Artist seeking your words of support to prevent West Seattle sculpture from ‘becoming a corpse’ (updated Tuesday)

The artist who created an iconic West Seattle sculpture is asking for support in his quest to save it from being demolished instead of replaced.

(Photo courtesy Don Fels)

That’s the Paragon, installed more than 20 years ago at what’s now known as həʔapus Village Park and Shoreline Habitat (formerly T-107 Park) along West Marginal Way near the Duwamish Tribe Longhouse. We heard from artist Don Fels over the weekend – he explains that this dates back to when he was the lead artist on the West Seattle Cultural Trail on Alki 25+ years ago – and continued it down West Marginal Way. He picks up the story from there, in the email he sent us explaining why he’s asking for community words of support:

I created three sculptures there, including the Geo-Slice, which tells the geomorphic history of the site, and the Paragon, which features a scaled-down wooden framework of a halibut schooner designed and built in Seattle in 1923. The sculpture is now in mortal danger!

The sculpture was a broad ranging collaboration between me, the Port of Seattle, the City of Seattle, the Center for Wooden Boats, Seattle City Light and people from the Croatian community of West Seattle. I obtained the plans for the original Paragon, which is still fishing up in Alaska, and then Michael Vlahovich, a third-generation boat builder, whose grandmother lived on the site, built the wooden ‘boat’ with his boat-building students at Bates Technical College.

Under the boat are several panels giving the history of the site- telling how the Native people who lived and fished there were forced out by destruction of the habitat, how immigrants from (the then) Yugoslavia, Greece, and Italy moved in, often squatting, to live and build boats. The Port bulldozed down their settlement, which even though the Port arranged to have the sculpture created on the site, they let me acknowledge in the text I produced for the sculpture.

Seattle’s Office of Arts and Culture was charged with maintaining the wood boat structure, which they failed to do. There is now considerable rot and it is infested with carpenter ants. Suddenly, their solution to years of their neglect: tear it down. To counter that very real threat, I am organizing a rebuild of the wooden boat (the steel and concrete structure is sound). In very short order I have garnered support from the Center for Wooden Boats, the Burke Museum, the Port of Seattle, the Washington Trust for Historic Preservation, Allied Arts, and thanks to the great help from Ken (Workman), the Duwamish Tribe. I continue to reach out to other potential partners, and am certain there will be many others.

At present we are planning for a community rebuilding of the boat next year. I would WELCOME volunteers, donations of materials, etc etc. But for now I’m looking to get letters from the community sent to the Office of Arts and Culture from people who want the sculpture to remain and be fixed up. They can be directed to the Deputy Director, Kelly Davidson. Her email is Kelly.Davidson@seattle.gov.

Fels is meeting with her on Tuesday morning and adds, “If anyone feels compelled to write her, it would be wonderfully helpful if they did so before then, so that she sees there is real support to save the sculpture. I want them to take ‘deaccessioning’ (i.e. destroying it) off their agenda. This is very important ASAP, because once they officially stamp it ‘deaccessioned,’ the sculpture goes from being an artwork to a corpse.” If you can spare a moment to email Kelly Davidson, Don adds, please cc him, at donatofels@gmail.com.

ADDED TUESDAY MIDDAY: Here’s the statement we received from the Office of Arts and Culture:

The Office of Arts & Culture envisions a city driven by creativity that provides the opportunity for everyone to engage in diverse arts and cultural experiences. Deaccessioning artworks is always a last resort. The first priority of any public artwork commission is to ensure that there is no risk to the public if the structure were to break apart or collapse.

Don Fels’ Paragon has stood at həʔapus Village Park & Shoreline Habitat since 2001, honoring its surrounding communities. It is one of 400 art works in the Seattle Civic Art Collection, each of which requires maintenance. The Office of Arts and Culture has maintained the structure over the years, however, Seattle’s rainy climate, the passage of time (23 years) and the original materials used in Paragon have resulted in this very natural outcome. We look forward to meeting with Mr. Fels this week to discuss the options for potentially saving the current structure. (Indeed, we will be meeting with Mr. Fels later this morning). That said, the structure is currently a significant safety hazard that must be addressed as soon as possible.

Anytime people are moved by art, we consider our mission successful.That you all feel passionate about this artwork to write to us and save it makes us proud.

Gülgün Kayim
Director, Seattle Office of Arts & Culture

18 Replies to "Artist seeking your words of support to prevent West Seattle sculpture from 'becoming a corpse' (updated Tuesday)"

  • Peggy July 14, 2024 (10:17 pm)

    Just sent in an email asking to keep the art piece. Good luck!

  • KayK July 14, 2024 (10:39 pm)

    Thanks for the update. Been noting the construction fencing around the work and assumed the piece was under maintenance.We have enjoyed having it there during many years of driving W Marginal. Particularly in the evening hours the simple illumination made it float, ghostlike in the vegetation. The adjacency to the Longhouse gives it further meaning. Since the artist is involved and in dialog with the community why not repair it? Isn’t that one of the foundational points of public work like this?

  • Mike July 14, 2024 (10:59 pm)

    They should move it to outside MOHIA by the wooden boat museum.  Get two museums with one piece of art.

  • WS July 15, 2024 (7:33 am)

    Right, let’s move all the community art we paid for down here up to the North end where the Amazon drones and luxury condo owners can enjoy it.  Brilliant idea.

  • Joan July 15, 2024 (7:36 am)

    I hate it  when  public works of art get destroyed or removed. Let’s save this!

  • Curious George July 15, 2024 (8:08 am)

    It’s very disturbing to see such a great piece of history and art be destroyed by the city not fulfilling its contract.  I would pursue this to have the city cover all replacement costs and pro-active maintenance on the replacement.

  • cw July 15, 2024 (8:21 am)

    I too just emailed. Feel free to copy/paste and email! 
    ————————————–
    Hello Kelly,
    I’m writing to support the rebuilding vs. demolition of the Paragon Sculpture after learning of its important historic symbolism.
     

    Too often we are quick to destroy instead of re-investing in important ‘time capsules’ as historic reminders for generations to come. Significant stories such as these, should indeed be a priority to sustain.

  • 22blades July 15, 2024 (9:30 am)

    Email sent. I reminded them of their stated “Mission & Vision Statement. It’s our art with a unique historical significance as well.

    Mission

    We activate and sustain Seattle through arts and culture

    Vision

    The Office of Arts & Culture envisions a city driven by creativity that provides the opportunity for everyone to engage in diverse arts and cultural experiences.

    • cw July 15, 2024 (9:41 am)

      yes, thank you! Don tells me the city only notified him less than a week ago with a meeting set tomorrow to seal its fate. It is a waste of public paid funds (two-fold if demolished!) and an important work to preserve. The Deputy Director Kelly has been in her role for 3 months now, we must assure her this is not a good start to supporting cultural art in that role.

      • Alki gal July 15, 2024 (4:58 pm)

        Only 3 months on the job?? Must have come in with the Harrell administration….

  • proudpugetridger July 15, 2024 (1:25 pm)

    With artwork, it always seems tough to make practical decisions.  Regardless of who’s money is spent in restoration, deciding if the finished value of the piece equal to, or greater than, the cost of repairs seems crucial to any decisions regarding repair-vs-demolish.  Compounding that basic question (restoration cost vs actual value) is the projected cost of preventative maintenance in the future.  Sadly, I’m betting the non-emotional answer to both questions is the painful decision is to demo.  I’m thankful for the 20 years we did get to enjoy that sculpture.  …and I didn’t even make any jokes about replacing it with a pickleball court!

    • Dawn July 15, 2024 (10:31 pm)

      Ah, but see that’s the fly in the ointment. The “value” of a work of art extends beyond just the monetary, and that’s as subjective as the opinions on the piece itself. 

  • Aurora July 15, 2024 (2:56 pm)

    I do have a question to the artist. Do you know if you have right granted under VARA? VARA covered works cannot be mutilated or destroyed without a waiver from the artist.  Obviously there are a lot of nuances, but I think you should check and see if you have any protection under the VARA act. 

  • Kyle July 16, 2024 (6:42 am)

    Probably my engineer mind taking over..but if we rebuild what is the sustainable maintenance plan? How much will it cost and what would be required? If Seattle couldn’t maintain the current maintenance schedule do we need to build differently to make it more sustainable?

  • WSB July 16, 2024 (11:44 am)

    Statement from Arts & Culture added above.

  • Monica Cavagnaro July 16, 2024 (11:50 am)

    I’ve enjoyed Don Fels art for 20 years on my trips in and out of West Seattle. It’s a unique piece and needs work – please let it be and find the funds to hire a knowledgeable conservator who can direct the repairs, replacement of materials. The story it tells is valuable to community.

  • Alice Kuder July 16, 2024 (7:29 pm)

    It seems there is disagreement as to the definition of maintaining the artwork over the years. If it had truly been maintained, would it still have deteriorated so horribly? If the deterioration had been monitored, couldn’t it have been repaired before it got to this point?

  • Ryanco Concrete Construction July 16, 2024 (8:02 pm)

    Don Fels’ Paragon sculpture is an essential piece of West Seattle’s cultural heritage. Installed over 20 years ago, it tells the story of the area’s diverse history and community. It’s heartbreaking to see it deteriorating due to neglect. Let’s rally together to support its restoration. Please email Kelly Davidson at Kelly.Davidson@seattle.gov to show your support for preserving this significant artwork. Your voice can make a difference!

Sorry, comment time is over.