Update: West Seattle Water Taxi crashes downtown, 7 to hospital

(This was our Sunday coverage of the incident, from first report through evening updates – The Water Taxi *will* run a normal schedule, with an Argosy boat, Monday, says the county)

(Top photo courtesy Roy, who was on the Water Taxi when it hit, added 12:27 pm; below photo, WSB cameraphone, added 11:56 am)

ORIGINAL 11:29 AM REPORT: From the scanner, and we are en route – the medic call to Alaskan Way involves the Water Taxi from West Seattle colliding with crashing into its downtown dock. Minor injuries are reported. We’re on the way to find out more. No word yet how this will affect service.

11:35 AM UPDATE: From Amy, in comments:

My husband is on the water taxi that crashed with our two young sons. Apparently the boat crashed into the dock on the Seattle side. He has heard reports of someone with a bloody nose and can see a broken window, but otherwise it didn’t sound too bad. He said they are telling everyone to stay seated while they decide how to get everyone off the boat.

According to the scanner, seven people are believed to be hurt, and one may have been briefly knocked unconscious, but is conscious now. Also from the scanner (we are almost to the scene), rescuers are using the fireboat Leschi to help get people off the boat. Nearby Fire Station 5 (on the waterfront between Colman Dock and Ivar’s) is being used as a base of operations to stage medics.

11:57 AM UPDATE: We are downtown finding out more about what’s happened. Four ambulances are at Fire Station 5 awaiting the patients, who will be brought over from the dock. We’re adding photos.

12:03 PM UPDATE: Note that traffic on Alaskan Way is being affected – as is obviously the Water Taxi schedule – we are working to reach King County DOT to find out about their plans. At least 5 are confirmed hurt – 4 being put on stretchers at the scene, 1 who is “walking” – the 4 will be taken to the hospital by ambulance. Police and Coast Guard, meantime, are assisting on the water:

We have just spoken at the scene with a passenger named Mike from West Seattle who says they got warning at the last moment – the captain said, everybody hold on, we’re going to hit – but they were not traveling at excessive speed, in Mike’s opinion.

12:29 PM UPDATE: Five patients are going to the hospital – from the scanner description, one is more seriously hurt than the other four. We have just added a photo atop this story from Roy, who was on board when it happened (husband of Amy, who has reported twice now in comments). Christopher Boffoli has joined Patrick Sand at the scene for WSB coverage; Christopher stopped by the West Seattle dock on the way here and says people there hadn’t yet gotten news about what had happened and were wondering where the boat was.

12:38 PM UPDATE: The Rachel Marie is the boat that hit the dock – recently there was a substitution for maintenance, but we have confirmed this. The other boat that serves Water Taxi runs, usually to Vashon, Melissa Ann, will be summoned into service later today, says Linda Thielke of King County Department of Transportation, but West Seattle Water Taxi service is suspended until then (no estimated time yet).

1:06 PM UPDATE: From “E” in comments:

We were on the boat too! I luckily had just strapped our 11 week old baby in the bjorn. My husband was helping with our 3-year-old son in the stroller. They took a pretty good hit. Sad for my son because he’s still a little traumatized!!! We are at Seahawk game now and he’s doing a little better. Hopefully one day he’ll remember how fun it was to get rescued by the police boat!!

Meantime, Amy’s husband Roy, who shared the top photo, checked in:

He reports, “We were cruising into the dock. I had noticed the boat went past where it normally stops, then I heard them say something like ‘Jones to the Control Room’ and then ‘everyone please brace for impact, we have an emergency’ and boom, we crashed into the dock. It felt like being hit while in a moving car.” He held onto the kids and they were ok, although a seat came loose from the base of the floor. He observed one end of the pier now sticking through the window of the water taxi, where thankfully no one was sitting. He said, “I’ll put it this way: I’m glad we weren’t going any faster.”

Just got an update at the scene from Seattle Police Det. Jeff Kappel of the Media Unit, who will be briefing us and others shortly – he says seven people went to the hospital, all with “non-life-threatening” injuries. (Update – USCG did the briefing instead – photo below:)

1:39 PM UPDATE: Briefing from Coast Guard: Mechanical failure is suspected. They say no one went into the water. (added later – video of the briefing in its entirety)

Meantime, King County DOT says water-taxi service has resumed – the Melissa Ann went toward West Seattle at 1:30 and should be back on the regular schedule.

2:09 PM UPDATE: Adding more photos – the ones we’ve had till now (except for Roy’s, atop the story) were from the WSB BlackBerry. Here’s a closer look at where the Rachel Marie hit the seawall – right where the ironwork at the historic Washington Street Landing is:

Here are Coast Guard boats getting the injured people to shore:

2:49 PM UPDATE: The damaged Rachel Marie has been pulled away from the seawall, Christopher reports. He says it’s now tied up to its dock at Pier 50, while Seattle Police photograph damage to the seawall. Christopher says the impact appears to have taken out at least one piling. We’ll be checking with King County DOT regarding both the Rachel Marie’s condition and how, if at all, tomorrow’s Water Taxi schedule will be affected, since the Melissa Ann serves Vashon Mondays-Fridays. Meantime, Jason Grotelueschen just sent this photo of the Melissa Ann just arriving at Seacrest, with passengers disembarking:

3:34 PM UPDATE: We just added our video of the full briefing by USCG Lt. Jon Lane, following the entry two hours ago in which we summarized it. He said 73 people were on the Rachel Marie when this happened, including the crew, and it was reported to have been going about 6 knots at the time.

ADDED 4:17 PM: Two photos from Christopher, showing damage to the Rachel Marie, including the broken window, from outside:

7:43 PM UPDATE: Water Taxi service will be normal tomorrow, according to the latest from King County:

Water taxi service between West Seattle and downtown Seattle will operate on a normal schedule Monday, Sept. 27 between Seacrest Dock and Pier 55, according to the King County Department of Transportation.

Service was briefly suspended Sunday when the vessel Rachel Marie struck a waterfront landing adjacent to its regular docking location along Alaskan Way in downtown Seattle. Preliminary reports point to a mechanical malfunction. The U.S. Coast Guard is currently investigating the incident.

While regular service will resume Monday morning with the 6:50 a.m. sailing using an Argosy Cruises vessel, passengers should visit the King County Marine Division’s website at
http://www.kingcounty.gov/transportation/kcdot/WaterTaxi/WestSeattleRoute.aspx for updates and potential schedule adjustments.

Tonight we also have Christopher’s video of the Rachel Marie being pulled back from the collision scene:

ADDED 9:04 PM: West Seattleite Andrew Harms also was on board the Rachel Marie when it crashed into the seawall/historic pier and is sharing photos tonight – including one from the police boat that took him and more than 30 others to shore:

This is the piling mentioned earlier as having been taken out:

And from inside the Rachel Marie, seats tossed about:

We aren’t likely to get more details on the damage – to the seawall/pier as well as the Rachel Marie – till tomorrow.

51 Replies to "Update: West Seattle Water Taxi crashes downtown, 7 to hospital"

  • Amy September 26, 2010 (11:33 am)

    My husband is on the water taxi that crashed with our two young sons. Apparently the boat crashed into the dock on the Seattle side. He has heard reports of someone with a bloody nose and can see a broken window, but otherwise it didn’t sound too bad. He said they are telling everyone to stay seated while they decide how to get everyone off the boat. (Of course, staying seated is easier said than done with two highly energetic boys.)

  • WSB September 26, 2010 (11:35 am)

    Thanks – that’s what we heard on the scanner, they were trying to figure out how to clear passengers since they’re not sure of the dock’s stability (yet). – TR

  • Amy September 26, 2010 (11:40 am)

    Latest update: They’re being transported off on a police boat. DH sent a picture of my son looking thrilled.

  • Valerie September 26, 2010 (11:47 am)

    @Amy, I’m glad it turned out to be simply a thrilling adventure for your family :-)

  • Amy September 26, 2010 (12:06 pm)

    Just heard from hubby again. He reports, “We were cruising into the dock. I had noticed the boat went past where it normally stops, then I heard them say something like ‘Jones to the Control Room’ and then ‘everyone please brace for impact, we have an emergency’ and boom, we crashed into the dock. It felt like being hit while in a moving car.”

    He held onto the kids and they were ok, although a seat came lose from the base of the floor. He observed one end of the pier now sticking through the window of the water taxi, where thankfully no one was sitting. He said, “I’ll put it this way: I’m glad we weren’t going any faster.” He also said one woman was complaining of back pain, another person had a bloody nose, a lot of people were pretty shaken up, but otherwise everyone seems OK.

  • Mary T September 26, 2010 (12:17 pm)

    WTH? Didn’t the previous water taxi crash into the dock on Alki? ETA: Oh, right, it did in 2008.

  • Maggie Sudduth September 26, 2010 (12:29 pm)

    Which vessel was it – the Melissa Ann or Rachel Marie? Thanks.

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (12:37 pm)

      Maggie – I called Patrick to ask, he says Rachel Marie. There was the recent maintenance sub-out but of course on the weekend since Vashon doesn’t run they could have been using either, but this is what he’s seeing – TR

  • lina rose September 26, 2010 (12:35 pm)

    Hope everyone is okay and that this does not hurt water taxi service or support which is usually super safe and reliable.

  • Celeste September 26, 2010 (12:37 pm)

    Should be the Rachel Marie. The scary thing is that I would have been sitting right about there when I ride the boat.

  • E September 26, 2010 (12:53 pm)

    We were on the boat too! I luckily had just strapped our 11 week old baby in the bjorn. My husband was helping with our 3yr old son in the stroller. They took a pretty good hit. Sad for my son bc he’s still a little traumatized!!! We are at seahawk game now and he’s doing a little better. Hopefully one day he’ll remember how fun it was to get rescued by the police boat!! Tomorrow is his 3rd bday:-)

  • CarolPB September 26, 2010 (1:14 pm)

    P-I is reporting some passengers were in the water???

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (1:20 pm)

      Carol, we have been monitoring this incident from the start, from the very first shouted WATER TAXI COLLIDED WITH THE DOCK! first via scanner, and then we rushed downtown, and have two people at the scene. I have never heard anything about people in the water BUT that doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. Lots of public-info officers (for SPD, SFD and King County DOT) are here now and will brief soon, and if that really happened, we’ll await their confirmation. – Tracy

  • William September 26, 2010 (1:25 pm)

    KOMO’s website has photos of a man in the water.

  • Fred September 26, 2010 (1:35 pm)

    Look at the caption for the KOMO photo. It was the Coast Guard checking for people in the water and finding none.

  • CarolPB September 26, 2010 (1:36 pm)

    he was not a passenger-Coast Guardsman

  • Cami September 26, 2010 (1:37 pm)

    However, a Coast Guardsman who was walking in the area jumped into the water to look for passengers who might need rescuing.
    http://www.komonews.com/news/local/103821828.html

  • Diane September 26, 2010 (1:44 pm)

    yes, if you read caption on photo of man in water on komo “A Coast Guardsman jumped into the water after the crash landing to look for passengers who may have fallen into the water. It later was determined that no passengers went overboard”

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (2:08 pm)

      I tried to add this in comments 15 minutes ago but had connectivity problems after adding it to the main story. Coast Guard said it in the briefing, NO ONE WAS EVER IN THE WATER contrary to some citywide-media reports (aside from the USCG guy). – TR

  • Diane September 26, 2010 (2:19 pm)

    I just checked PI and Times websites; still both have incorrect info re “people in water” on top of their “news” sites; thankfully we can always rely on westseattleblog team for verified accurate reporting

  • CarolPB September 26, 2010 (2:29 pm)

    as usual, the best, most accurate reporting from WSB!

  • david September 26, 2010 (2:29 pm)

    KOMO is blasting the headline “at full speed”… If this boat had been going at full speed – 20 knots+ – it would look alot worse than the pictures and injuries I’m seeing/hearing.

  • Rod September 26, 2010 (2:31 pm)

    And then there’s the Seattle Times…”The person who fell overboard was immediately recovered, said Coast Guard Lt. Jon Lane.” Hmmmm

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (2:57 pm)

      Re: The Times’ account of a person overboard – I checked with them, since we are informal partners, and our contact tells me they talked by phone early on with a USCG person who gave them the account of a person falling overboard, but the USCG has since corrected that account and the Times has updated its story and home-page caption. – TR

  • William September 26, 2010 (2:38 pm)

    No worries, KOMO’s photo captions do not show up with all photo view options on their website. I saw the captions in a different viewing option after posting above. In any event, the tide is rising and will peak this evening about 4 to 5 feet higher than it is now (2:30 PM). What are authorities saying about that?

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (2:56 pm)

      William, re: the tide, that’s why they have pulled the boat out – it’s now back over at its regular berth, with the help of a tug etc. – TR

  • Jiggers September 26, 2010 (2:59 pm)

    The wolves are lining up and slap the city with a lawsuit.

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (3:00 pm)

      Jig, the water taxi’s operated by the county.

  • rainmaker September 26, 2010 (3:07 pm)

    I hope the injured recover quickly.

    King County / Dow Constantine have no business spending millions on Foot Ferries – the County’s top mandate is public safety, yet Constantine is cutting Police / Detectives and Courts. Foot Ferries are a lesser priority and should only be funded after enough funds are avaiable for Police / Courts. Let the cities (Seattle) or the State take care of ferries. Constantine needs to stop funding his pet projects and find funds for areas that are in his “real” job description.

  • William September 26, 2010 (3:20 pm)

    Typically, the Coast Guard will drug test the entire crew after this kind of incident.

    Lawsuits over the Staten Island Ferry crash a few years ago were staggering.

  • Jiggers September 26, 2010 (3:30 pm)

    Oh..county then. Either way, there’s goes that money that was going to keep it in operation year round. But what do I know.

  • david September 26, 2010 (3:42 pm)

    so rainmaker, we should shut down all the other subsidized transportation run by King County Metro? In the Puget Sound region (Sound refers to water by the way), why is water transportaion any less important than land based? Your agenda is obvious but I feel doesn’t hold water… and your rant seems misplaced.

  • west by southwest September 26, 2010 (3:55 pm)

    Years ago I worked on a boat of a similar size that crashed into a dock. The reason was a mechanical failure – a small screw connecting the gear box to the controls fell out and one of the engines did not reverse as the vessel was docking. I would not be surprised if the same thing happened here.

  • jp1seattle September 26, 2010 (4:13 pm)

    Cheers to the West Seattle Blog for reporting the facts and not trying to sensationalize this story. King 5 and Komo have been reporting numerous inaccuracies such as “hitting the dock full speed” and “several passengers thrown into the water”.

    Also, I have seen reports that the vessel was off course. Any of us that have ridden the West Seattle taxi know that when approaching Seattle, the boat swings wide and spins around so it docks facing West. The boat wasn’t off course at all.

  • Anne September 26, 2010 (4:39 pm)

    I was on the water taxi with my two daughters, five and three years old. We were seated up by the wheelhouse, and the captain called for James to come to the wheelhouse, he came running up and then ran back down apparently trying to resolve the issue. The engines were not running, but we were going at a pretty good clip, passing the dock, when the captain said, “emergency, brace for impact”. My 5 yr. old was in the aisle so I grabbed her, I held on to my 3 yr. old, and ten seconds after being warned we slammed into the pier. I flew off the seat with my girls and slammed into the bench in front of us, which came apart. My youngest was between me and the seat in front of us. I was very scared that she was injured. She had a pretty good bump on her head, but is okay. There was a coast guard man on one of the piers, and he jumped in, swam over to the taxi and climbed aboard to see if we were okay. That may be why people were saying someone went overboard.

  • Shari September 26, 2010 (5:06 pm)

    My husband and I were on the boat sitting inside front row on the left. Knew something was up when we passed the loading dock. Was told to prepare for collision and hit the seawall hard. Two were injured inside, hitting there heads on the glass. We all were toss around pretty good. The folks outside couldn’t hear the announcement so had less time to prepare before we hit. At least 6 to 7 people were hurt. They never told us to put our life jackets on until we loaded onto the US Coast Guard boats. I heard them talking about the boat taking on a small amount of water. It was pretty scary but we still made the game! Sore but doing ok.

  • R65 September 26, 2010 (5:07 pm)

    Of course it you look at the comments section on the times website, it’s nothing but negativity towards the water taxi period. Bunch of jealous non west seattleites complaining about overpriced it is and how much we don’t need it.

  • Mary T September 26, 2010 (6:14 pm)

    Anne, scary! So glad you’re okay!

    About the naysaying, personally I love the Water Taxi and wish there were runs, such as straight to the business district on Alki and closer to Belltown – I work in Belltown and I’d take the taxi every day if it went anywhere near there. Sigh.

  • ------- September 26, 2010 (6:31 pm)

    Why should taxpayers fund Constantine’s pet project, when he can’t even find funding for basic mandates within King County? Sounds like some folks want it all and could care less if others have no court / police service and get crimes committed against them due to lack of safety, yeah, a foot ferry is more important than keeping kids / people safe…(sarcasm here).

  • coffee September 26, 2010 (7:48 pm)

    I don’t know why people have to complain about alternate transportation methods. Not a single mass transit system is there to make money. They are all funded by the government. I am sure that the ones knocking the water taxi are also never ever complaining about traffic, gas cost, parking costs, car repair costs, etc….. I use mass transit when possible and would use it quite a bit more if I could.

  • Robert September 26, 2010 (8:14 pm)

    I rode the 6:30 sailing back to West Seattle tonight and the ol’ Sightseer was parked at the water taxi dock at Seacrest. I asked one of the deck hands if the Sightseer was going to be temporarily used while the Rachel Marie was being repaired. He couldn’t say however it would be nice to have it back for a couple commutes into town next week. In the last couple weeks the Rachael Marie was pulled from service and at one point the Kitsap Passenger Ferry was running trips to Vashon while the Melissa Ann ran the West Seattle route, is it possible they were already having problems with Rachael Marie and was still questionable of her performance? I ride this almost everyday and I hope this accident doesn’t limit the proposed winter services.

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (8:44 pm)

      Robert – The Rachel Marie was put into drydock earlier this month for what was described as “maintenance,” announced more than a week in advance. I asked KC DOT tonight if they expected to have more information tomorrow regarding damage and how long the RM would be out – they’re not sure yet but we will be checking. If you saw the Sightseer there, I wouldn’t be surprised to hear if that’s the Argosy Cruises vessel they plan to use – since it had never used the new dock, they would have had to do some practice ahead of time – we’ll be out checking early in the morning … TR

  • Tim Flanagan September 26, 2010 (8:53 pm)

    Excellent coverage.

    One slight clarification: Rachel Marie “allided” with the landing. They can’t “collide”, since the landing is stationary. Pedantic mariner jargon, perhaps, but watch the USCG news briefing and you’ll hear Lt. Lane use the proper term.

    • WSB September 26, 2010 (9:18 pm)

      Thanks, Tim, thought I had fixed that somewhere along the way but maybe not. Since unfortunately even for a word nerd like me, allide is not a familiar word, I will probably change any remaining “collide” to “crashed into” … TR

  • chas redmond September 26, 2010 (9:27 pm)

    Allision is the act of dashing against or striking upon; it is often used to describe the action of one boat hitting against another, or of the sea dashing against a boat. The word is commonly used in place of “collision” to distinguish that one of the objects was fixed.

    interesting that the marine world has it’s own lexicon – as it should. Rare that the two intersect in a headline, though.

  • Tim Flanagan September 26, 2010 (9:27 pm)

    It’s a minor quibble, and most people wouldn’t have any idea what you meant if you used it in a headline anyway. “Rams” is good enough for my audience at PugetSoundMaritime.com, for instance! :-)

  • JD September 26, 2010 (9:30 pm)

    I miss the Sightseer

  • cjboffoli September 26, 2010 (9:32 pm)

    Tim: Excellent point! You definitely merit the triple word score.

    But what about Newtonian physics? The Third Law of Motion (the mutual actions of two bodies upon each other are always equal) would dictate that when the water taxi hit the dock, the dock hit back. All forces are interactions and there is no such thing as a unidirectional force.

    Just a little Newtonian pedantry for you :-)

  • Michael September 26, 2010 (9:53 pm)

    Seriously? Has any headline writer in the history of the English language ever used “allide”?

  • Chuck September 26, 2010 (9:55 pm)

    I can’t WAIT to see SIGHTSEER ON MONDAY!! Yah!

  • Tim Flanagan September 26, 2010 (9:59 pm)

    We could go Einsteinian and say that no objects are REALLY “stationary” at all, so every crash IS a “collision”. :-)

Sorry, comment time is over.