Amazon.com is local. Unless this is a $150+ toaster oven it might not be worth it. Try Scott Wiseman, but I’d buy a new one that got high marks on Amazon and hope for better luck. Depressing but likely true.
If you really are wanting to get it fixed: Ajax small appliance repair on first ave (just south of home depot, west side of street). they repaired a cuisinart for me. Not sure it’s worth the price though but they can tell you for sure.