FOLLOWUP: Almost a month later, SUV still on West Seattle beach

It’s been almost a month since somebody drove that Jeep Compass onto the rocky beach between Seola and The Arroyos. (Here’s our original report; police later told us the vehicle’s owner belatedly reported it stolen.) While other vehicle-in-water cases have resulted in relatively rapid removal, this one is still there. Area resident Robin, awho sent the photos above and below, has been tracking the situation, and campaigning to get something done about it.

Most recently, Robin filed an illegal-dumping report via Find It Fix It. Seattle Public Utilities, which runs the illegal-dumping program, referred it to Seattle Parks. But Parks closed the ticket, telling Robin in a follow-up call that it’s not on Parks property. Meantime, it’s not just beached, it’s in and out of the water as the tide fluctuates:

That photo is from Tim, who was startled to see the semi-submerged SUV while out paddling last Saturday. The question remains, who’s ultimately accountable for getting it off the beach? In our most-recent round of inquiries more than a week ago, the state Ecology Department – which had responded to the scene early on, to remove fuel from the vehicle – said it was a “police matter” and that local law enforcement needed to work with the beach owners. After that, we asked SPD where it stood, and they repeated what had been mentioned before – tow trucks couldn’t get close enough to remove it: “There have been discussions with the Department of Ecology, U.S. Coast Guard and others, but it remains in the water for now.”

That it does.

60 Replies to "FOLLOWUP: Almost a month later, SUV still on West Seattle beach"

  • Alki resident May 15, 2024 (10:51 pm)

    Wait until the tide is in and get a tug boat or something to get it maybe? Could a smaller ferry show up with a tow truck on board?

    • Ben May 16, 2024 (6:11 am)

      It isn’t going to be deep enough during high tide for most vessels sturdy enough to assist with something of this scope without either getting beached themselves or taking on damage. Maybe a small landing craft with ramp & winch could be chartered but they’ve got a lot of other business this time of year they would have to pass up to assist so it would be high cost & probably require paying for a survey of the landing before they would give a definite answer given how rocky the beach is. If accessible, a crane will need to be positioned on the property of a local resident to try to recover from the beach, it is doubtful that someone will want to grant access & waive potential damages to their property. They’re probably going to have to float this out into the water to try to recover. Any feasible plan is going to be expensive & well beyond the value of the claim against the wreck.

    • Daniel May 16, 2024 (7:58 am)

      You’d need to jack the SUV, float it on something with a very specific size, and then pull it away with a longer leash.  Can’t use just a tug, because the tug couldn’t get close enough.  Seems feasible I guess, probably just a matter of figuring out who pays for that operation.

      • TQ May 16, 2024 (11:26 pm)

        It would t require a tug to move it once floating. Basically any boat would be able to move it. It’s really not that complicated if an issue. Float it with a couple inflatable bag and move it somewhere where a tow truck could have access.

    • Curious George May 16, 2024 (4:41 pm)

      There are companies that specialize in servicing islands in the Sound / San Juan’s that have no docks with barges & landing craft that can get next to this car and winch it onto the craft.

    • Mamook May 18, 2024 (3:21 pm)

      Landing craft could do it…..

    • Drey May 20, 2024 (8:27 pm)

      You would think that would be the owners insurance responsibility to retrieve the vehicle. Also, last time I saw it, it was fairly close, couldn’t imagine it’s that difficult to hook it up by the crane and pull it up… 

  • C May 15, 2024 (11:22 pm)

    Classic “pass the buck” situation. Lovely. 

    • Bill May 16, 2024 (12:22 am)

      Your tax dollars at work!

    • Frog May 16, 2024 (12:33 am)

      More like hold on to your bucks — no one wants to bear the cost.  Seems like this would fall to the owner’s insurance company, unless the owner didn’t have insurance.

      • Claudia Williams May 16, 2024 (6:31 am)

        Yes, by law, the owner is ultimately responsible for the recovery/salvage of the vehicle. This case made me take a close look at my car insurance to check my coverage. In the meantime, municipalities routinely have to manage costly cleanups and will figure out who will pay for it later. This is another sign that our leadership is inept and I’m sure plenty of people actually working for the city, county, state can devise a way of removing this vehicle in a month’s time. This is pathetic!

      • waikikigirl May 16, 2024 (7:11 am)

        I agree with “Frog”  shouldn’t it fall on the owners responsibility  and their insurance to get this out of the water…oh wait like “Frog” said, maybe the owner had no insurance. 

        • 1994 May 16, 2024 (10:25 pm)

          But they could be sent a bill for the cost of removal. And taken to court if they don’t pay. Seems like the owner should be held responsible for the expense of removal.  Is this in city or county turf, or is it state since it is tideland?

    • Foop May 16, 2024 (9:41 am)

      Sounds like SPD, glad we just gave them a raise

      • Anne May 16, 2024 (3:04 pm)

        What an inane comment. Why should SPD haul it out? 

  • Gina May 15, 2024 (11:47 pm)

    Make it into an oyster bed?

  • David Hutchinson May 16, 2024 (12:23 am)

    Has anyone contacted Puget Sound Keepers to see if they can be of assistance?

    https://pugetsoundkeeper.org/strategies/

    “We accomplish our mission by actively patrolling the waters of Puget Sound, enforcing the Clean Water Act, engaging with businesses, government, agencies and community members, and pursuing strong policy and proactive solutions to the problem of toxic pollution.”

  • miws May 16, 2024 (12:35 am)

    Drain/strip it of all toxins, float it out and sink it at sea, to become a reef for marine life. —Mike 

    • Jeepney May 16, 2024 (7:28 am)

      Please, no.  That would be an ecological nightmare.

    • Question Authority May 16, 2024 (8:44 am)

      By the time the full removal of toxins was accomplished there would only be window glass left, even the painted steel frame would have to go.  Entirety impractical, much like just leaving it there.

      • k May 16, 2024 (11:02 am)

        Based on the pictures here vs. a month ago, the window glass was the first thing nature reclaimed.

  • Rhonda May 16, 2024 (2:41 am)

    Pull off the plastics, drain the fluids and let nature take it back.

  • Mike May 16, 2024 (5:23 am)

    It’s the responsibility of the vehicle owners insurance company to get it out.  Beach property owners need to sue the insurance company.  The state (Bob Ferguson) needs to sue the insurance company for leaving a biohazard in the state waterway.

    • TQ May 16, 2024 (11:29 pm)

      With the oil and gas removed it’s not really a bio hazard. 

    • Cori May 17, 2024 (9:35 am)

      Bob Ferguson will sue alot of people but insurance companies are not amongst them. 

  • Private land May 16, 2024 (5:55 am)

    Those waterfront houses have owners rights to the extreme low tide. Their land, their problem it seems. 

    • Chuck Jacobs May 16, 2024 (10:30 am)

      The waterfront property owner only owns to the high tide line unless it’s a pre-statehood, (Nov 1889) homestead, or purchased from the state prior to 1971. Otherwise the state owns all tidal lands.

      • TQ May 16, 2024 (11:30 pm)

        Wrong a lot of beachfront homes in Washington own the beaches in front of their houses. 

      • Cori r May 17, 2024 (9:46 am)

        That’s incorrect. Property lines in that area extend into sidelines. 

      • Cori r May 17, 2024 (9:48 am)

  • anonyme May 16, 2024 (6:32 am)

    What a sickening display of both bureaucratic incompetence and ecological apathy.  The car was driven to its current location, so the excuse that the location is inaccessible is clearly rubbish.

  • Dan May 16, 2024 (6:58 am)

    what a joke.  This can’t be that difficult to take care of.   Someone needs to step up and do the right thing.A winch an/or a come along would move it to someplace where a tow truck could access it. 

  • Sheila May 16, 2024 (7:00 am)

    A Jeep Compass was responsible for a hit and run at 15th ave and Roxbury,  where a man was killed. Could this be the car?

    • WSB May 16, 2024 (10:01 am)

      No, that’s already been asked and answered. This was already on the beach before that incident.

  • flimflam May 16, 2024 (7:48 am)

    Petty pasing of the buck. One of these agencies needs to suck it up and think of the greater good…jeez.

  • bill May 16, 2024 (7:56 am)

    Surely there is a marine salvage company that could deal with this.

  • don May 16, 2024 (7:59 am)

    I’m thinking of the home owners of beachfront property who claim to own to the low tide line, if you can’t walk there you can’t drive there.   

  • Jennifer May 16, 2024 (8:10 am)

    It seems like if it can’t be pulled out it should be able to be cut up into smaller pieces and removed. It’s not doing to ocean life any good that is for sure. Just because the fuel is gone does not mean there aren’t other chemicals leaking. 

  • sbre May 16, 2024 (8:40 am)

    It’s embarrassing how long this has been going on!!People from around the country have asked me why no one is removing it from the water.

  • GCM May 16, 2024 (9:22 am)

    Contact a local (semi-local Eastern WA or OR) off road club or group. They would have the exact experience and equipment needed to get this back to a point where a city tow truck could recover it. See YouTube “Matt’s off road recovery “ for inspiration. G

  • Seola lover May 16, 2024 (9:35 am)

    There are a few points of beach access in the area. If a tow company wants to make some money from an insurance claim, they can get to the vehicle. It will be a lot of work but it can be done.  Someone HAS to pay to get it off the beach. It’s not going to move itself. 

  • FishOn May 16, 2024 (10:20 am)

    Drag it out to 60 feet low tide and sink it.  Will make a great fishing structure.

  • Josh May 16, 2024 (10:25 am)

    To be honest if you paid me like $100 an hour I would go down there on my weekends with a ratchet set, a hammer, and a couple other small tools and disassemble the car piece by piece and carry it out.  Seems like a fun project for a couple people for a couple days.  It wouldnt be too hard until you got to the engine block but it also would not take that much time and energy to slog it off the beach manually.

  • HS May 16, 2024 (10:55 am)

    Perhaps float bladders (inflatable pontoon balloons), inflated underneath, then pulled to a boat ramp where a tow truck could take over?

    https://maxwelltanks.com/emissions-control-devices/pontoon/inflatable-pontoon-balloon/

    • ArroyoGirl May 17, 2024 (9:11 am)

      A few years ago, not far away from this SUV, A large sailboat sunk and was somewhat buried in for about a month. Then in a few hours it was raised using the bladders mentioned above and was towed away. Surely this would work rather easily to remove this SUV. Or as another commenter mentioned, tow it out beyond the drop-off as possibly the least expensive solution. Currently it’s like 3D crime graffiti. Needs to go. 

  • Rob May 16, 2024 (11:34 am)

    Can’t they just give it a jump start an drive it back out?

  • John Alfers May 16, 2024 (12:03 pm)

    Isn’t this the auto insurance companies responsibility?    Also, I scuba dived for a few years around Puget Sound and Hood Canal.  Objects like this car make great homes for octopus, eals and sealife of all kinds. A good boat can hookup at high tide and drag it out to a 60′ depth, after it’s been stripped of tires and seats, of course. The rest will eventually deteriorate and return to the earth. 

  • Actually Mike May 16, 2024 (12:14 pm)

    The punk(s) that stole this vehicle, took it for a joyride and then left it out there at low tide are still laughing.

  • Mellow Kitty May 16, 2024 (12:49 pm)

    I’ve had it with the RV people. I tried to be understanding. I tried to be tolerant. They blew it. I’m sick of them coming into my work space, blazing out, and leaving garbage everywhere. They pee wherever they want. They poop on the sidewalk and lawn. Enough is enough. Get them out! I don’t care how they do it at this point. Just get them out! 

    • WS98 May 18, 2024 (7:13 am)

      Unless you have proof the vehicle was stolen by someone who is unhoused, your comments are completely unrelated to this situation. 

  • The Earl May 16, 2024 (12:57 pm)

    All arguments and opinions aside. This is completely ridiculous. One more strike against the most poorly run nonprofit in existence. 

  • Jort May 16, 2024 (1:28 pm)

    Sort of interesting that some community members seem to care so, so much about retaining parking for cars at Alki than about a car literally poisoning the water, right now.

  • Jim P. May 16, 2024 (2:05 pm)

    Owner gets it out or the city/county does it and bills the owner.  This is not rocket surgery.This finer pointing to the next person or agency is a sign of increasingly disfunctional government.

  • Rhonda May 16, 2024 (4:19 pm)

  • lb May 16, 2024 (6:48 pm)

    as some one else noted….how about breaking this down into smaller parts?.  Disassemble and cart off section by section.  auto body team could tackle it.  hoping toxic fluids and their containers have been/ can be removed before further contamination occurs. there is a public “community day of service” coming up. This would be a good project!

  • Admiral-2009 May 16, 2024 (10:39 pm)

    Maybe an email to the manufacturer of the Jeep vehicle with verbiage stating this vehicle does not live up to the hype as a rugged off road vehicle might help.

  • WSPK May 17, 2024 (8:06 am)

    Get the military to haul it out as a training exercise. They routinely do mountain rescue and charge the expense to their training budget. A Chinook or Blackhawk could easily lift that.

  • anne May 19, 2024 (12:01 am)

    Couldn’t the people just start dismantling it onw piece at a time? where are the machinists? And how about those community college students wanting to learn from their teachers? crazy thought but why not? we have an auto school at south seattle community college I think. Lets just take care of it!

  • S May 22, 2024 (1:47 pm)

    Leadership?  Anyone read the book “the dog poop initiative”? Seems eerily familiar.   Sad reflection of our times.

  • batgurrl May 29, 2024 (8:30 am)

    Update – Went down there on Monday 5/27 and it is still there. Many have suggested that it be pulled apart piece by piece.  Well, mother nature and vandalism is doing that for us.  The hood has become unattached and I found it a few yards north on the beach covered in seaweed.   Neighbors told me they found some other smaller parts north and were taking them home to the trash.   I personally flipped the hood over and over to get it up into the driftwood.  Hope that keeps it from floating off for a bit.

Sorry, comment time is over.