credit where it’s due.

In terms of opportunities for community engagement….The City has already engaged in a lot of outreach to determine what people want for this site. We don’t want to contribute to “process fatigue” by asking community to keep repeating the same feedback they’ve given before. But we typically host one or more community open house opportunities for engagement on projects before we submit our permit application. We intend to submit the permit application in May of 2025. We have not yet scheduled those events.

We hope to have full funding for the project by the end of 2025 and start construction in early 2026. However, if we are not fully funded, the timeline may get pushed to start construction in 2027.

16 Replies to "FOLLOWUP: Homestead Community Land Trust chosen as affordable-homeownership developer for ex-substation site at 16th/Holden"

  • Skipalapondo September 12, 2024 (12:30 pm)

    I have no problem with adding affordable housing, but I think adding commercial properties on the ground floor is a folly. Seattle already has a surplus of office space and mixed residential/commercial spaces, and a dearth of housing. It reminds me of the push in the state capital to change zoning to allow homeowners to open businesses in previously restricted residential areas, in that it’s solving the wrong problem. We’re a decade into the housing crises and solutions appear short on the ground.That said, I’m thankful for more housing anywhere and hope this is completed soon!

    • Amoo September 12, 2024 (2:02 pm)

      Mixed use neighborhoods are good if you care about walkability and quality of life. Or even if you don’t, but just want to keep traffic from getting even worse.

    • DC September 12, 2024 (2:06 pm)

      This is an area with a serious dearth of retail options. As more people work from home and go into the commercial zones less often, small lot commercial properties within walking distance of residential neighborhoods is exactly what we need! I walk to this intersection regularly and visit each of the business there. I’m very excited for new options. And new neighbors!

    • Kyle September 12, 2024 (3:00 pm)

      The retail options at this corner are very limited. This would be good for the community. The renderings shows parking in front but there will be no parking after an SPU project completes that was tied to the bridge closure. Personally, I think they should rechannel that intersection to make the light more efficient and have queueing for left or right turning cars. Because of the inefficiency many motorists cut around the light through the neighborhood.

    • Rb September 12, 2024 (11:28 pm)

      Au contraire, the neighborhood and the low income residents could greatly benefit from walkable shopping. West Seattle in general has very limited commercial spaces and that’s why is unaffordable for most small business owners. 

  • Carl W. September 12, 2024 (3:08 pm)

    The fact that it took over 10 years just to even start getting something done with this property is just plain embarrassing.

  • westseattlebob September 12, 2024 (4:21 pm)

    Can we please have something built that isn’t just a box and have an actual architect think about design?? God these are awful and is a blight on the neighborhoods they live in. Give us something that at least tries to be something rather than just another building.

    • TJ September 12, 2024 (5:51 pm)

      I agree that new buildings need better designs instead of the cheapest style, which is a gray box with windows. Better designs also boost the morale of residents living in the buildings and the surrounding neighborhood. It gives people something to take pride in, especially when you add some trees and grass.The SHA housing in High Point is a good example. The units look like real homes, not boxes.

    • Joe September 12, 2024 (5:53 pm)

      For affordable?….doubt it. It’ll be a box.

    • The King September 12, 2024 (6:14 pm)

      If it weren’t for architect Victor Steinbrueck playing roles in saving Pioneer Square and the Pike Place Market we wouldn’t have much left in this city. He played a key role in designing the Space Needle also

    • Joan September 12, 2024 (8:22 pm)

      Totally agree. Why should low income residents have to live in a depressing gray concrete box?

      • WSB September 12, 2024 (8:23 pm)

        As explained, this is a “massing” (size/shape) rendering, not what the building will eventually look like (colors, materials, etc.).

  • george finis September 13, 2024 (9:14 am)

    another 80 unit apartment building with NO Parking?

    • WSB September 13, 2024 (9:41 am)

      This will not be 80 units, nor will it be an apartment building. Affordable *homeownership* – the units will be for sale.

  • South Delridge resident September 13, 2024 (11:10 am)

    I look forward to new businesses and neighbors in Highland Park!! We have a great need for this kind of housing and real estate for small businesses. Kudos to the Highland park non-profits and Lisa for making this happen!I also want to say that it seems like the city is focused on planning these developments in south east West Seattle and White Center – where real estate prices are the lowest in the Seattle area. Do we know if there are any future affordable housing developments planned for the west side of 35th and closer to our California junctions, Alki, Admiral and etc? It has been proven that integrating affordable housing into higher income neighborhoods provides more opportunities, better schools, easier transportation as well as creating diverse and vibrant communities.  

  • Spit Delridge Community Member September 21, 2024 (8:55 am)

    I own a home right around the corner and I’m very excited about this! There is very little that is walkable to in this area so I’m looking forward to having more local storefront space to improve walkability. Around the neighborhood new residential housing is mostly expensive townhomes so I appreciate that there will be affordable housing options. Historically this neighborhood was where blue collar Boeing workers and immigrants lived. While we grow, let’s keep the neighborhood history of being affordable for families.

Sorry, comment time is over.