West Seattle buses: Metro service reminder; questions answered

First, that reminder: Long before Snowstorm ’08, as we were reminded last week, Metro had been planning to run a “partial holiday schedule” for most of the time between Christmas and New Year’s. That includes today through Wednesday, plus Friday; here’s the list of routes that are affected. (Thursday, New Year’s Day, will be on a Sunday schedule.) (Note added: This morning Metro published a specific page to address this week – check that here.)

Now, the “questions answered” part – over the weekend, we received some additional information from Metro’s Linda Thielke, after she read the “editorial-esque aside” we included in this post – it’s about why bus-tracking didn’t work so well, and why it should in the not-too-distant future – for that and more, read on:

The main question we posed must be answered by local leaders — and we expect discussion, for starters, will ensue; we checked with King County Councilmember Dow Constantine‘s office just before Christmas — since he’s the chair of the council’s Transportation Committee. They promise “a public hearing at the council after the new year.”

But in the short run, what Linda was offering was an answer to the question of why the online “bus tracker” wasn’t accurate. Here’s what she wrote:

Tracker is the only service offered by Metro.

*MyBus and Busview come from the UW.

*All three pull from the same database.

*That database is dependent on the buses being on normal routing and passing electronic readers installed on the streets that track the time they pass those locations. The buses have technology on board that trigger the readers.

*If the bus is rerouted, even for a portion of the route, it can throw the tracking off because the buses don’t pass the expected signposts and are “lost” in the tracking sequence. This includes being on snow routes.

*If routes don’t show up on these programs (which happened during the recent snow/ice storms) that does not mean it is not operating. It may be on alternate routing where there are no sensors to track the coach’s progress.

*This should improve in 2010 when Metro installs a GPS-based vehicle location system to track buses in real time, something we have been working on for a while.

That last one was news to us, so we tried to find more information online; after finally giving up, we e-mailed Linda back to ask if she can point us to more details — she said she didn’t think Metro’s “written much” about the GPS system, but she’ll look.

One more note — we went back into the WSB archives to see what happened in the wake of the last major winter-storm trouble that befell our area — the December 2006 windstorm/January 2007 snowstorm. We found coverage of the February 5, 2007, King County Council Town Hall meeting at The Hall at Fauntleroy. We posted two reports – this short note about people not getting a chance to speak till the very end, when many had left; this longer report somewhat acerbically summing up the entire event. We wrote about it chronologically; about an hour into the meeting, this excerpt:

The first panel of experts isn’t even the utility panel — it’s public health, sheriffs, Metro buses, and King County roads. Their interesting revelations: The sheriff rep noted that Nextel service sucked during the post-windstorm troubles … the Metro rep noted that their “customer communication system” has trouble keeping up with “rapidly changing conditions,” and then elicits the first real laugh of the night by mentioning “We know that sometimes it’ll snow in the North End and be perfectly dry down here and yet your [West Seattle] buses will just disappear.”

The Town Hall meeting also has its own page on the county website, though we can’t get the video files to play. Elsewhere on the county site, we did find this summary of changes made by Metro after the tumultuous 2006-2007 winter – though the date at the top of this page makes it look new, if you check the page bottom, it was actually posted in December 2007.

8 Replies to "West Seattle buses: Metro service reminder; questions answered"

  • Diane December 29, 2008 (9:59 am)

    oh my god, this is just begging for comments, but are we all too exhausted, angry, fed up, feel like no one in “leadership” roles even cares at this point?
    ~
    I have been wondering why we haven’t heard anything from Dow through all this; we sure heard from them plenty when they decided to raise bus fares

  • Bill December 29, 2008 (11:27 am)

    The roads in my neighborhood couldn’t be clearer and today I find my bus (#133) is canceled ALL WEEK! Why does Nickels give Metro a “B” rating during the snow when they do things like this? Where’s Charlie Chong when you need him? I know…dead.

  • MM December 29, 2008 (11:28 am)

    This blog is the only place there’s any online evidence of the “partial holiday” schedule for 12/29-12/31, posted before the morning of 12/29!

    I carefully checked the Metro web page last night, and didn’t see any indication of the schedule change. Several other “regulars” were also at my normal stop this morning (cancelled!), and on my backup route (41) a ton of riders were left behind at Northgate.

  • WSB December 29, 2008 (11:31 am)

    Bill – Just a reminder, Metro is a county service, not a city service.
    Your local councilmember (unlike the city, they are elected to represent specific areas) is Dow Constantine:
    http://www.kingcounty.gov/Constantine.aspx
    And King County Executive Ron Sims’ info is here:
    http://your.kingcounty.gov/exec/
    However, it’s been noted that better clearing of city streets also factors into the buses’ ability to operate.

  • WSB December 29, 2008 (11:45 am)

    MM – sorry to hear that. We were closely tracking the Metro situation throughout the storm and Linda from Metro called our attention to that “partial holiday” schedule last week (see inline link above) … I don’t know what was sent to other media and when. We have tracked transportation fairly closely here for a long time (we are a news website that publishes in blog format, not really a “blog”) but from hereon out, even in relatively normal times, I’ll be keeping a closer eye on such things, to make sure people get early word … TR

  • fatcat1111 December 29, 2008 (1:54 pm)

    The problem isn’t the King County Council, at least not directly. The problem lies with Kevin Desmond, Metro’s director. I know as a fact (and have photos to prove it) that he kept hundreds of buses in the yard – not just articulated buses, which the WSP ordered off the roads, but trolleys and old diesels as well – then stated that he didn’t have the buses to send out. Further he limited mechanics to two hours of overtime, just when they’re needed most.

    While I’m sure that this will keep Metro under budget, it leaves people literally stranded.

    He did the same thing when he worked for New York Transit, and they ran him out of town for it.

  • Dow Constantine December 29, 2008 (5:06 pm)

    I hear you. I, and plenty of others here at the King County Council, am very focused on fixing the problems that plagued transit riders during the recent snowfall. Because of the condition of the roads, Metro managers had to leave most of our articulated buses out of service during most snow days, which meant that the system was operating at only about 50 percent capacity.

    I salute Metro’s employees for their diligent work under extremely adverse conditions. However, I was also dismayed by the serious communications failures I learned of from the media, my constituents, and my bus-riding employees. I wrote to Metro General Manager Kevin Desmond two days before Christmas outlining my concerns with the goal of meeting with him personally in the first week of January and arranging a County Council briefing shortly thereafter. The issues I raised in my letter included Metro’s phone and website communications, the difficulty of getting information on modified (snow) routes to bus riders, bus frequency to popular destinations, and the general issue of areas which were completely unserved by transit during the snowfall.

    Although the Seattle area rarely gets a snowfall of this size or duration, we need to learn from both mistakes and successes and to improve performance under adverse weather and other emergency conditions.

  • cleat December 31, 2008 (11:13 am)

    Dow … if you can get Metro’s ear on the semi-holiday schedule fiasco too, it has forced many of us to drive to be able to continue our normal work schedules!!!

Sorry, comment time is over.