BIZNOTE FOLLOWUP: Inside the plan for new West Seattle restaurant The Neighborhood

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

Though a key feature of the kitchen is a New York-style pizza oven, new restaurant The Neighborhood is not going to be a place you can pigeonhole as a pizzeria, says its proprietor.

Since our first report four days ago about The Neighborhood taking over the ex-Peel & Press space at 6503 California SW, we’ve visited the space for a chat with owner-operator Jenny Almukhtar.

Though her restaurant-to-be is in the throes of a major cleanup and refresh, it already has a friendly feeling. Jenny’s in-laws were doing some interior work when we dropped by; her mom-in-law already has contributed the chalk sketch shown atop this story. That’s not the official logo, though, Jenny explains; they will have one, and it’s being developed by an artist right now. Jenny says it’ll harmonize with the different colors they plan to use to “lighten up the space” from the woodsy ambience of Peel & Press. You’ll see a mural-style version of the forthcoming logo by the front door, place names (like California/Fauntleroy) on the wall, and some other neighborhood-ish touches in back – hopscotch markings on the way to the restrooms, perhaps. And the name will be spelled out in old tap handles that Jenny and husband Ahmed have collected over their years in the hospitality industry.

What about new tap handles, and other beverage plans? The Neighborhood is seeking a full liquor license, which is what Peel & Press had, so no basic change there. They’ll have eight tap handles, with two of them devoted to wine; four or five draft beers, with a local emphasis (something from Georgetown Brewing, maybe Manny’s, will be included, of course). Cocktails? They plan a housemade limoncello that will play a part – such as in a limoncello martini. They’re also working on a Mezcal Negroni. And a lineup of mocktails that Jenny promises will be more flavorful and memorable than just alcohol-free versions of classic drinks.

But not pretentious, she insists. The whole vibe is meant to be casual – even though you might not draw that inference from a place that will only be open for dinner, for starters. That’s not forever, she clarifies. What they want to do is start simple, get everything right, and then look at how they might grow – pop-up brunches, perhaps? Speaking of which, let’s get back to the food.

“We know Italian,” Jenny emphasizes. That includes some time spent living back east, as you’ll glean from this photo she shares of herself and Ahmed:

Italian is a cuisine that’s “easy to execute,” she adds. You’ll likely see a simple menu with several main dishes such as “deconstructed lasagna” and chicken parmigiana, plus four or five appetizers, a few salads, and the pizzas – we took a peek at the famous oven, which can bake other items too:

Baked items, of course, can be sweet as well as savory! In fact, Jenny says they’re planning a lineup of “fantastic desserts,” including tiramisu featuring the aforementioned housemade limoncello, plus butterscotch pudding, gelato or sherbet, and “something decadently chocolate.”

Back to the pizza for a moment – Jenny plans a Pizza of the Month contest, modeled after the Burger of the Month competition from her days down the street at The Bridge: Customers will suggest it, there’ll be an online vote, and the winning pizza will be a menu feature for the month. That’ll be in the spirit of the community vibe she’s hoping The Neighborhood will offer. Having been in the hospitality industry since she was 13 years old, she says it’s her second nature.

That also plays into listening to what the customers want. Aware of the chatter about how the space was potentially destined for a bagel shop, Jenny says they might try making bagels – sometime.

But first – they have a plan, and will work hard to “get it right.” If all goes well, they’ve chalked in April 2 for a grand opening.

16 Replies to "BIZNOTE FOLLOWUP: Inside the plan for new West Seattle restaurant The Neighborhood"

  • Juanita February 20, 2025 (7:45 am)

    Looking forward to trying out the variety of food.  I only ask, as someone originally from NYC, please, please don’t advertise NY style pizza unless that’s what you’ve really got.  So far, have only found one place in WA, Brooklyn Brothers in Everett, that has actual NY style pizza.  Gonna try the food here regardless (fingers crossed for either zeppoles or garlic knots) and wish them much success!

  • Wes Sea Rider February 20, 2025 (8:18 am)

    Go Bills! Can we get some real honest to goodness Buffalo wings?

  • alkibeeeech February 20, 2025 (8:24 am)

    We live within walking distance and look forward to the opening! I am excited to eat butterscotch pudding after some tasty Italian food then waddle home full and happy. 

  • HTB February 20, 2025 (8:42 am)

    Sounds great – But I have conflicted feelings knowing they were among the Bills fans who more or less took over Lumen Field this season! :)

    • Jeff F. February 20, 2025 (2:19 pm)

      It’s been a contentious issue with 12s these past couple seasons. Know your audience, people!  At least they aren’t wearing Niners gear… 

  • justme February 20, 2025 (10:57 am)

    Please offer chicken piccata! I have yet to find a good version in Seattle area.

    • Erin98126 February 20, 2025 (12:43 pm)

      Circa’s chicken piccata is delish!

  • JB February 20, 2025 (11:12 am)

    Came here to also say bring us true Buffalo wings! (Duffs>Anchor Bar) Go Bills!

  • helpermonkey February 20, 2025 (1:00 pm)

    if you can offer some gluten free options, I know I would be very happy! 

    • J February 22, 2025 (6:47 am)

      Yes please!!

  • WS Local February 20, 2025 (1:42 pm)

    Can’t wait to try this spot!

  • Patrick February 20, 2025 (7:39 pm)

    Pizza. In West Seattle. What a concept.

  • Neighbor of the neighborhood February 20, 2025 (8:42 pm)

    Can’t wait to support fellow Bills fans! Agreed about the need for some great buffalo wings on game days. Go Bills! 

  • grittygrits February 20, 2025 (9:03 pm)

    Good luck.

  • E-Dubs February 21, 2025 (9:56 am)

    I am so excited for The Neighborhood to open in my hood! Jenny and Ahmed know their way around a kitchen, and I know the food is going to be amazing! 

  • Bob L February 21, 2025 (11:17 am)

    Can’t wait for the opening. Ahmed and Jenny are wonderfully talented people who genuinely love what they do.wishing you all the best from the east coast…

Sorry, comment time is over.