‘This model is no longer sustainable’: West Seattle’s only shelter will remain closed until ‘the next chapter’ is determined

(WSB file photo of shelter/American Legion building at 3618 SW Alaska)

After two months of closure for what was initially described as repairs and renovations, the Westside Neighbors Network has decided that its shelter in The Triangle will remain closed until further notice. Founder/manager Keith Hughes made that announcement today. Here’s the full text of what he said at a gathering today, as forwarded to us:

After seven years of service to the South West community, sharing our love made tangible through the Morning Warm-Up Center and the Winter Cold Weather Shelter, Westside Neighbors Network has made the difficult decision to temporarily close both operations and enter into a time of discernment, strategic planning, and administrative reorganization.

Through these past years we have funded the operations with an all-volunteer staff, and donations from individuals and organizations in the community. However, with the political and socio-economic time creating an ever increasing need, this model is no longer sustainable.

We have long sought sustainable funding through government and non-government partners and have not found it there – and so we are stepping back to do the careful work of building something lasting: a model rooted in the community we serve.

We don’t yet know the shape of what’s coming. But we know this: the next chapter must be written by us, supported by us, and embodied by us. The relationships, the trust, the deep roots of care – that social capital is real, and it is not going anywhere.

We are deeply grateful for every resource, every relationship, and every act of kindness and faithfulness that has carried us here – including many of you here in this room. We know that you are with us in the knowledge that West Seattle deserves a welcoming place where neighbors can rest and be restored. That conviction has not wavered.

The work of designing our new future has begun, and though we can’t give you a time line at this point, We will be back and we will keep in touch as we move through this process.

Continue to take care of one another, West Seattle.

The building that has housed the shelter and warm-up center is also the local American Legion Post 160 headquarters and West Seattle Veterans Center. Though, as the statement above notes, it’s never been officially funded or sanctioned, it’s long served as West Seattle’s only building-based emergency shelter, and at times provided space for more than 40 people to sleep, along with breakfast for more than 80. Some community members blamed its presence for increased violent street disorder in the Triangle area, which also has had an unsanctioned encampment on city-owned parkland a few blocks east. We’re following up with some questions and will add whatever more we find out.

47 Replies to "'This model is no longer sustainable': West Seattle's only shelter will remain closed until 'the next chapter' is determined"

  • Walkinroun June 9, 2026 (4:56 pm)

    There probably aren’t a lot of people left in West Seattle and Fauntleroy who remember my brother, David Jones. David died in 2015 at age 65 of multiple, painful medical conditions related to his lifelong substance abuse. In the last years of his life he had relapsed to alcohol after quitting methadone, believing he could stay sober without it. He was kicked out of Cal-Mor Circle in 2010 and spent the last 5 years of his life on the street, in recovery centers, in detox, back on the street, in hospitals, back on the street and round and round. 

    The one place I could always direct my brother was the Dutch Shisler Sobering Center in downtown Seattle. It was the one place that would always take him whatever condition he was in. He was treated with compassion, given a sandwich, a shower and a mat to sleep on. Eventually he was given a room in a supportive low barrier apartment complex. The Dutch Shisler was torn down several years ago now and replaced by a big fancy building. To my knowledge it was never restored somewhere else as had been promised. There seemed to be nowhere that someone didn’t object to siting it there.

    The Dutch Shisler had been a true safe space for my brother. I completely understand why people are nervous about shelters and the stricken people who need them. Substance abuse and mental health problems often entail behaviors that are troubling and unpredictable and sometimes dangerous. I honor those kind people who brave these behaviors to care for people like my brother. I do not judge those who do not. But I do wish we had more and better ways to serve this population.

    • Lauren June 9, 2026 (7:01 pm)

      Thanks for sharing story, and condolences on the loss of your brother.

      • walkinroun June 10, 2026 (10:01 am)

        Thank you for the link. I know there were various attempts to reopen the Dutch, but did not learn if any were successful. At the time of my brother there were zero services in West Seattle, hence having to direct him downtown, where he was often frightened himself by the increasing chaos of unwell people living on the streets.

    • X June 10, 2026 (9:04 pm)

      I remember the Dutch when the Recovery Café moved nearby. We welcomed many during the day as the Dutch did at night. When the Dutch closed, the Café took care to include on it’s property the names of homeless people who had Leaves of Remembrance laid as bronze plaques at the Dutch by the Homeless Remembrance Project. We’ve added leaves to our site since the original group was brought over.

  • North Admiral Neighbor June 9, 2026 (5:08 pm)

    Very sad to hear, the shelter provided a valuable resource for the least privileged in our community. Hoping that with enough support and volunteering from the community we can see the shelter re-open soon.

  • Alki resident June 9, 2026 (5:22 pm)

    I hope this gives a nice break for the area residents who’ve had to endure so much chaos and drama. We’ve all witnessed more than we wanted to from that building. 

    • Steve June 10, 2026 (1:22 pm)

      Exactly. I feel bad for those that really needed it but not for that constant crowds of people using it as an area to openly smoke crack. 

    • Parent June 10, 2026 (5:12 pm)

      Same. It always disturbed me seeing people fight, smoke drugs, and scream profanities at the same time my daughter and her preschool classmates were playing just on the other side of the fence.

      • Alki resident June 10, 2026 (8:17 pm)

        One of my biggest concerns was the daycare a block down. I’m so sorry the kids had to deal with all of that. 

  • aa June 9, 2026 (5:45 pm)

    Thank you Keith Hughes for everything you have done to help others throughout your life. I know you will continue your commitment as you recreate this shelter. A truly wonderful man. 

    • Rachel June 10, 2026 (12:18 pm)

      I second that! Keith Hughes is one of the most caring, compassionate people I will meet in my lifetime and his willingness to act and help those in need has made a positive impact on so many lives. Thank you, Keith – looking forward to seeing what comes next.

    • concerned about the triangle June 11, 2026 (1:50 pm)

      I would like to thank Keith for his humanity and for making a responsible decision for the community at large here. I’m sure it was difficult. Until the right amount of security is available, something had/has to change. 

  • Carol June 9, 2026 (7:10 pm)

    This center has been a beacon of hope in our community. I send out thanks to all those who have given so much to this effort. You have made a difference. All my prayers and thoughts to you as you figure out how to proceed

  • Gordon Gow June 9, 2026 (9:35 pm)

    I’m right now in an old pickup had to bolt north from my CITY Seattle 6 years ago for safety of me and Chihuahua because I have Red hair. Shelters are Volatile places as one commenter says but warm and safe. OBVIOUS this is a travesty indicative of FRAUD in City and County for bureaucratic HELP which literally sucks money and now this is only the FIRST to Shutter. It’s Seattle Holier than Thou Democrats. They won’t be happy they are congenitally disinclined to happiness, only power. 

  • Star55 June 9, 2026 (9:40 pm)

    I have made a donation every year, grant it does not make a dent to the great service Keith has provided. It saddens me to see that he cannot get any government/ state or local funding to keep this place alive.WE the WS residents need to stand up and use voice to help get funding. How many times have you driven by a homeless person and felt empathy for that person. Come on WS let’s stat up and make this a sustainable place for those less fortunate.

  • 1994 June 9, 2026 (10:29 pm)

    Years ago, the early to mid 1990s, the church located on 35th Ave SW and SW Cloverdale St opened it’s basement for overnight sleeping for homeless. My friend lived right across the street and said the arrangement seemed to work because the people had to leave by 7:00 AM. There were never large numbers of people hanging around all day.  People in those days seem better mannered and followed rules. I think the church changed hands or brands since that time. 

    • hithere June 10, 2026 (8:55 am)

      I wonder if it’s the type and prevalence of the drugs available on the street. I also see things these days that I never used to see in the 90s.

  • Sarchka June 10, 2026 (6:15 am)

    I don’t purport to be an expert on the funding streams involved, but looking at the big picture…  it really burns me up to think of the MILLIONS allotted to bureaucracies like KCRHA and here’s an organization making an actual difference who gets nothing.  We should all be 100% outraged.  

    • flimflam June 10, 2026 (11:04 am)

      Yes, KCRHA has been an utter disaster and full of either incompetence or outright fraud

  • rmk June 10, 2026 (7:18 am)

    I am sure all of the business around that place are happier.   

  • Had Enough June 10, 2026 (8:17 am)

    Thank God it closed! Nice guy Keith tried to do good and did at first. Then the violators swarmed in and took advantage turning it into a location for drug trafficking, and sex sales. Street economy took over. Get real folks, you have to see it with your own eyes. Just being nice and giving money and giving stuff does not help people, experts with experience in this field are required!

    • alkiannie June 10, 2026 (8:57 am)

      He provided beds to sleep in and pancakes in the morning for breakfast. He did not provide money to peope. Wherever there are shelters, there are challenges, even shelters ran by “experts”. 

      • Other Neighbor June 11, 2026 (12:01 pm)

        No, this place became a magnet for people looking for more than just a bed and pancakes. If you lived/worked/were in this neighborhood, you would have seen the drastic changes that happened the last couple of years. It’s a welcome relief to see this area cleaned up. It should have never been allowed to get so bad.

  • alkiannie June 10, 2026 (8:54 am)

    Thank you, Ken, for your many years of service to this community. You have saved lives. I wish you the best in your next steps, whatever they might be. This must be a difficult time for you. I hope knowing of the lives you have blessed is a condolence. 

  • Dwest June 10, 2026 (9:59 am)

    Living near this place, it was a perfect storm. Bruce Harrell’s downtown clean up scattered people out of downtown. I watched as the drug dealers set up shop on lower Alaska, it was a perfect place, right along major bus routes, it had this shelter, and a huge underutilized city property between the stadium and camp long, perfect for an encampment, on top of that the abandoned Dr. Office on Alaska and 36th became a hot bed for squatters. It got out of hand, drug addicts looking for ways to fund their addiction created a huge spike of petty and some serious crime, camp long lodge burnt down, there were other acts of violence, local businesses like mountains to sound took the brunt of petty crime, my garage and garden tools were broken into, package theft was everywhere, gas was syphoned from my neighbor’s car, another neighbor wheels stolen, copper wires stripped etc etc. overdoses seemed like a daily occurrence. I don’t blame the shelter, they operated for years in a sustainable, manageable way, but things had gotten out of hand. Today lower Alaska is a different place, it’s worlds better, they cleared the encampment, the open drug market seems to be gone, crime seems in check, it’s such a different place than just a few months ago, did it all go to someone else’s neighborhood, probably. The homeless problem here is complex and we saw how hard it is to manage, I respect what they did down at the shelter, but I also think shutting it all down was the right thing to do, because of what it had become. We just need to find better ways to manage mental illness and addiction, that’s my takeaway from it all. I want to help the homeless but I also want to feel safe in the place that I live.

    • Kadoo June 10, 2026 (5:06 pm)

      I totally agree. 

    • Karen B June 10, 2026 (11:25 pm)

      I also agree. While I really appreciate what Keith Hughes
      did to help the homeless and those in need of temporary shelter, especially in
      the winter in those early years, it was because it did seem well-managed. The people
      coming and going from there seemed non-threatening when I’d pass them on the sidewalk.
       

      In recent years, the mix of mentally ill people acting aggressively,
      and druggies taking advantage of bus shelters, and the sheer number of them (!), have made my walks to nearby businesses feel unsafe. I’m not just a worry-wort: some dude threatened to slit my throat one day, and I considered crossing Alaska against traffic to avoid him. Heartbreaking how Camp Long has been impacted…

    • Jfp June 11, 2026 (6:11 am)

      Well said. I agree. As wonderful as Kieth’s intentions are, he was over his head attracting despondent addicts to this shelter. Hot coffee and a bed is short-term relief but at the cost of safety and wellbeing to business, the childcare center and the public. Unfortunately in the age of “fetty”’addiction shelters need a clear program and pipeline of services. Without that, the neighborhood greatly suffers. 

    • JunctionResident June 11, 2026 (9:49 am)

      Totally agree. We can acknowledge that Keith is a kind-hearted man who is compassionate but also that the situation at hand outside the Legion was unsustainable and was spiraling out of control for neighbors.

    • Donn June 13, 2026 (5:18 am)

      I couldn’t have said  it better, Dwest was spot on!

  • Medium June 10, 2026 (12:39 pm)

    Great news! The area around SW Alaska Street had gotten incredibly dangerous. Since the shelter closed it has been so much better. Stolen merchandise, graffiti, drugs, violence, and overdose deaths. Now it’s time to heal from the lives and businesses destroyed.

    • Bob June 10, 2026 (1:24 pm)

      ⬆️ 100%

  • Sea Lemon June 10, 2026 (3:08 pm)

    Thank you to Keith and everyone who volunteered their time and energy to this shelter. Keeping people warm and safe is a beautiful, powerful endeavor and not for the faint of heart. I understand there will be complicated feelings about this throughout the neighborhood, but I firmly believe every warm night and cup of coffee served made a material impact on the lives of people suffering.I hope everyone involved feels proud of the work they have done.

  • DemandCurve June 10, 2026 (6:20 pm)

    All according to plan..,, we cannot have any homelessness resources being spent outside the local monopoly / racket.  If they could close the churches they would.

  • Denden June 11, 2026 (6:59 am)

    The Westside Neighbors Shelter on SW Alaska Street is currently closed until further notice, and the change in the surrounding neighborhood has been impossible to miss.Before anyone misunderstands my point, I respect the volunteers and the people who have worked hard to help those in need. Their intentions are good.However, for years the area around the shelter has struggled with drug use, overdoses, encampments, garbage, vandalism, public intoxication, and human waste. I work at the Grove Inn, one block away, and these problems were a regular part of daily life for nearby businesses, residents, and visitors.Since the shelter closed and the city cleaned up nearby encampments, the neighborhood has become noticeably cleaner, safer, and more welcoming. The difference is visible to anyone who spends time in the area.That reality should prompt an honest discussion about whether this shelter belongs in the middle of a residential and business district. Good intentions do not erase real-world consequences.Compassion for those in need is important. But compassion must also extend to the residents, businesses, park users, and visitors who live with the impacts every day.West Seattle deserves both compassion and accountability.

    • k June 11, 2026 (8:41 am)

      If a shelter “doesn’t belong” in business or residential areas, does that mean all homeless people should be filed away in industrial areas?  Away from any resources like transit and libraries, which will make them less able to engage in services and more likely to die, but at least they’ll be out of view when it happens?

      You can have compassion and accountability in residential neighborhoods and business districts.  This whole post is just a laundry list of concern trolling talking points from people who don’t see the homeless population as worthwhile enough to be a part of the solution. I look forward to the day when housed people and businesses look in the mirror and ask for accountability for themselves too. 

      • JunctionResident June 11, 2026 (9:51 am)

        Lets open a shelter across the street from your residence and see how you feel about the situation.

        • k June 11, 2026 (4:54 pm)

          Like this, right here.  Not helpful, nothing here about solving the problem.  People need to hold themselves accountable for polluting the conversation with snark, and impeding real solutions.  Your assumptions are unhelpful (and wrong, but that’s beside the point).  All comments like that do is call yourself out as deeply unserious.  Your neighbors deserve better.

          • Not Snark June 13, 2026 (8:19 am)

            Do you want a shelter across from your house?  That question is not snark. You’re deflecting because the answer is “no”. 

    • concerned about the triangle June 11, 2026 (6:29 pm)

      well said. I am very happy for the Grove and all the surrounding residents, businesses, and care facilities. This was not a sustainable model – maybe it would have been with adequate safety and security but who knows. I have the utmost admiration for Keith and the shelter’s intentions and core mission. Maybe one day there can be a safe coexistence but for now the reprieve from unsafe activity is a relief.

    • Suzanne June 11, 2026 (11:18 pm)

      I strongly agree with everything you said. Excellent comment. Keith Hughes put his heart and soul into trying to provide an essential service to people in need. However, the depth of their needs is FAR greater than any good hearted person can shoulder even when he puts everything he has on the line to try to make it work. Thank you for giving it your all Keith Hughes. Your legacy will always be extraordinary kindness and being willing to do the hard (so hard!) work. 

      The future use of the building needs to be something that lifts the neighborhood up. 

      And the City of Seattle with its massive but stretched budget needs to figure out real solutions to the homelessness crisis and drug use. Drug addiction is as important to address as homelessness. The two issues can’t be separated. 

  • Scarlett June 11, 2026 (9:26 am)

    This entire economic model is not sustainable.  Private charity is not the answer,  a nanny state is not the answer, either.  The problem is, and the Elephant in the Room,  millions of us are invested – or ensnared to be more generous – in this corrupt economic model.   And yes, even the poor are an engine of this corrupt economic model.  This is why real change never happens,  save some extraordinary event, a Black Swan, or such.      

  • Bill Schrier June 13, 2026 (5:52 pm)

    I talked to a Seattle City Council member about Keith Hughes’ compassionate work and the need for a homeless shelter in West Seattle.  This Council member agreed, but said the American Legion site was not properly licensed and the building was not suitable.  But still, West Seattle have no alternative, despite the $228 million invested by the City each year in homelessness, and hundreds of millions more by King County.  The closure of this site without an alternative is a travesty.

    • Karen B June 13, 2026 (11:17 pm)

      Thanks Bill, I appreciate that you reached out to City
      Council, and I agree that the closure of this site without any alternatives is
      going to be very hard on the people that Keith Hughes has been helping.

       

      Following is a more general comment about funding for homelessness – just my two cents worth.

       

      In my mind the travesty is how big tech and other very
      profitable businesses in this region (and elsewhere in this country)
      have been able to ignore the income disparity that they have created.

       

      I can’t speak to the drug addiction problems and homelessness
      generally, but I can speak to the fact that tech workers that I knew “back in
      the day“ when I was a tech worker, were let go and almost immediately replaced
      by contractors and workers from other places who could be hired for lesser
      wages.

       

      The Mike Maples of this world deserve a special place in
      “history” for labeling workers being laid off at Microsoft as “dead wood” (in
      the Seattle Times) and covering up and glossing over those relatively early
      layoffs in tech. 

       

      If the millions being spent now to deal with this
      fallout aren’t enough to create much measurable or observable change –
       my thought is that the tech industry and the huge corporations that have
      sprung up in their wake, need to pay a bigger share to solve this
      problem. 

       

      No one seems to be saying this out loud. So I’m
       saying it in memory of a very good tech writer who was laid off from my
      workplace… who I spotted a year or two later in downtown Seattle discreetly
      looking in trash cans.

       

      What do the corporate heads think happens when they lay off
      multiple workers in the same field at the same time? What do they think happens when they downplay what they’re doing in the media? What do they think happens when HR departments or AI software rejects folks who have gaps in their work experience?

  • Denden June 14, 2026 (6:21 am)

    Back in the day as I remember people saying “Good riddence to bad rubbish.” 

  • Claiborne June 29, 2026 (9:33 pm)

    There is a noticeable difference in the area since the closure.  I am sure the businesses and residents in the immediate area would agree that things are cleaner and safer.

Sorry, comment time is over.