WEST SEATTLE LIGHT RAIL: No committee vote today after all – here’s what did happen

The Sound Transit Board‘s Executive Committee didn’t vote this afternoon on an ST revision after all, but the push is still on for a full board vote two weeks from today. The board’s chair, Snohomish County executive Dave Somers, said a vote wouldn’t be appropriate because too many amendments had either been, or were expected to be, proposed.

This afternoon’s discussion did shine more light on issues brought up by board members at their regular monthly meeting last week. For example – why are they updating the plan now? ST’s Alex Krieg said the ST3 plan approved by voters in 2016 required a plan update when the plan is out of alignment with the available funding, and they’ve certainly arrived at that point. They can afford $57 billion worth of projects, both fully and partly funded, and West Seattle light rail – currently priced, even without the Avalon station, at $6.8 billion – would be on the fully funded list. But unless they adopted a complete new plan, they wouldn’t be allowed to spend all the money they’d need to spend to get West Seattle on the track to completion.

Krieg insisted that the proposed revision doesn’t cancel or eliminate anything, and there’s still room and time to add things back – like the Ballard Link Extension, for example, with a price tag of $7 billion to $9 billion for the segment from Seattle Center to Market Street, which is left hanging in the proposed revision. Though he’s not on the Executive Committee, board member Dan Strauss – who represents Ballard on the City Council – was there to say he won’t settle for that. And Mayor Katie Wilson, a board member who is on the committee, said she wanted to at least see a date for when they envisioned completing Ballard in this revision. (Theoretically West Seattle, “fully funded,” is still on track for 2032 completion, although board chair Somers took issue at one point with the frequent usage of “shovel-ready” to describe it, saying “major construction” actually wouldn’t start until 2028.)

One date of note: CFO Hughey Newsom noted that the revision would extend the end date of ST3 financing from 2046 to 2052.

And he pointed out that the revised plan would totally max out their expected financing – not counting a 10 percent so any change in costs, for example, could throw it “out of alignment” again and require yet another revision.

In board comments, committee member Ryan Mello, Pierce County Executive, declared the board needs to take action – “delay will only add cost and risk and is not our friend.”

King County Executive Girmay Zahilay, also a committee member, said he supports a vote at the May 28 board meeting too.

Along the way, Somers pointed out that even a vote on this ST3 revision is not a final commitment to West Seattle or any other project – those would be separate votes. So here’s what happens next:

27 Replies to "WEST SEATTLE LIGHT RAIL: No committee vote today after all - here's what did happen"

  • CarDriver May 14, 2026 (5:14 pm)

    Doesn’t give me a warm and fuzzy that they won’t rule out more financial “surprises”. When they come for our ankles you’ll know it’s to shake the money tree.

    • Jake May 15, 2026 (12:04 pm)

      So your whole thing is going to be complaining about things that might or likely not happen. Let’s stay in reality first… Do you have proof or data of any non-democratic agreed on measures that aren’t due to inflation/rising costs of goods? I’ll wait.

  • K to the F May 14, 2026 (5:41 pm)

    So disillusioned by how much this process and the ST3 costs have got away from ST. No one wants to make the call to spend 5x what was initially forecast/specced and it’s just vote after vote and community input after community input. I fear, at this point, we’re being slowly setup for the West Seattle spur to be cut entirely. For the initial costs it was worth it. Now, I can’t say I feel it is.

    • skeeter May 14, 2026 (7:54 pm)

      Good comment K TO THE F.  I voted yes on ST3.  But costs have ballooned so much I’ve lost much (but not all) faith in Sound Transit.  It’s such a mess and now every mayor and ST board member is just fighting for the light rail *their* city was promised.  It’s like Hunger Games — the only way you can win is if everyone else loses.  Community input is worthless at this point.  Sound Transit should go hire a person from Oregon or Idaho with no agenda or preference to study ST3 and impartially decide what should be built and what should be scrapped.             

  • Dr Wu May 14, 2026 (6:51 pm)

    After reading this WEST SEATTLE BLOG article, I smell a rat. 

  • pophouse May 14, 2026 (6:55 pm)

    Every place that has invested in public transportation has reaped rewards. We need this to be done yesterday. Continued waiting and listening to negative voices will only make the costs go up more. 

    • Lauren May 15, 2026 (7:47 am)

      Agreed, pophouse

  • 1994 May 14, 2026 (9:14 pm)

    How much money is ST losing because people are not purchasing their license plate tabs yearly? Today I saw a Honda Accord buzzing about on Roxbury with a license tab  year 2017!!!   ST has missed out on 10 years of taxes for that car.  

    • AdmiralE May 14, 2026 (9:50 pm)

      It’s rampant everywhere! I take my dog for a short walk and see at least a half dozen in 10 minutes. Then I get out on the road and my head explodes… Why isn’t this enforced?

      • WSB May 14, 2026 (10:01 pm)

        It is. Just listen to the scanner. Somebody was pulled over minutes ago for no rear plate (turned out the car’s registration was clear and current, they just tried to get away with not displaying their plate).

        • KB May 15, 2026 (6:41 am)

          I can confirm.  I was parked down in Sodo for a baseball game and had forgotten to put my new tabs on and received a hefty ticket!

          • max34 May 15, 2026 (1:21 pm)

            same.   mine was 6 months late (completely forgot) and while they never got me prior being in much more heavily patrolled areas, somehow they got me parked on the street…. in front of my house .  BUT, all that being said, ST has nothing to do with tabs and fees.  that’s on the City.  

  • WS Person May 14, 2026 (9:24 pm)

    So weird to me that people continue to champion the need for this one costs have become so astronomical. At some point it doesn’t matter whether there’s a benefit. The costs to taxpayers has become so outrageous. Shudder it and explore other options.

    • OTOH May 14, 2026 (10:53 pm)

      It is kind of weird we want light rail. It has been discussed since the 80s around here. It has been a long held promise that we’ve voted on and approved in one form or another many times, so many I’ve lost count. What happens is an idea comes around, gets voted for, gets rolling then dies. We pay for it, in part but don’t get our money back if it doesn’t get realized. Then they start again. Remember the movie Singles? The thing is if we stop now to figure out a plan, not plan a,b, c or d but something like plan h, it’ll take ~10 years for a plan and 5 to 10 times more than what we are spending now for any option that would actually serve this community to even get close to where we are now. (gondolas don’t count). It’ll cost more tomorrow than today. Let’s cut our losses and actually make this happen in full now. 

      • Canton May 15, 2026 (7:43 am)

        Let’s say you’re looking to buy a home. You have 800k in credit to buy a home. You’re taking your time, figuring out the best value. After a few years of looking, the same home is now quadruple, 3.2 million. Are you still considering the purchase?…

        • Derp May 15, 2026 (9:39 am)

          People need to understand that the cost of materials have gone up thru the roof and of course the original “Guesstimation” are going to go up. It is called inflation Now maybe if ST bought all the materials when the cost estimates were done. These costs wouldn’t go up.

          • max34 May 15, 2026 (1:28 pm)

            that’s not how any of this works.   you can’t just buy pre-fabricated guideways for something that exists as lines and dots on the map.  and let’s say you could magically know exactly the height/size needed for the entire corridor,   what do you think there’s some giant warehouse to store all this stuff?  And then have security/maintain it for 10 years?   

        • K May 15, 2026 (3:44 pm)

          Yes, Canton, because you need somewhere to live and EVERYTHING has quadrupled in that time, so there is no cheaper option.

        • Ex-Westwood Resident May 16, 2026 (4:47 pm)

          Well on the other hand, say you bought a 4-bedroom, 4-bath, 3,000 sq ft home, for $500,000 and then three weeks after signing papers, the seller tells you that what you’re ACTUALLY getting is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom, 1,000 sq ft home for the same price.

          Then the courts tell you that what you bought WASN’T the house, but the idea of a house.

          That is what ST and WASC did to the voters.

      • HTB May 15, 2026 (2:28 pm)

        Yes, but if you give them great coffee and great music…

    • PDiddy May 16, 2026 (9:47 am)

      I agree. The cost is insane and can easily be serviced by busses for the 4 miles.

  • Delridge Dude May 15, 2026 (6:54 am)

    I was glad to see Councilmember Saka give public comment! 

    • Jake May 15, 2026 (11:08 am)

      Hi Rob lol

  • Roosevelt May 15, 2026 (7:36 am)

    If their solution to cost uncertainties is to have “fare ambassadors” shakedown riders  for a few bucks and install lifesize video adverts at the stations I fear they’re alienating the only people left who would vote for further funding.

  • Your neighbor May 15, 2026 (8:16 am)

    As a car free person, I would use light rail daily. I can also share that I am losing a renter to light rail. They really like the neighborhood but it’s not easy for them to return home from their after work activities by bus. Instead of staying in WS, they are choosing to rent near the light rail.

  • Scarlett May 15, 2026 (11:53 am)

    I’m afraid people don’t understand the cost-benefit principle which is very, very important when we’re talking about allocating billions of dollars for infrastructure.  Sure,  light rail might be the best thing since sliced bread for your individual  needs, but does it meet the needs of your neighbor and enough of their neighbors?  Also, you can’t just plop down light rail,  you need the infrastructure around it to make it attractive to enough people.   Comparisons are odious, of course, but in pedestrian and bike friendly Tokyo, getting to a train station (and storing your bike) for example, is much easier with abundant ped/bike paths.  And, people don’t think anything of walking long distances to a station, even the elderly which bespeaks of culture and a healthy population.  I’ve always maintained that light rail will have a limited impact, overall, and I don’t see anything that has changed my mind.  

  • Scarlett May 15, 2026 (4:28 pm)

    Buy! Buy!  Build! Build!  That’s the financially irresponsible argument light rail supporters are using to justify plowing ahead with light rail, the same reasoning which resembles the frenzied speculation that is driving the stock market.   Get in now before prices go up even more!  Breathe into a paper bag, people.   Good god.     

Sorry, comment time is over.