WEST SEATTLE CRIME WATCH: Catalytic-converter theft attempts; repeat mailbox break-in

Reader eeports in Crime Watch this morning:

CATALYTIC-CONVERTER THEFT ATTEMPTS: We haven’t heard catalytic-converter theft mentioned in a long time (we were among the victims in an earlier wave). But this morning, two notes – Joanna reported:

just wanted to give a heads up about a car catalytic converter thief who is driving around Beach Drive. They did not (succeed) but they have been caught twice trying to steal the converter. Police have been notified. They seem to be driving between the hours of 3 AM-5 AM.

Then we heard from Anthony:

About 3:55 am in the 5400 block of Beach Dr SW, heard loud grinding sounds outside. Looked out the window and saw two persons at the passenger side of my car. One was lying down very close to the passenger door and the other was standing near looking at him. Yelled for them to get away. Went to front door and yelled again. They then left in a black newer crossover which had been standing in the southbound lane next to my car, on Beach Dr.

Examining my car, they had made a single complete cut through the pipe from the engine to the exhaust.

About a half hour later a dark car returned, parked again next to my car and a person was walking around to the passenger side of my car. I opened the door to my home and yelled, fervently, that they should quickly leave. They did. I went out to examine my car. There was a black knit cap next to the driver’s-side door that had NOT been there a half hour before. Talking to the police officers about a half hour later, they remarked that that they couldn’t recall a converter theft report for several years.

They took the hat.

Our archives remind us this type of theft was especially frequent in 2022.

MAILBOXES BROKEN INTO, AGAIN: The report and photo are from Keenan:

I live in a 16-unit townhouse complex on 44th Ave SW between Oregon and Genesee. This morning I noticed our shared mailbox was broken into last night and the doors are currently open. My neighbors reported this happening last year as well – this is only the latest incident. The post office has not been helpful at all – the only solution is for them to change the master locks on all of the mailboxes in the area so the stolen key the thieves have no longer opens our box. But they refuse to help.

8 Replies to "WEST SEATTLE CRIME WATCH: Catalytic-converter theft attempts; repeat mailbox break-in"

  • Another Condo Mailbox Break In January 25, 2026 (12:34 pm)

    Our condo mailboxes (2 boxes for a total of 9 units) were found open like this a couple of weeks ago, too. It happened on a Saturday night off Beach drive in South Alki. 

  • Marie January 25, 2026 (12:36 pm)

    How awful, maybe call the Seattle Mayor’s Ofc.? She/they might know where you could turn to find a solution.  Thanks & take care. 

  • Rob January 25, 2026 (12:59 pm)

    I live on the same block of 44th and our group of mailboxes were also wide open this morning. It was obviously opened by key as there was no damage.  This also happened last year.

  • 1994 January 25, 2026 (10:21 pm)

    I am sorry to hear the catalytic-converter thieves are back at it. Maybe some had been jailed and recently got out only to resume their crimes? I hope these guys are caught again. 

  • Dirk January 26, 2026 (10:31 am)

    They used the stolen key  a couple of  times on our condo mailbox on SW Hudson. Our only recourse was to move the boxes inside a locked gate.

  • Post Malone January 26, 2026 (11:07 am)

    I know, it’s frustrating. I had my car stolen last year and the car dealership offered to sell me a new one. But they refuse to help.

  • Richard January 26, 2026 (1:16 pm)

    We had to change the mailbox cluster. It cost over $5,000. However if you go thru the post office, they will install and it will be cheaper.

  • ONLINE...complaint January 27, 2026 (11:20 am)

    Go to USPS online and make a formal written complaint about how the local post office is handling your situation. COMPLAIN  ONLINE  (it actually works better to do it that way.) sorry that happened…. be persistent in getting a remedy… keep going up up up to supervisors ..and supervisor’s supervisors

Sorry, comment time is over.