Redo for faded bricks at Statue of Liberty Plaza? Alki Community Council hears about that + 2 big summer events

(December 27, 2022, photo by Deb Holbrook)

King tides have swamped Alki Statue of Liberty Plaza multiple times in recent years, and that’s just part of why many of the inscribed bricks that comprise much of the plaza have faded into illegibility. A suggestion for restoring them was brought to the Alki Community Council last night, from one of the community advocates who made the plaza happen 15 years ago. She wonders what you think of the idea.

Libby Carr doesn’t live in West Seattle now, but did in the mid-’00s, when she and husband Paul Carr fought bureaucracy and amassed serious fundraising to first recast the statue and then create a new base for it and a plaza befitting it. The statue was re-dedicated in 2007, the plaza a year later. A major part of the fundraising came from selling more than 3,000 inscribed bricks and plaques. Now, after almost 15 years of wind, waves, and sand, it’s all but impossible to go to the plaza and find “your” brick.

Libby Carr told the ACC that her research has turned up someone who says he could reinscribe the bricks with a method that would be much longer-lasting. He estimated the 3,003 bricks could be reinscribed for about $60,000. The cost of removing and replacing them would have to be determined, though. But Carr sees a way to cover much if not all the costs: She says the ramp down to the plaza, built some years later, could hold 29 inscribed plaques that could be sold for $5.000 each, raising $145,000 for starters, more than double what it would cost to fix the bricks.

In the years since the plaza was dedicated, a maintenance fund – left over from the $350,000 raised for the plaza and statue – has seen Parks and the ACC partner on keeping the plaza maintained, but they’ve tried many ways to protect and restore the inscribed bricks, without much success. But Carr had a key question: Does the community care? Are West Seattleites – both those who bought bricks/plaques and those who did not – interested? “Is there will and desire in the community to do this all over?” (If you have a thought either way, consider commenting below.) The ACC agreed to talk about this again at its next meeting. Carr said she’d be happy to come back.

Two other topics of note:

ALKI ART FAIR: Its longtime leader Giovannina Souers brought this year’s toplines. Three days again this year, July 21st through 23rd, 2 pm-8 pm Friday, 10 am-8 pm Saturday, 10 am-6 pm Sunday. They have more than 80 artists lined up for this year. The AAF is a nonprofit, and powered by volunteers – Souers says more are needed, as well as a vice president who will then step up to president (she has been president off and on for the festival’s quarter-century of existence and is about to have to step down again due to term limitation). You can find out how to get involved via the Alki Art Fair website.

ALKI BEACH PRIDE: Roger Starkweather was there with an early Alki Beach Pride preview. Biggest change this year – a street party on Alki Avenue SW. It will be closed from Harry’s Beach House to Blue Moon Burgers for activities noon-7 pm on August 20th; then there’ll be a movie at Alki Playfield at 8 pm. ABP will feature a beer garden, entertainment, kids’ activities, vendors, and more. They’re expecting about a thousand people to attend. “It’s not about a big show, it’s about community.” They’re still accepting vendor applications, too.

Alki Community Council meets at 7 pm on the third Thursday of most months, in person at Alki UCC (6115 SW Hinds) and online via Zoom.

43 Replies to "Redo for faded bricks at Statue of Liberty Plaza? Alki Community Council hears about that + 2 big summer events"

  • Star55 June 16, 2023 (10:04 pm)

    Yes I want my brick re-done and saved. 

  • WS Resident June 16, 2023 (10:44 pm)

    How coincidental, I was down there this evening and looking for the bricks we got and noticed they were all worn off. I’m really surprised they weren’t etched deeper initially. Poor quality for sure. 

  • Christine June 16, 2023 (11:14 pm)

    Happy to donate to get our brick freshened. We are on top of the stairs along with a bunch of people we know, which is fun and they seem abit less worn up there. Every time we have guests in town we go visit our brick. Thanks Libby for all the dedication to this project. Really appreciate it.

  • Karen White June 16, 2023 (11:20 pm)

    I would appreciate having our commemorative and memorial bricks visible again.  It would mean a lot to me.

  • Alki Resident June 17, 2023 (12:19 am)

    Honestly, I’d rather let the brick engravings fade than have the plaza needlessly torn up. Save the restoration for the next time they actually need to be removed.

    • Anne June 17, 2023 (7:44 am)

      It’s not needlessly-This is that time. 

    • LK June 17, 2023 (9:27 am)

      I totally agree. Erosion will continue. We would be best served to wait until the area becomes damaged enough to warrant digging it up and redoing the small plaza then. Also, is there any process where the bricks could be re-engraved on place? Any hand tool with the right craft person that could do the job in the short term? 

  • Chris J June 17, 2023 (12:48 am)

    My family has enjoyed having our brick be part of the plaza, and check on it every time we walk through. I would love to see these restored, and though a $5,000 plaque is out of reach, I’d be happy to contribute something to the effort again if the opportunity arises. I also wonder if it might be possible to edit the bricks during the restoration, as my husband changed his last name once we were able to marry?

  • Jim June 17, 2023 (1:09 am)

    The old pedestal was beautiful It might have needed some work but I loved the flowers that were planted around it. I think what’s there now is a modern looking downgrade

    (Note I’m not talking about the bricks but the base of the statue and lay out)

  • David Hutchinson June 17, 2023 (1:10 am)

    I agree that the brick inscription illegibility is a major problem at the Plaza and I certainly hope the best solution for this is found. I am very grateful to Libby and Paul for the hard work they put in against the odds to make the Plaza a reality. My wife and I worked with the Seattle Statue of Liberty Plaza Project and then the Alki Community Council. She dealt with donors and their inscriptions and I entered all those inscriptions in Excel spreadsheets to be submitted to the vendor. Those records still exist, and if the decision is to replace the existing pavers with all new clay bricks, as is being considered, they could be passed along to the new vendor Libby has dealt with. The existing bricks, which are concrete pavers, had the inscriptions sandblasted into their surface to a depth of approximately 1/4 inch which was standard for that material. The letters and graphic symbols were then filled with black grout. That method was recommended to the SSLPP as best for a high traffic area. The inscriptions and grout are still there, but over the 12-15 years the bricks have been in place, they and that grout has been subjected to UV fading, salt spray and water during the periodic king tides. This has resulted in the inscriptions being visible when wet and pretty much illegible when dry – see the photos taken about 1 month ago below..DryWetWet after being hosed off

    • Pelicans June 17, 2023 (7:23 am)

      My brick is all but illegible, too.Here’s an idea:  How about replacing all those old bricks with used bricks from Seattle streets?  The bricks are right under our current streets and roads and have lasted for a century or more. They are not your normal red bricks found in buildings.  They are usually a base covered over in asphalt on streets, but are occasionally dug up to completely repave a road.  They are bigger, deeper, denser, sturdier, and longer than ordinary bricks. I have seen them for sale at Second Use, and have helped a neighbor move  blocks of them into her garden.  How about reusing these?

    • LyndaB June 18, 2023 (9:09 am)

      I don’t have a brick down there but perhaps we can take the opportunity to digitize the vwet version and allow people to view it from a website.  Seems like a great school project or scout project.

  • Kathy June 17, 2023 (6:03 am)

    I would also be in favor of restoring the bricks.  Ours is barely visible and is a family memorial to parents who have passed. 

  • PeterT June 17, 2023 (6:44 am)

    I was just going to go down there and fill my two bricks in with a Sharpie….

    • StupidInSeattle June 18, 2023 (3:44 pm)

      I intended for our brick to both restore the Liberty statue plaza and be a lasting legacy for our two sons to enjoy for years into the future.  I favor restoration of the engraved bricks.

  • sbre June 17, 2023 (7:55 am)

    Declan, my nephew, and I would love to see our and others’ bricks restored and would be happy to contribute some for the work.

  • Vee June 17, 2023 (8:00 am)

    I had 2 done in hopes they would always be there but if it’s a lot of work and money it’s ok if not done

  • Kitcat June 17, 2023 (8:09 am)

    While I would like our brick legible, waiting until the plaza needs major repairs, not  just brick replacement, makes most sense to me. The cost of resetting bricks will be key; imagine that could be exorbitantly expensive.  Any ideas for etching of bricks to last longer if replaced?  

  • Wyndi Rejniak June 17, 2023 (8:35 am)

    Great timing! I was just there with my son and wanted to show him the brick that we did for me and his dads wedding date. Sadly, we cld barely read it. Fully support the redo. Would love to add my kiddos name too. 

  • Fiona June 17, 2023 (9:10 am)

    I would appreciate my family’s brick being restored, and would consider contributing.  David’s pictures show that some more research could be done into coating the bricks with a “shellac” that would both enhance the names and protect them.

  • ACG June 17, 2023 (9:13 am)

    Yes!  We’d like our brick re-inscribed and would even purchase another if they opened it up again! We’d be happy to contribute to a fund for the cost.

  • Buzzy June 17, 2023 (9:29 am)

    The last time I visited the statue I was very sad to see a blank slate where my brick had been. Restoration would be so wonderful.

  • Alki Eric June 17, 2023 (9:40 am)

    It looks fine, so many better ways to spend money at our parks, this seems vain…just look at David’s pictures, it’s fine, move on. 

    • clinker June 17, 2023 (2:28 pm)

      Hear hear. Let’s use our resources to improve Alki for everyone rather than the vanity of a few.

      • Brynn June 18, 2023 (9:06 am)

        I don’t think it’s vanity and would love to contribute to restore the bricks. Our family has one brick. It has the names of my Dad and brother who have both passed. Me and my Mom walk down to Alki and go “sit with the boys”. I know it’s just a brick but it hurts a little to see it fading. 

  • KL June 17, 2023 (9:48 am)

    We would love for our brick inscription to be restored and would be happy to contribute in order to help this project happen. Thank you for initiating the conversation!

  • waikikigirl June 17, 2023 (10:19 am)

    Instead of replacing them, maybe some sort of sealant can be put on them so as to keep them in that wet look as in David’s picture, but not slippery. ??? 

  • Marie June 17, 2023 (11:41 am)

    I’m willing to contribute to restoring the bricks. I enjoy “visiting” my brick and reading the inscriptions on others. There’s a lot of West Seattle history there, and that is worth preserving. Grass roots community efforts like this should be encouraged. Thank you, Libby and Paul. 

  • Placman June 17, 2023 (12:24 pm)

    Ignored in all of this?

    CLIMATE CHANGE

    The photo  of king tide, moon and storm surge flooding is the unfortunate future of the whole plaza. 
    Anything an everything done to protect what exists at the plaza elevation will be exposed to increasing ocean flooding and sand erosion. 

    Although I have family who have ‘fading’ bricks, I embrace the narrative lessons of nature and our changing world.

    • WS Res June 17, 2023 (1:55 pm)

      Exactly. This is literally the equivalent of building sandcastles on the beach and then mourning when the tide washes them away.

      • Placman June 20, 2023 (12:02 pm)

        After the Statue’s dedication in 1886, the Black Press began to debunk romantic notions of the Statue of Liberty and American History. Racism and discrimination towards African Americans did not end after the Civil War or with the dedication of the Statue – it continued on for more than a century. As a result, the Statue was not a symbol of democratic government or Enlightenment ideals for African Americans but rather a source of pain. Instead of representing freedom and justice for all, the Statue emphasized the bitter ironies of America’s professed identity as a just and free society for all people regardless of race. From the time of the Statue’s dedication, attitudes towards the Statue in the African American community were ambivalent and uncertain.” National Park Service

         https://www.nps.gov/stli/learn/historyculture/abolition.htm#:~:text=After%20the%20Statue%27s%20dedication%20in,for%20more%20than%20a%20century

        Many things have transpired since the bricks were purchased.  
        With the perspective of the last few years and finally the emergence of our acknowledgement of our occupation of indigenous lands, if any work is to be done, it should be done as an expansive, embracing, non-colonial tinged monument inclusive of Black and Indigenous Peoples. 

  • PlantTrees June 17, 2023 (1:17 pm)

    I too have several bricks that my family visited and enjoyed, but I agree that climate change and resulting flooding will again degrade any refurbishing done and that effort is better spent for example to plant native trees. 

  • Alki family... June 17, 2023 (2:20 pm)

    Yes we care!! I can speak for several families who have bricks lovingly dedicated to family members who would like them restored! Thanks to Libby and Paul for doing the hard work years ago in wrangling the donations and the brick work. I’m happy to help this time around if WSB wants to give Libby my contact info and I’m also willing to donate again.  The degradation can’t  all be due to the King tides btw — I believe we may have been sold an inferior product (brick or engraving or grout?). One of our tiles is on the street level and quite protected from foot traffic and yet it’s  completely unreadable – even with water on it. Not sure how to explain that. In any case, yes, let’s fix these up for all the people who bought them the first time with promises of “forever tiles” at Alki.

  • Millie June 17, 2023 (2:38 pm)

     Does someone have a listing of all the individuals who purchased  bricks in the past?  Reason for asking, pretty sure I did, but truly can’t remember.  Any help would be appreciated to jog my memory.

  • David Hutchinson June 17, 2023 (6:59 pm)

    Millie – Yes, there is a complete database of brick purchasers. It is searchable by first name, last name of the person who paid for the brick or by words in the inscription. If you email me at libertyplaza@msn.com with any or all of that information, I should be able to let you know if you have a brick in the plaza.The database includes all bricks purchased first through the Northwest Programs for the Arts – 450 bricks, then through the SSLPP – 1,907 bricks, and finally through the ACC – 646 bricks.

    Photo courtesy of The Bronze Works. The original Alki Statue of Liberty is in the background.

  • Matt B June 17, 2023 (9:23 pm)

    I’m in favor of restoration.  My family enjoys visiting our two personalized bricks down on Alki, one of which is dedicated to my late grandpa.

  • WiseWoman June 18, 2023 (12:14 pm)

    Restoring and etching with protection would be better than doing any kind if plaques. Plaques are brass and or bronze and we know metal thieves steal everything even bolted down. – that is why replaced statue of kids on WSB side. 

  • Another idea June 18, 2023 (8:51 pm)

    Since the plaza floods. Why not leave the bricks as is?  They are functional. Instead, Add a beautiful poured concrete banister on both sides of the stairs going down to the plaza from Alki.  The banister walls could have the current names of the plaza on them.  The names would be out of the unstoppable king tide flood water & the banister walls would visually frame the Statue of Liberty from the street side.  Just an idea. 

  • Another idea June 18, 2023 (9:06 pm)

    This vibe Or something  

  • Joe June 19, 2023 (1:20 am)

    Might be time to think about raising that retaining wall?  No? King tides are just going to continue to happen….right?  

  • Leaving a legacy June 19, 2023 (5:41 pm)

    Definitely want restoration. Our family saved to have our brick engraved and placed at Alki, the birthplace of Seattle. 

  • Geje00 June 19, 2023 (8:15 pm)

    I know we’re talking about bricks, but… regarding the Statue of Liberty, I’ve always felt the newer base lacked something. The statue should be a little higher and some sort of circular wide base   with nice stones should be constructed to look more substantial. That whole section should be upgraded.

  • Susan Crow July 3, 2023 (3:25 pm)

    My father’s name is on one of those bricks and I would like for it to stay there.Thank you,Susan Crow

Sorry, comment time is over.