HA, good luck. WSeattle is totally devoid of a good bagel place. I’d even go so far as to say we’re even at a loss of a good (not super fancy crazy flavor of the month type) doughnut shop around here. Maybe White Center? Wish I knew!
Closest I know is Blazing Bagels on 1st/ Lander. Yes, I know that’s out of the area you are asking about. Grocery store bagels, even from a local bakery are awful, so are Trader Joes. All bad.
Eltana delivers to West Seattle. I found this out during the pandemic and it totally boosted my spirits. They will provide freezer bags too. I think they deliver in WS every other Friday. I agree with the others, I’ve found no good bagels in WS. I do love Good Day in White Center for doughnuts though!
Not bagels, but if you want absolutely wonderful english muffins, Patch Pocket Productions is West Seattle based and does home delivery on Saturdays. Order via the instagram page: https://www.instagram.com/patch.pocket.productions/ Order by Wednesday and pay via venmo, and they get delivered Saturday. They have pretzels too and pepper cheese that are amazing too.