The End of Public Education?

Home Forums Politics The End of Public Education?

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #875838

    TanDL
    Participant

    This was posted by someone familiar with education on my Facebook page and I thought I would share. Not sure where the bill is at the moment, but these days it pays to be pro-active and start throwing fits quickly if you believe that an educated populace is important:

    “I am appalled and horrified… Please help by calling in to your representatives! It makes a difference! If you called in against DeVos please call in now. This is horrendous.
    An assault on us all. Because it all starts with our children…
    Our worst fears are coming true. House Bill 610 makes some large changes. Inform yourselves.
    This bill will effectively start the school voucher system to be used by children ages 5-17, and starts the defunding process of public schools.
    In addition the bill will eliminate the Elementary and Education Act of 1965, which is the nation’s educational law and provides equal opportunity in education.
    It would repeal ESSA (Every Students Succeeds Act):
    ESSA is a big comprehensive program that covers programs for struggling learners, AP classes, ESL classes, classes for minorities such as Native Americans, Rural Education, Education for the Homeless, School Safety (Gun-Free schools), Monitoring and Compliance and Federal Accountability Programs.
    The Bill also abolishes the Nutritional Act of 2012 (No Hungry Kids Act) which provides nutritional standards in school breakfast and lunch.
    The bill has no wording whatsoever protecting SN kids, no mention of IDEA and FAPE.
    Some things ESSA does for Children with Disabilities
    -Ensures access to the general education curriculum.
    -Ensures access to accommodations on assessments.
    -Ensures concepts of Universal Design for Learning
    -Includes provisions that require local education agencies to provide evidence-based
    interventions in schools with consistently underperforming subgroups.
    -Requires states in Title I plans to address how they will improve conditions for learning including reducing incidents of bullying and harassment in schools, overuse of discipline practices and reduce the use of aversive behavioral interventions (such as restraints and seclusion).
    Please call your representative and ask him/her to vote NO on House Bill 610 (HR 610) introduced by three Republican reps.” https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/610/text

    #876140

    williamf64
    Participant

    This is a Joke .. Right ? Liberals pretending to care ? Really ?

    Liberal’s are all about choice when it comes to killing unborn children or killing yourself or destroying your life with Drugs.. Oh yeah.. We need choice for that.
    ” It’s our right “.
    But when it comes to School Choice. HELL NO !
    If an African American woman trapped in a Liberal controlled inner city HELL HOLE surrounded by poverty, crime and despair caused by decades of destructive Progressive policies wants School Choice than NO WAY !. ” We have to fight against that..” says the Liberal Love and tolerance machine.
    In fact not only don’t you get a choice but we will fight against you getting a choice to free your children from the progressive, generational cycle of illiteracy. Yet the Progressives ONLY answer to this decades long destruction of our education system is .. yup.. You guessed it ” More Money. ” That’s it. No other solutions.
    Liberals pretend to care to make their shallow souls feel good for the moment but the real reason is Control. Yes, Control of the system and control of the teachers unions to make sure that our kids stay in the Liberal indoctrination institutions.
    Seriously, If you didn’t know the statistics or the situation the Liberal argument could possibly pass as Giving a Crap. A Very slight “crap ” but it does make it sound like they care. But, once you present the statistics and ” Facts ” ( Liberals Hate that evil word… Facts ! ) then the argument against that African American woman wanting to give her next generation a chance in this life by sending her sons or daughters to schools with graduation rates above ( 10 – 20% ) FAILS COMPLETELY !

    How about these SAD statistics. Get ready because the Liberal slime balls are going to whip out the age old argument of ” Republicans are racist because they won’t give our failing system even more money ! ”

    * US spends MORE per student than ANY other country in the World yet ranks 17th – 20th.
    * US ranks ( # 24 ) in the world in Literacy. ( Shameful ! )
    * US ranks 18th in reading
    * Some Graduation rates in the inner city schools in the single digits ! ]
    But, even when they ” Graduate ” they aren’t proficient in anything.

    These sad and pathetic statistics go on and on and our Liberal controlled crime, poverty and drug infested inner city schools educational statistics are so low that many 3rd world countries would be ashamed. But, the rich white Liberal schools are used to balance out these statistics to justify keeping the system exactly the same. In fact, ONLY in our education system and some Communist countries is ” Tenure ” used. Yes, ” Tenure ” where an employee ( ie.. teacher in this case ) CANNOT be fired no matter how bad of a job they do. Imagine that in any other profession ? Imagine the Liberal outrage if some Conservative institution granted ” Tenure ‘ to an a continuously incompetent employee ?
    My friend went to a school in inner city Los Angeles that last year had a graduation rate of ( 12% ). YES.. that was ( 12 % )
    Yup. Liberals care so much that if ( 200 ) un-armed Black men are killed every year by the evil White cops then it is one progressive ” March of outrage” after another. But when millions are trapped in our inner city crap schools and want to escape? Want a choice ? NO WAY ! In fact. they fight to keep them there.

    Yup.. Vote Democrat ! All they need is just a little more money !

    #876151

    waynster
    Participant

    Who let the troll out………Willy you always complain and show no facts to prove your claims…. yet you say we are wrong for not voting for trump and the GOP….. I know where he got his facts guess which side..lol

    http://www.gocomics.com/nonsequitur/2017/03/03

    http://www.gocomics.com/nonsequitur/2017/03/02

    • This reply was modified 7 years, 1 month ago by waynster.
    #876222

    anonyme
    Participant

    The voucher system is not only unconstitutional, it is unworkable. Educational philosophies aside, schools must function as brick and mortar ‘businesses’, with fairly long-term planning required in terms of staffing, maintenance, supplies, etc.,etc. A voucher system would create utter chaos, as it would be difficult or impossible to anticipate voucher use. Mark my words, private corporations such as Summit (and others) are ready to step in and start raking in the profits in the form of taxpayer dollars – just as Wall Street did a few years ago and is poised to do again.

    So,yes – this could be the end of public education. Wasn’t that the plan all along? I’d like to see DeVos tarred, feathered, and dragged from a yacht, but….patience.

    #876233

    williamf64
    Participant

    Exactly ! Your ridiculous responses are exactly why trump got elected. Besides the fact that you nominated a truly corrupt & slimy lying criminal but liberals have ignored all that. I hope ?
    I Have no Facts ? . Your kidding right ? These are all well known and easy to verify statistics but I understand. This is a prime example of L.M.D. ( Liberal Mental DisOrder ) and how it allows those infected to deny the reality of any situation in order to further the Ideology. You are simply going to deny ALL the streams of Statistics and pretend that US public schools ( ranked 17th – 20th ) are doing just great to make yourselves ” Feel ” better and that is what Liberal & Progressive-isms is all about, Liberals ” feeling ” better about themselves.
    Just like the Social Justice Elitist Millionaire Celebrity Warriors that pretend to care about the Environment , Guns, schools and other inner city struggles over their Twitter account. Amy Schumer and George Clooney cry over the injustice while getting off of their private jets, surrounded by armed security on their way to the exclusively WHITE gated estates just after picking up their kids from the ” Academy “. ” I feel your pain ! ” with a little tear in the corner of his eye… says Clooney.
    The left’s hypocracy is sickening and this sickness is being exposed. African Americans are finally waking up and seeing this for themselves. They live in these Liberal controlled HELL HOLES that are getting worse and worse and have for decades but Liberals are telling them ” Hey.. your fine. We just need MORE money from the evil, racist Republicans “. Then Trump roles in and says ” What in the hell do you have to lose ” and you know what…? they are listening and voting and the Liberals are losing their minds. Many Many prominent African American leaders are meeting with him and the real leaders of the African American communities that actually want to improve the situation are working with Trump.
    To me there is no example better than Chicago which literally has had more Murders and shooting over a 10 year period than the Freak’n Iraq War and Liberals are ABSOLUTELY SILENT. S.I.L.E.N.T. !! If it wasn’t so sad and truly telling about the sickness of Liberalism and how they don’t give One Damn it would be hilarious. But, no one is laughing.
    25 African Americans murdered in Chicago on july 4th weekend and not one news report, no protests, no rallies, no Liberal nothing. But..HOLY CRAP ! an African American was shot by a white police officer and there is a chance of ” Racism “? OK.. cue the Liberal OUTRAGE ! Organize the marches, make huge banners and get the paid protestors to bring matches and cans of gasoline. Oh.. and don’t forget them to pretend to give a crap this time too.
    Trump has been Amazing ! Any other politician would have folded or at least been affected by all this hysterical and disgusting progressive outrage. lies and rioting but not the 45th President of the United States. He has done like any other responsible parent has done and told the Liberal scum to ” Shut up, stop throwing your toys and get to your room ! ” and it has been Beautiful !
    But, the beautiful thing is that as the Liberal sickness gets exposed they behavior gets worse and worse but the problem is that you don’t control the conversation anymore and therefore you are forced to address the real truth and that will be the Liberal downfall. The only problem with the Wizard of Oz was when they pulled back the curtain and made him explain himself and that is what is happening to the Progressives.
    You can scream all you want but when African Americans are burying there children and the ones that don’t get shot or addicted end up in a school that graduates 10% of there students they aren’t believing it anymore. George Clooney and Nancy Pelosi’s kids get the CHOICE to go to the “Academy” but not your kids. IT DOESN’T WORK THAT WAY ! Its’ Unconstitutional for YOUR kids to get a choice. Everything’s fine nothing to see here!

    #876234

    waynster
    Participant

    A lot of rant willy still no facts ….just like whats coming out of white house theses days all bull with a lot of poop its so bad the GOP shovels can’t keep up…..

    http://www.gocomics.com/nonsequitur/2017/02/27

    #876260

    JoB
    Participant

    sigh.. show me the studies that show throwing public money at private schools works..
    there are lots and lots of statements.. but no studies because when studies are done they show the opposite.. that voucher systems drain money from public school systems without providing better outcome for students..
    those standardized tests are a bitch

    #876346

    J242
    Participant

    http://www.businessinsider.com/are-charter-schools-the-new-mortgage-crisis-2016-1

    “The study, “Are charter schools the new subprime loans?” warns of several factors that appear to be edging the charter industry toward a bubble premeditated by the same factors that encouraged banks to start offering risky mortgage loans.”

    “Charter schools have this same misalignment when it comes to management by third-party organizations, the study says. Many charter-school boards hire private education-management organizations to run the day-to-day administrative tasks of the school.

    The study says that while charter-school boards have the responsibility to follow the laws mandated of public schools, the incentive of these outside organizations is to increase revenue or cut expenses. And that misalignment creates an environment that may discriminate against students the organizations see as “too expensive,” such as those with disabilities, according to the study.”

    #876390

    TanDL
    Participant

    Dismal results from vouchers surprise researchers – A NY Times article found on Yahoo… I can’t seem to get the link to post here. From a 2/23 article about surprising results of vouchers used in Indiana, students in the voucher program showed significant drops in academic performance. Name of article is “Dismal results from vouchers surprise researchers as DeVos era begins.”

    • This reply was modified 7 years, 1 month ago by TanDL.
    • This reply was modified 7 years, 1 month ago by TanDL.
    • This reply was modified 7 years, 1 month ago by TanDL.
    #876436

    AJP
    Participant

    I think vouchers sound great! If I’m already paying $20K/year for my kid to go to Bush school, that means I’ll get voucher from the government (tax payers) to cover $5000 of my costs. Never mind all the other kids who still can’t afford the extra $15K. Discount for me, wahoo!

    I think we should extend it to parks too. I’m tired of going to the public park and finding trash, or just trashy people, hanging out there. I’d like my tax money to go to a voucher system instead. I won’t use the public parks, I’ll just take my park voucher to the local country club and put the tax payer’s money there. Let’s privatize libraries, too. Homeless people in the library–ew! Private library with my wealthy friends–yay! Can I use a voucher for my private fire and police departments too? Let’s do sewer systems!

    #876520

    JoB
    Participant

    AJP..
    i am going to read your post as tongue in cheek irony..
    anything else would spoil my day…

    #876583

    redblack
    Participant

    “school choice” is dog-whistle for for-profit education, which is pretty unamerican, in my opinion.

    we are a nation, and we are supposed to be born equally. we should, therefore, all be guaranteed a basic, universal education that competes with all other industrialized nations and ensures that our young adults understand the intrinsic workings of our universe by the age of 18 – regardless of socioeconomic status.

    the voucher and for-profit models seem to be thinly-veiled job recruitment programs for those who can afford them.

    furthermore, william seems to be frightened and paranoid. i don’t believe that fear is a good foundation for opinions on sociopolitical issues.

    we, as a nation, are better than that.

    • This reply was modified 7 years, 1 month ago by redblack.
    #877074

    williamf64
    Participant

    This is Sad.
    Normally I would thank you Liberals for giving us the “non-infected” a view of what the Liberal mental illness really looks like but in this case this is our schools we are talking about. Our Kids! Our Future!. The fact that Liberals pretend to care about our kids but use them strictly as pawns in a political game is .. like I said.. Sickening ! If Sick Ideology of Liberalism had a soul you would understand and be embarrassed.

    There is absolutely NO better example of how sickness of Liberalism has completely infected our public schools than the disgraceful announcement yesterday by the “ Great ?? “ State of New York. A prime example how the religious like devotion to a sick ideology Trumps ( I knew you would like that ) our childrens education. How Liberals truly don’t give one damn !
    Yes, The Great State of New York announced that they would be dropping the requirement for their TEACHERS to pass a Literacy test. Yes, you heard me right. Their “TEACHERS” to take and I am assuming to pass a LITERACY test because a disproportionate amount of Non-White teachers couldn’t pass the Literacy test.
    ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME !
    Teachers not being able to pass a Literacy test ? Only in the sick liberal mind could that possibly make any sense. ??

    So, rather than require TEACHERS to be LITERATE ( I can’t believe I have to say this ! ) and meet some basic standards of education before they attempt to teach our children which will provide the basic foundations for their future and the future of our society. Liberals will gladly sacrifice our childrens futures by dropping the LITERACY requirements. Yes, drop the LITERACY requirements ( I still can’t believe I am saying this ) for teachers rather than accept the fact that for some reason minority teaching applicants might need to work on and refine their basic LITERACY education before they teach our kids. TRUE NEGLECTFUL INSANITY !
    Gee.. Why would anyone CHOOSE to get the Hell out of that system ? . Oh wait.. OBama, Biden, Pelosi and ALL the rest DID. They send their kids to private schools. Hmmmm?

    It is more important that Liberals keep up the appearance of not being racists than our children be given the best education possible. The truly ironic thing about this is the fact that Maybe.. Just maybe. the reasons why these minority teachers can’t pass the Literacy tests ( I still can’t believe I am saying this..) is because their lack of ” Literacy ” education came from the same FAILED educations system. So, the state of new York is fighting to pass on the legacy of illiteracy ? OMG !

    I truly HOPE TO GOD that the same mental infection dosen’t permeate our nations life guard institutions this summer. Because under the same sick liberal Ideology if minority life guard applicants couldn’t pass the basic swimming tests to become Life guards then Liberals would certainly suggest to just drop the swimming requirements test ? Right ?
    Yes, rather than help those that can’t freak’n swim we are just going to ignore the whole thing and then act all shocked & horrified when people drown.
    Let’s see how many liberals would take their kids to that pool. SICKENING !

    #877099

    PangolinPie
    Participant

    First, I find it ironic (and sad) that someone who seems to be unaware of how punctuation and capital letters are used in the English language is so wound up about literacy. Oh, sorry; that’s LITERACY.

    Second, while I agree that teachers should be chosen from the most literate folks available, this test is one of four assessments “…introduced in the 2013-2014 school year as part of an effort to raise the level of elementary and secondary school teaching in the state.”*

    And the finding that “just 46 percent of Hispanic test takers and 41 percent of black test takers passed it on the first try, compared with 64 percent of white candidates”* is interesting. Your assumption is that the minorities who weren’t able to pass it can blame their education. That’s certainly one possibility, but isn’t it also at least a possibility that there are cultural biases in the test? And maybe rather than your all-caps, semi-literate freak-out, it might just be worth asking that question? Cultural bias in institutionalized testing is not a new or unknown thing.

    Additionally, I’m pretty darned sure that Trump’s kids all went to private school as well.

    Finally, williamf64: you are annoying and weird. I think you might want to seek help from a qualified therapist. Or at the very least try some meditation practices that could help you calm the f— down.

    *Source:
    http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/story/news/education/2017/03/11/test-meant-screen-teachers-instead-weeded-out-minorities/99050796/

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.