CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: Alki Avenue murder suspect arrested in Morgan Junction, bail set at $500,000

(June 2018 WSB photo by Christopher Boffoli)

11:04 AM: Some asked about an arrest Monday afternoon at the Morgan Junction Starbucks. Seattle Police have just announced that the person they took into custody is a suspect in last year’s murder on Alki Avenue SW near Anchor Park:

Seattle Police have arrested a 25-year-old man for the June 2nd, 2018 homicide on Alki Beach of stabbing victim Jonathan Pecina, age 28. Officers arrested the suspect in West Seattle.

Homicide detectives recently received DNA evidence from the WSP Crime Lab linking the suspect to an item left at the crime scene. This week, detectives coordinated with officers of the Southwest Precinct bicycle unit and the Southwest Precinct Anti-Crime Team in an attempt to locate and apprehend the suspect.

On Monday afternoon July 1st at about 4 pm, the suspect was located by those Southwest Precinct officers at a coffee shop at California Avenue SW and Fauntleroy Way SW. The suspect was taken into custody without incident.

Detectives interviewed the suspect and then booked him into King County Jail for investigation of murder. This remains an active and on-going investigation.

You’ll recall that SPD announced the DNA breakthrough back in January.

ADDED 1:27 PM: We asked SPD a followup question about how they found the suspect; Det. Mark Jamieson says the suspect “was known to frequent West Seattle. Officer spotted him at the coffee shop and came up with a quick plan to arrest him safely.” He is scheduled to appear before a judge this afternoon, and we’ll add any more information that emerges.

ADDED 4:16 PM: Though the suspect is not yet charged in this case, he has a high-profile West Seattle-related conviction on his record, so we are identifying him: Nickolas J. Osborne In March of last year, he set an SPD car on fire while Southwest Precinct officers were taking him to jail after arresting him for harassing Lincoln Park/Lowman Beach visitors. He pleaded guilty to malicious mischief in that case. Since then, records show, he also has served time for threatening people with a knife at a gym in Redmond – two incidents that happened just days after the West Seattle murder. Probable cause was found this afternoon to hold Osborne in lieu of $500,000 bail. We are reading the newest documents and will add any additional new details.

ADDED 4:54 PM: The probable-cause narrative begins by recounting the night of the murder, including “There were many 911 callers who reported seeing or hearing two Hispanic males and a white male yelling at each other on the inland sidewalk in front of the condominiums. One eyewitness heard the white male yell at the Hispanic male that that he hated people with saggy pants.” The three started fighting and it all ended with Jonathan Pecina being fatally stabbed. The other man with him was interviewed by police days later. He is reported to have told them:

They were confronted by a white male walking in the opposite direction. (The witness) would primarily refer to the man as a “Trump Supporter.” When asked what “Trump Supporter” meant, he claimed this person was racist against “Mexicans”. There was no further explanation of his use of the term “Trump supporter”. (The witness) said that the guy started saying “racial sh-t” including “I hate Mexicans”. Torres said they were going to walk off but “the guy kept saying sh-t”. The guy pulled out a knife. Jonathan took off his belt to use in self-defense. (The witness) said he was not wearing a belt (and) denied ever hitting the suspect. He said it all happened very fast but suddenly Pecina was stabbed.

While DNA from a knife sheath found at the scene did not bring up a match last year, this year it did, to Osborne. And, the probable-cause narrative continues, “Database research has revealed that Nickolas Osborne has been the subject of racially charged violent crimes and incidents before and since the murder of Jonathan Pecina.” They include the two we mention above; in the Lincoln Park/Lowman Beach harassment that preceded the poilce-car-torching arrest, Osborne is reported to have been saying he wanted to kill Mexicans and Black people (using a slur for the latter). In the Redmond case days after the Alki stabbing, police note, Osborne “used a knife to threaten a Hispanic male at a gym while muttering about the Illuminati, FBI, and MS-13.”

The document also says he was involved in two Alki incidents this year, a “disturbance” in March in which he was reported to be yelling racist and misogynist slurs both before and after police took him into custody, and one a little more than a week ago in which he allegedly had been pursuing “a Hispanic man” with a knife and was shot with a BB gun, later telling police “he was shot at by ‘border jumpers’ and ‘f—ing Mexicans’.”

24 Replies to "CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: Alki Avenue murder suspect arrested in Morgan Junction, bail set at $500,000"

  • Drew July 2, 2019 (11:18 am)

    That’s really good news… not that there’s anything good about any of it, but was literally just talking about this case with a friend and actually stopped at Anchor Park yesterday for some fresh air, to check out low tide and to find a moment of peace. Was thinking about this. Condolences to the victims family and friends.

  • Seattlite July 2, 2019 (11:32 am)

    Great work SPD!  It makes one wonder just how many criminals are living in our communities and waiting in line at a Starbucks near you.

  • Jon Wright July 2, 2019 (12:47 pm)

    I didn’t recall the DNA breakthrough from January so I went
    back and read that story. It included a video from Assistant Chief Nollette. At
    0:40 of the video, Chief Nollette states the police investigation determined
    that the person killed and a friend “were acting aggressively, confrontational,
    and belligerent towards other community members.” I hadn’t heard that before
    and I gotta say, it changes how I feel about what happened.

    • donttreadonme July 2, 2019 (1:13 pm)

      You feel that an extrajudicial death penalty should be the punishment for being confrontational?

      • Jeff July 2, 2019 (3:16 pm)

        I don’t think that’s what he said at all.   It just sounds a bit like the deceased was looking for trouble, and got more trouble than he bargained for.

      • Mike July 2, 2019 (5:47 pm)

        That’s not what they said.  I’m just glad they have this guy in custody now.

  • old timer July 2, 2019 (2:39 pm)

    Thanks to the “alert officer”.Hope he/she gets plus points at review time.

  • Guy July 2, 2019 (4:11 pm)

    When will we find out the suspect’s name?Was it a hate crime?

    • WSB July 2, 2019 (4:23 pm)

      I’ve actually just published it. There are indications this may have been racially motivated, as well as other incidents in which he is suspected/charged, and I will be adding more detaiis from the probable-cause documents as soon as I can accurately summarize them. One thing wrong in the document, though – it says he was arrested at the Alki Starbucks. As per the original police announcement this morning, and several tips we got yesterday afternoon, it was Morgan, not Alki. – TR

  • Kathy July 2, 2019 (5:58 pm)

    There was another murder in Alki at 61st and Alki Ave May 23rd, 2017 just down the block from where I live. Seems like there were a lot of witnesses to that one, but I haven’t  heard if anyone was charged yet. 

    • WSB July 2, 2019 (6:22 pm)

      West Seattle has several unsolved murders including that one.

  • Community Member July 2, 2019 (6:36 pm)

    Last year a significant portion of commenters assumed or implied that this crime was due to gang retaliation.  And a few commenters wanted to set up some kind of security system to keep those people away.So instead, turns out it was a hate crime by some white dude who hates minorities. Thank you Seattle Police Department for pursuing the truth.

    • Lagartija Nick July 2, 2019 (6:49 pm)

      Thank you so much for bringing this up. I remember how ugly those comments were. All of them should apologize and reflect on just how wrong they were.

      • Yo! July 3, 2019 (5:33 am)

        Yes thank you for this comment!!  I agree that it is so important to highlight the hopefully true motivations behind this crime.  I also want to thank spd for pursuing the truth and in the process of holding the perpetrator accountable  also helping society to erode away the biases/thinking that lead to this act. 

    • Bradley July 2, 2019 (8:14 pm)

      This incident was a 2-against-1 fight that ended up in the death of one of the combatants and, according to one of the participants, hateful words went both ways. Had the victim and his partner ended up killing the suspect, the fight would have still claimed a life. It’s disturbing that the person with the knife wasn’t serving a long sentence for his previous antics instead of being allowed to engage others in a deadly scuffle (which he did again in Redmond shortly after the murder). But calling the suspect “some white dude” isn’t helping the situation and is unnecessarily bringing race into an already-sad, violent death. Let the justice system determine if this murder was a hate crime or not.

  • M July 2, 2019 (7:24 pm)

    Is there a photo of the suspect? 

    • WSB July 2, 2019 (7:38 pm)

      The only mugshots available are (a) if they have served time in the state prison system, (b) if they are a registered sex offender, (c) if one is distributed by law enforcement seeking help in finding someone. #2 and #3 are n/a here. So far as I can tell I haven’t found evidence he’s been in the state prison system but I’m sending them a request tomorrow to check. – TR

  • 1994 July 2, 2019 (10:07 pm)

    Sounds like an angry, violent, and possibly mentally ill, guy who needed to be removed from the streets.  DNA scores again along with good observation skills. Thank  you for the update WSB.

    • Lagartija Nick July 3, 2019 (8:16 am)

      Yes, racists are generally angry and violent.

  • Jethro Marx July 2, 2019 (11:50 pm)

    Whoa, the FBI, Illuminati, and MS-13: we oughta get them to sit down together and hash out the world’s problems. I’ll pour the coffee.

  • Barry July 3, 2019 (11:47 am)

    Could not agree more. I was down on Alki last year explaining to my 3 year old that the candles and memorial sight were sacred and not to be touched. Some man walked by and yelled back at my son “that’s why you don’t join a gang kid”. I was appalled and was even more disappointed in the online comments  on here at the time regarding this tragedy. So many people jumped to conclusions….I’m so glad that SPD caught this person.  

  • bolo July 4, 2019 (11:06 pm)

    “… he was reported to be yelling racist and misogynist slurs…”
    Jeez, who or what could have been enabling this guy?

  • Tricia Goshorn July 6, 2019 (11:35 am)

    So let’s not charge this guy? WTF? I am so flipping pissed right now. Self defense my ass? Some guy talks smack that does not give you the right to stab them. He obviously has a serious history of violent crimes and murdering someone didn’t seem to faze him enough to quit threatening people with a knife. If you were really sorry or did it on accident you pulling a knife on somebody else three days later and threatening to kill them. God I hope this piece of s–t doesn’t kill someone else. Cuz when he does. It’s on you SPD. You should get this piece of s–t off the street. Self defense my ass!

    • WSB July 6, 2019 (11:55 am)

      SPD *did* get him off the street. They submitted their case and evidence. After that, the charging decision is up to the county prosecuting attorney’s office – a separate agency – and in this case, as amply reported above, that agency decided not to file charges “at this time.” (That could change – see the case I noted at story’s end, where a murder suspect was arrested, released days later because it was possible self-defense, then charged a few years later.) – TR

Sorry, comment time is over.