WEST SEATTLE LIGHT RAIL: Sound Transit Board votes for Junction tunnel, Andover elevated stations

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

While the region was dealing with transportation troubles by sea and by land this afternoon, the Sound Transit Board of Directors took what you could call it semifinal vote on routing and station locations for West Seattle’s future light rail.

Without much discussion, despite an at-times-emotional last round of public comment, board members unanimously approved final environmental-impact studies for the “preferred alternative” recommended by a board committee two weeks ago, with these locations and possible modifications:

See the full slide deck here. For engineering concept diagrams, you can see this appendix of the Draft Environmental Impact Report; for lists of potentially affected parcels, see this section of the DEIS. (ADDED) For summaries of the chosen options, see this document – page 41 explains the Junction station and the “retained cut” Avalon station that goes with it (unless dropped later), while page 36 explains the Andover station, and page 26 summarizes the “preferred” Duwamish River crossing.

Almost all of the West Seattle-related comments in the hour and a half of public comment that opened the meeting had to do with opposition to the Delridge station option the board is supporting, DEL-6, particularly because of its potential impacts on Transitional Resources, which provides supportive housing and other services to people living with behavioral/mental-health issues, many of whom were formerly homeless, about half of whom TR says are BIPOC. TR’s CEO Darcell Slovek-Walker broke down in tears while speaking to the board today, recounting how she had to tell clients that “their homes are at risk.” TR clients past and present spoke as well; one asked, “how can you even think about tearing it down?” A current resident said, “There’s nothing transitional about (it) … please don’t destroy our homes.” Another, who said TR saved their life 10 years ago, added, “I was given a home that surrounded me with love and support” after leaving a hospital … “the irony is that TR taught me how to use Seattle transit, including light rail, for my independence.” And a TR supporter said that what the organization provides “cannot be replicated” and “serves the most marginalized people in our community.” Almost all the non-WS comments at the meeting were about the Chinatown-ID station south of downtown, which will be studied for at least a few more months before the board votes on a “preferred alternative.”

At least one board member said they were moved by the Transitional Resources stories and pledged to do what they could to find a way to lessen the project’s impact. ST executive Cathal Ridge, while presenting the motion’s key points, said that the modifications to be studied – perhaps shifting the Andover station-related route a bit – could work toward that end.

WHAT’S NEXT: ST staff now works on the final Environmental Impact Statement, which among other things will respond to all the concerns and issues raised in relation to the Draft EIS. The FEIS is due out sometime next year; after that, the board would take a final vote on routing and station locations. If nothing else affects the timeline, West Seattle light rail is still expected to open in 2032.

60 Replies to "WEST SEATTLE LIGHT RAIL: Sound Transit Board votes for Junction tunnel, Andover elevated stations"

  • RR July 28, 2022 (6:14 pm)

    I wonder what the catalyst would be to get ST to shift the station from 41st/Alaska (Bank of America property) to 42nd/Alaska (Jefferson Square). It seems to me that shifting from the preferred alternative at 41st to 42nd makes more sense. Jefferson Square is an entire city block and seems underutilized to me.

    • Auntie July 28, 2022 (6:50 pm)

      I doubt that the residents of the apartments at Jefferson Square or any of the many successful businesses located there consider it to be underutilized. 

      • RR July 28, 2022 (7:21 pm)

        I hear ya. Totally lame for all the residents and businesses there for sure. However the 41st route takes out another huge complex of apartments at Citywatch and the condos next to it on Edmunds. BofA is totally underutilized too but Jefferson Square is an entire city block and half of it is a parking lot. Just my two cents.

        • Mark July 30, 2022 (3:58 am)

          I live in the condos on 41st and Edmunds. We can’t sale now because of this. We are basically stuck.

      • RR July 28, 2022 (8:38 pm)

        I hear ya. It would be totally lame for those businesses and residents no doubt. However, half of Jefferson square is a parking lot, so it seems more underutilized than the 41st/BofA block. The 41st/BofA block is loaded with housing and a future park. That block has the newish Broadstone Sky apartments,  the 5 story condo building on Edmunds, and the City Watch Apartments/Swedish building. That is a pretty densly populated block (other than the BofA space). If you were to put a new station at Jefferson Square you could redevelop it for housing and commercial space as well. 

    • Brayton July 28, 2022 (7:06 pm)

      I was thinking the opposite. The only thing on the BofA space is…BofA, and there’s not much to it. Building a station there seems ideal before someone builds a Jefferson Square Part Deaux on it. 

      • V July 28, 2022 (10:33 pm)

        Jefferson Square is not underutilized. It has quite a bit of retail stores (Safeway and Bartells being the largest) and much more car and pedestrian traffic than 41st due to the large apartment buildings across the street. Previous plans showed an above ground station as an option on 42nd which would have been a terrible eye sore. I can see why this tunnel is a new option as the previous plan would have cut off access to essentials. I’m curious as to how this 41st underground tunnel plays out though. 

        • RR July 29, 2022 (3:27 pm)

          It is totally underutilized. If someone were to redevelop that property I can promise you that the footprint would not be 50% at grade parking lot. 

  • Light rail equals equity July 28, 2022 (7:07 pm)

    This is the biggest project we will do in our lifetimes for equity. I’m having a hard time figuring out if we dropped the Avalon station or not. I sure hope not. And the costs are what they are, we have to figure out how to serve the most people and plan the best neighborhood around it. The expense of doing it right today will surely be less than not getting this right the first time. I sure hope this moves forward as swiftly as possible. 

    • WSB July 28, 2022 (7:12 pm)

      Nothing changed since the recommendation vote two weeks ago. Possibly dropping the Avalon station will be “studied” but it’s not currently part of the “preferred alternative.” – TR

      • East Coast Cynic July 28, 2022 (7:41 pm)

        Leaving the Avalon Station out of the preferred alternative and submitting it to further study sounds like a passive aggressive way of dropping it entirely.  I suspect the STB will do that in their final final decision, probably believing it will lessen the ability of the residents to fight back.  If they do, STB should find some sort of bus shuttle option to get Avalon residents to one of the stations.

        • WSB July 28, 2022 (8:39 pm)

          It’s not left out of the preferred alternative. It’s basically a package deal that comes along with the Junction decision – unless it’s dropped later. The Junction decision includes the “retained cut” Avalon station.
          https://www.soundtransit.org/sites/default/files/documents/2-wsble-drafteis-chapter2-alternatives-202201.pdf
          Explained on page 41.

          Alternative WSJ-3a* would be in a tunnel under Southwest Genesee Street heading west from
          31st Avenue Southwest then curve to the southwest between 37th Avenue Southwest and 41st
          Avenue Southwest. The tunnel would end in the vicinity of Southwest Hudson Street, with the
          tail track in a north-south orientation under 41st Avenue Southwest. The guideway would be
          entirely in a tunnel. The plan and profile for this alternative is shown on Figure 2-35. Stations
          would be located as follows:
          • Avalon Station: The Avalon Station would be beneath Fauntleroy Way Southwest. Station
          entrances would be on the west side of Fauntleroy Way Southwest and on the east side of
          35th Avenue Southwest.
          • Alaska Junction Station: The Alaska Junction Station would be beneath 41st Avenue
          Southwest and Southwest Alaska Street. Station entrances would be on either side of
          Southwest Alaska Street along the east side of 41st Avenue Southwest.

          • East Coast Cynic July 28, 2022 (9:15 pm)

            This preferred alternative is predicated on that “wish upon a star” 3rd party funding.  If they don’t get the funding or don’t get enough of it, I could foresee the elimination of Avalon, but that’s just being cynical:).

          • WSB July 29, 2022 (12:23 am)

            That’s old info in the doc. Currently they don’t expect to need 3rd-party funding for the Junction tunneled option after all.

          • Joe Z July 29, 2022 (9:13 am)

            WSJ-5 is the new preferred alternative, not WSJ-3a. The 41st station is slightly different (shallower) in WSJ-5 vs. WSJ-3a.

    • Pessoa July 28, 2022 (11:00 pm)

      How is light rail going to assure equity?  More likely, it will reduce equity in terms of access to public transportation.  In the future, you will see reduced bus transit with the excuse that it is a redundacy, despite the fact that bus routes have more stops and thus are more accessible to those who really need public transportation. Now, we have the really odious prospect of displacing those who live at Transitional Resources.  This extension is an utterly, and completely half-baked idea.  Good grief, wake up people. 

    • Pessoa July 29, 2022 (7:50 am)

      This massively disruptive, unnecessary piece of so-called “infrastructure”  will do zero to improve equity.  In fact, it will most likely lead to reductions in bus transit for those who critically need it.   Now, the have the odious prospect of displacing residents of Transitional Resources by those who call themselves “progressives.”   The stench of hypocrisy is unbearable.   

      • Question Authority July 29, 2022 (12:38 pm)

        Change happens, that facility will find a new location just like every other displaced residence and business along the entire Sound Transit corridor in Puget Sound.  Back to California you go, to bad you can’t take the rest of your transplanted  kind with you for the good of us locals 

    • Pessoa July 29, 2022 (9:45 am)

      Nothing screams “equity” quite like a proposed option tearing down of Transistional Resources.  

      On a side note,  this is my final post.  My partner and I are departing Seattle.  To put it as delicately as I can, Seattle didn’t “take” and I’ll leave it at that rather risk offending anyone further.  We miss the Cali vibe and the sunshine, something probaby only California transplants will understand.   I’ll check in once in a great while, but won’t be commenting in the future under “Pessoa,” or any other alias.  Thanks WSB for the stellar reporting and equinimity in handling the comment thread. 
      Cheers,
      Pessoa

      • heartless July 29, 2022 (1:37 pm)

        Pessoa,

        I am sad to learn that you are leaving, but I understand.  From one Cali ex-pat to another, enjoy the vibes and the sunshine.

        Send me an email, why don’t you, if the urge ever strikes: wsbtrafficdata at gmail.

        Wishing you and yours the best.

      • Gatewood resident July 29, 2022 (8:08 pm)

        Washington sucks, tell all your friends

      • Jort July 29, 2022 (9:57 pm)

        Bye! Good luck. Bye. 

  • GatewoodGirl July 28, 2022 (8:01 pm)

    I might have missed a previous explanation, but what exactly is a “medium tunnel”?

    • TheHardestPart July 28, 2022 (8:34 pm)

      Refers to the length of the tunnel… or where the tunnel portion would start. There were short and long options explored as well.

      • Joe Z July 28, 2022 (8:48 pm)

        The tunnel will start at 37th and Fauntleroy, where West Seattle Brewery is located. The Avalon Station will be 30 ft below street grade with entrances at the current locations of Pecos Pit and Taco Time. “Retained cut” so underground but an open top. 35th Ave SW will close for several years during station construction (I think the DEIS said 2 or 3 years?) and then be rebuilt above the station. As of right now there will be no entrance on the north side of Fauntleroy which should make for some interesting conflicts between pedestrians and cars coming off the bridge ramp. 

        • D-Mom July 29, 2022 (5:33 am)

          35th will close for several years?  That is a major arterial for those of us south of the bridge. First we dealt with construction on 35th, which was a major pain. Then the bridge closed. When Is it ever going to be functional again?

    • RR July 28, 2022 (8:45 pm)

      I’m not sure exactly but I think it has to do with the fact that it is elevated for a portion and a tunnel for a portion of the route. At one point I beleive it was either elevated for the entire thing or a tunnel. This is kind of a hybrid. 

  • TheHardestPart July 28, 2022 (8:06 pm)

    As a homeowner who would be displaced by the recommended alignment I would really appreciate it if this latest vote would open up some more outreach resources. I’d like to start getting everything in order to facilitate a smooth acquisition but nobody at Sound Transit wants to get into the details before the final decision is made.

  • THOMAS July 28, 2022 (8:39 pm)

    its a big waste of money we dont need it

    • Honey July 29, 2022 (12:39 pm)

      Most West Seattlelites have NO idea what is sneakily being rammed through by Sound Transit helped greatly by  Dow  and Joe McDermott.  Light rail would take us ONLY to SODO where we would have to change trains to go anywhere.  Light rail will cause years of construction/destruction/  including two years along 35th Ave SW.  The two years estimate is ST propaganda – we are still waiting for the WS bridge to open should not be deceived.  The DEL6 estimate for some areas is 6  years of disruption.  My great fear isSound Transit will start tearing things up and destroy homes, businesses, traffic flow, the WS eco-system and will then run out of money.  We in West Seattle will be left with a wreck of our community and a huge bill in order to clean it up.  Can we stop this mess from happening?  How can we inform people?  

      • Ron Swanson July 29, 2022 (2:34 pm)

        “Light rail would take us ONLY to SODO where we would have to change trains to go anywhere.”

        This is true for the first few years of operation; when the new downtown tunnel and Ballard Link open West Seattle has a one-seat ride to downtown, the UW, Roosevelt, all the way to Everett.

      • LAintheJunction July 29, 2022 (2:47 pm)

        @Thomas and @Honey, you’re kidding me, right? I’d say most West Seattleites are very well aware of the great benefits that light rail service will bring. Transferring in Sodo makes sense because that’s a hub, why on earth would Sound Transit build another parallel track going into downtown when one already exists? We’ve been hoping and waiting for this for years, it’s time to get going. And I say this as someone who is going to be directly impacted by the construction – yes, it totally sucks that we’ll finally get the bridge back and then have another big construction project to deal with – but the only thing worse would be to do nothing and delay even further. We have to solve the transportation problems of getting out of West Seattle and light rail is our best hope. Time to get on the train!

      • Jeremiah July 29, 2022 (2:50 pm)

        Stop spreading misinformation. The train will ONLY go to SODO for the first few years. Then it will continue into downtown.

      • WS Res July 30, 2022 (1:42 pm)

        I don’t understand this pearl-clutching that comes up all the time about having to change trains.  Has anyone panicking about changing trains ever ridden trains in London, or New York, or even SF?  Yes, sometimes you have to get off one train and wait for another. It happens. News flash: sometimes you have to get off one bus and transfer to another, sometimes even walking to another stop! 

  • VentLady July 28, 2022 (9:43 pm)

    I don’t understand why after the Bank of America it has to plow through one more block of homes. They will never extend it farther south down 41st. Sad for my neighbors whose homes will be a tunnel dead end and a vent. 

    • HappyCamper July 29, 2022 (12:08 pm)

      I’m no expert but my guess would be space for changing tracks for the train to change direction and head out the other way.

  • John July 28, 2022 (10:04 pm)

    With this plan, would the station in the junction just occupy the Bank of America property or would the neighboring apartment building to the south be affected as well?

    • TheHardestPart July 29, 2022 (6:42 am)

      Review the engineering drawings linked above. Page 74 shows affected properties (within the dashed line) and the the last two pages show the conceptual station design that will give you an idea of the above/below ground portions.

      • John July 29, 2022 (10:54 pm)

        Yeah, I looked at those previously and just did again, and I still can’t tell which buildings would be torn down on that block other than the bank. Any insight from someone better at reading the plans would be appreciated. 

        • TheHardestPart July 30, 2022 (7:36 am)

          South of a Alaska it would be BoA, Citywatch Apartments, and the small condo building on the corner. Then all houses between 41st and the alley between 40th and 41st south to the Hudson stairs. Basically, the station would be located below the intersection of Alaska and 41st, with entrance buildings on both the north and south sides, and the tunnel overrun and associated utilities would continue south to the Hudson stairs. Looks like the design is attempting to preserve all properties to the west side of 41st.

  • WSDUDEMAN July 29, 2022 (9:12 am)

    Avalon Station is an absolute joke and waste of additional resources. Anyone North, West and South of the Junction station will also have to travel a good distance to jump on the train. Having 2 very very expensive stations built near each other is ludicrous. 

    • MyThruppence July 29, 2022 (12:11 pm)

      Not if that’s where the concentration of population will be.

      • WSDUDEMAN July 29, 2022 (1:32 pm)

        The future density of the Avalon Triangle area will not exceed the entire rest of West Seattle. It will be dense development from the Triangle into the Junction. One stop should suffice. 

        • MyThruppence July 29, 2022 (7:19 pm)

          Yeah, well, you know, that’s just, like, your opinion, man. We’ll see which of us is correct in about 25 years. Cheers! Off to enjoy a White Russian.

    • Keep Avalon July 30, 2022 (9:21 am)

      Half a mile between stations is not close. It’s slightly more than the distance between Delridge and Avalon. That’s like saying we should remove Delridge station because it’s close enough to Avalon. 

  • LateToParty July 29, 2022 (12:22 pm)

    I’ve no house to lose and my heart goes out to those who do, so this feels like a selfish question, but I am unsure if I read the information correctly. Does this mean we will lose the West Seattle Health Club? 

    • Honey July 29, 2022 (12:49 pm)
      • Most West Seattlelites have NO idea what is sneakily being rammed through by Sound Transit helped greatly by  Dow  and Joe McDermott.  Light rail would take us ONLY to SODO where we would have to change trains to go anywhere.  Light rail will cause years of construction/destruction/  including two years along 35th Ave SW.  The two years estimate is ST propaganda – we who are still waiting for the WS bridge to open should not be deceived.  The DEL6 estimate for some areas is 6  years of disruption.  My great fear is that Sound Transit will start tearing things up and destroy homes, businesses, traffic flow, the WS eco-system and will then run out of money.  We in West Seattle will be left with a wreck of our community and a huge bill in order to clean it up.  Can we stop this mess from happening?  How can we inform people?  
      • M July 29, 2022 (1:20 pm)

        How do you know that most West Seattlelites “have NO idea” of this plan being “rammed through” vs. them being okay with the plan or just not caring? Nothing sneaky about it when every meeting about ST is widely published here and on other sources. You can dislike something without it being a conspiracy–it’s fine!

        • Honey July 29, 2022 (2:44 pm)

          Yes, M.  I have no idea what “most” West Seattleites think.  It would be interesting to take a poll.  I should have said “most of the people I speak with here” are astounded to learn some of the facts.    I stand by “Light rail would take us ONLY to SODO where we would have to change trains to go anywhere.  Light rail will cause years of construction/destruction/  including two years along 35th Ave SW.  The two years estimate is ST propaganda – we who are still waiting for the WS bridge to open should not be deceived.  The DEL6 estimate for some areas is 6  years of disruption.  My great fear is that Sound Transit will start tearing things up and destroy homes, businesses, traffic flow, the WS eco-system and will then run out of money.  We in West Seattle will be left with a wreck of our community and a huge bill in order to clean it up”.    I wouldn’t and didn’t call it a conspiracy.  

          • WS Res July 31, 2022 (12:23 pm)

            I wouldn’t and didn’t call it a conspiracy.    You said it was being “sneakily rammed through” by a few individuals, and that most of the WS public didn’t know about it.  That is LITERALLY the definition of a conspiracy.

        • Jeremiah July 29, 2022 (2:52 pm)

          Also we all voted for this years ago, so nothing is sneaky and nothing is being rammed through. There’s also been a ton of discussion on this very blog. I can’t understand how anyone would say this was sneaky or rammed through

          • Wseattleite July 30, 2022 (1:51 pm)

            One factual note.  This is in no way the budget or schedule that was voted on. 

      • Lauren July 29, 2022 (9:02 pm)

        Having to transfer stations is very, very common in transit systems all over the world. Not a dealbreaker at all.

  • Mj July 29, 2022 (5:25 pm)

    Enough Seattle process already, a preferred alternative has been determined it’s time to devote resources to getting this option approved, designed and constructed.  No option is going to please everyone and spending money on more and more study detracts from getting the project completed as fast as practical.

  • 41stAveSW August 11, 2022 (1:03 pm)

    I’ve resigned myself that my rental property will need to be sold to Sound Transit. At this point, I’m looking to maximize the sale amount. Does anyone have first hand experience with the process?

Sorry, comment time is over.