BIZNOTE: Portage Bay Cafe closing West Seattle Junction location (updated)

(WSB photo from Portage Bay’s West Seattle opening day in 2023)

1:16 PM: Almost four years after expanding to West Seattle with a location in The Junction, Portage Bay Café has just announced it’s closing in WS. We talked by phone with owner Amy Fair Gunnar shortly after she made the announcement. It’s one of five locations the local mini-chain has, and she says the other four are going strong, but – especially given the “soaring costs” of operating a restaurant – this one has a fundamental problem, not enough indoor seating to get it through the fall/winter season. “We are really sorry to be leaving West Seattle,” she told us. “We’ll miss our guests.” She also noted that the Washington Hospitality Association has tallied ~2,000 restaurant closures this year, which she says outnumbers the closures during the first year of COVID. We asked about the West Seattle staff; she said they’re finding places at their other restaurants for “pretty much everybody.” The last day for the breakfast/brunch café at 4725 42nd SW will be Sunday, October 25. (Portage Bay was preceded in the space by Agave Cocina for three years, and before that, Fresh Bistro for nine years.)

8:55 PM: In comments, readers pointed out an August Seattle Times story about Portage Bay’s financial challenges. We subsequently checked court records and discovered a more-recent “unlawful detainer” action pertaining to this location – often a prelude to eviction if back rent isn’t paid up – at least $137,000 worth, per the court documents, as of late August. The court records show the next hearing date is October 29, four days after the West Seattle location’s just-announced closing date.

51 Replies to "BIZNOTE: Portage Bay Cafe closing West Seattle Junction location (updated)"

  • WS Ghoul October 14, 2026 (1:22 pm)

    we’re running out of brunch options in the Junction 😭

    • Derek October 14, 2026 (6:39 pm)

      Phoenecia next door and Jak’s have great brunch! I agree though we could always use more

    • Matt October 14, 2026 (7:38 pm)

      We still here. Serving brunch since 1999! Hopefully u like music too! Open at 7am daily. Breakfast brunch til 3! Killer coffee, killer bacon! Got a favorite dish? Dolly Parton Stack maybe? Johnny Cash Special? Jamesbrowns? Horton Heat Hash? Frances Farmer French Toast? Try us! Seattle Met Breakfast Hall of Fame ! 

      • Honey Bearsford October 14, 2026 (8:30 pm)

        The SKYLARK ?

      • BlairJ October 14, 2026 (8:40 pm)

        Where?

        • WSB October 14, 2026 (9:04 pm)

          That’s Matt from the iconic Easy Street Records & Café nearby.

      • Celiac October 15, 2026 (9:34 pm)

        Hi Matt, love Easy Street. Provide some gluten free and safe from cross contamination food and we’ll be there! 

    • The Real JP October 14, 2026 (8:44 pm)

      How so? On the contrary, in my experience there are too many restaurants that foist brunch menus on you on the weekend and it is a pet peeve of mine when they don’t allow you to order from the standard lunch menu. I have no use for brunch. I know breakfast can be highly profitable for operators, but I never understood the model for places like PB where the operator pays what I assume are extremely high rents and then are closed for 33-50% of core eating occasions.

    • AN October 15, 2026 (8:04 am)

      Pegasus serves a great one!

    • mlee October 15, 2026 (11:45 am)

       Jaks, Pegasus, Phoenecia, Shadowland, Husky Deli (Breakfast sandwiches and coffee) & Easy Street all have brunch.. Donuts at Top Pot and Dough Joy & Bakery Nouevau I’d say we are doing pretty good with brunch spots. Portage Bay had horrible hours that’s why most everyone I knew never went. 

      • estoy aquí October 17, 2026 (11:03 am)

        Add Taste and Best, which offers American breakfasts. I haven’t yet been there for breakfast, though. Glad to see the list. Yeah, I know I can cook my own, but having someone take my order, serve me,  and do the dishes makes breakfast out my favorite meal! (No, I don’t eat breakfast out that often.)
        Also, Phoenicia offers wonderful small plate brunch items. Highly recommend!

  • K October 14, 2026 (1:50 pm)

    Really sad, but not surprised for the exact reasons the owner cited.  Maybe a White Center expansion is next?

    • JJM October 14, 2026 (7:30 pm)

      That’s where Pegasus is expanding. 

  • Juanita October 14, 2026 (2:06 pm)

    I’ve eaten at their locations in South Lake Union (not crazy about the service), Roosevelt, and of course WS.  First, I hope that they find a place for Heather, if she is still the manager at the WS location.  I haven’t been to that location in a few months, but she’s always been phenomenal.  Second, I don’t understand limited indoor seating as being the reason they’re closing.  Unlike 3 of the other locations, (the South Lake Union, Ballard and Roosevelt locations), the one in WS is closed on Tues and Weds until Spring.  I can tell from the last two visits I’ve made to the Roosevelt location, seems like there’s some staffing issues.  And yes, both the South Lake Union and Roosevelt locations have more seating, but I’ve been to both when whole sections have been closed off.  The WS location is usually full.  Why would you close a location that consistently sells out without trying to relocate it in the same neighborhood?  Scary to think operating costs would be higher here than their other locations.  Sorry to see another business close and yet another where you could get a decent meal and good service.

    • Mark M October 16, 2026 (5:44 am)

      The culprit is likely rent. Everyone points to food costs and staffing, but the bulk of costs is rent. The issue is landlords charging business too much, but no one talks about it. 

      • Unpaid Vendor October 23, 2026 (10:02 pm)

        The culprit is not rent, Mark; it’s poor management.

  • Hollendaise October 14, 2026 (2:51 pm)

    August 31, this year, TST reported on Portage Bay’s finances including lawsuits for back rent on two of its facilities as well as a $240,000 owed to the state.  
    Amy Fair Gunnar at that time denied any upcoming closures. “We have no intention of closing our doors,” Gunnar said.

  • D-Mom October 14, 2026 (3:10 pm)

    This is actually my favorite location because of the smaller space. The others are so loud, that if I can’t sit outside, I won’t go. Sad to see this seems to be the model for them. 

  • Natty Ice Sipper October 14, 2026 (3:15 pm)

    I’m sorry to see so many empty and replaced locations at the Junction, but also, Go Hawks

  • Joan October 14, 2026 (4:56 pm)

    Never went due to limited days and hours, and it was always crowded anyway.  I once went to the Lake Union one and  thought it was nice and good food. Too bad. We desperately need more variety in WS.

  • Paul October 14, 2026 (5:09 pm)

    The only time I visited this location, the service was terrible. It was obvious everyone was phoning it in. I wonder if service has declined ar their other locations. 

  • Burgerman October 14, 2026 (5:39 pm)

    Once again the insane rents in the West Seattle Junction take down a fan favorite. Y’all still loving pure capitalism and landlord greed?

  • LG October 14, 2026 (5:46 pm)

    This spot would make a perfect Dough Zone! 

  • Sam October 14, 2026 (7:55 pm)

    Food was absolutely terrible. Hopefully something good goes into the location! 

  • Chris October 14, 2026 (8:11 pm)

    The Seattle Times had an article from August 31st of this year, specifically reporting on Portage Bays financial difficulties, including back taxes, back rent, as well as a lawsuit regarding their Greenlake lease.They closed their Sodo commissary kitchen as well to save costs.  While the West Seattle location was not as big as say, SLU, it wasn’t small by any stretch. Really too bad.

    • WSB October 14, 2026 (8:52 pm)

      I apologize, I am off my game today. I should have checked court records as a matter of routine, which I usually do in business-closure stories. There is an unlawful detainer action pending for this location, alleging six figures of unpaid rent – this type of action is a prelude to eviction if not cleared up.- TR

  • Rob October 14, 2026 (9:51 pm)

    West seattle  needs a Dennys!!

    • Actualperson October 15, 2026 (6:13 am)

      Had one south of the Junction @ where WS Nursery is. Started out as Sambo’s then became Dennys. Closed up @ mid to late 80’s. If memory serves me correct was a movie theater in that block too.

      • Jeff S October 15, 2026 (8:54 am)

        That restaurant was at Hudson and California, a bit north of the Nursery. Where those condos are now.  I can’t recall a movie theater but I do know the Rite Aid/CVS was a Safeway once.

      • B October 17, 2026 (9:55 am)

        I think the corner was a Herfy’s, and Denny’s was where the veterinarian is now

      • Leonette October 18, 2026 (12:14 pm)

        Granada Theater, long ago…

    • Burgerman October 15, 2026 (2:58 pm)

      Not before it gets a Jimmy John’s!

    • EL October 16, 2026 (6:33 am)

      Or even better – an IHOP !

    • Citizen Joe October 24, 2026 (12:45 am)

      Denny’s? Heck no. They microwave their prepackaged food. It’s a terrible choice. More local, less chain.

  • KT October 15, 2026 (4:18 am)

    Apparently Pegasus Pizza serves breakfast now according to their online menu.

  • Keenan October 15, 2026 (7:14 am)

    If you want a quick brunch in the Junction, go to Easy Street.  It’s the only reasonably priced place on the block.

    If you actually want a NICE brunch, you’re not going to find it in the Junction.  Portage Bay charged 3x what their mid food was worth, and if they have to close due to “financial difficulties” then it seems impossible that a dedicated brunch place will EVER be successful here until the landlords get their heads out of their asses and stop charging rents only venture capital-backed corpo chain restaurants can afford to pay.

    For a nice brunch, get down to Alki.  Harry’s Beach House will give you an excellent meal plus a great view if you’re sitting outside.

    • local October 15, 2026 (8:56 am)

      Kinda beg to differ on Harry’s. It’s a beautiful restaurant, but the food is not worth the price. It’s well presented and enjoyable, and the location is chef’s kiss – but I paid something like $24 for a slice of quiche once that was NOT it. Pricing is consistently wild. They also have some staff that act overly snobby (not all, but some). 

    • The Real JP October 15, 2026 (2:23 pm)

      Well it must be hard to find the cash flow to pay rent when your business is closed for half the day. That model might work in SLU where you’ve got a large captive audience of office employees, but the WS location never made sense, particularly considering a material amount of indoor space was the bar. Harry’s is one of those places that forces you to order from the brunch menu on weekends so I need to play hookey from work on the weekdays to get their delicious tuna melt. Brunch sucks.

    • Burgerman October 15, 2026 (3:02 pm)

      Jak’s had a very good brunch before it changed locations – I can’t speak to the current location. But yes, Easy Street is the best and only reasonably-priced option in the Junction. You do get a full meal for your money, too. I’m never left wanting more.Hear, hear on the greedy landlord problem! Absolutely ruining the potential of the Junction, despite it being pretty good even with those landlords.

    • Les H October 17, 2026 (5:18 pm)

      I beg to disagree! Their food was very high-quality, most often organic and locally sourced. More than you can say about 99% of restaurants in West Seattle.

  • RJB October 15, 2026 (8:15 am)

    Easy Steet is the best!! Soundgarden burger w/fries and ranch is something I should be eating everyday!!! Great music you get to listen to while be delighted…yum!

  • SEG October 15, 2026 (1:35 pm)

    I’m very sad to hear this. 

  • real wendy October 15, 2026 (4:44 pm)

    Kurt Cobain would have loved the West Seattle location of the Portage Bay restaurant franchise… Such a shame.

  • Jade October 15, 2026 (7:57 pm)

    What a bummer. Great place. Great vibe. Great food. 

    • scrumble October 16, 2026 (7:05 am)

      This is the first time I’ve heard anyone call it great food. It was bland, overpriced food and I’m baffled they lasted this long.        

      • Citizen Joe October 24, 2026 (12:47 am)

        The food was amazing. This location added variety to The Junction.

  • anonyme October 16, 2026 (4:29 pm)

    Seating was not the problem; I never saw the place full, except for the week it opened.  I agree with Scrumble, the food was mediocre and overpriced, and the hours were weird.  I wish someone else in the Junction served a good Eggs Benedict with hash browns instead of the awful roasted potatoes at PB.  I love almost any kind of potato, but not those.

  • Rb October 16, 2026 (8:25 pm)

    I like portage bay but here are the reasons why I rarely go. 1. Parking is hard in the junction. 2. Horrible times when they are open. 3. Too many choices in the junction. I wish they were in ither parts of west seattle with fewer restaurants. Maybe on 35th? Delridge?

  • Les H October 17, 2026 (5:14 pm)

    I’m so very disappointed to learn that Portage Bay Café is closing. Why not find a larger space instead of leaving West Seattle altogether?I was thrilled when they opened here. Years ago, I used to take visiting authors to the original Portage Bay in Ballard, and when the West Seattle location opened, I started bringing my guests here instead. I’ve been a regular ever since. Having a restaurant of this caliber in our own neighborhood has been a gift.I understand that seating runs short in winter, when the outdoor space can’t be used. I’ve often sat outside myself, but I also order to go regularly, including for group lunch meetings. Why not build a more permanent, heated outdoor space, like the one Elliott Bay Brewery has on California? Or go takeout-only for the winter months and advertise it widely?I know West Seattle rents are steep and climbing. But perhaps a location closer to Fauntleroy and California would be a bit more affordable and offer more parking and room for customers. Or as far south of Westwood Village? Having more patrons than you can seat sounds like a good problem to have. Why not expand?There are so few places in West Seattle that serve organic, local, sustainably farmed food. Portage Bay and the Box Bar are the only ones I know of for sure, so my choices are about to shrink to one, and the Box Bar doesn’t open until late afternoon. That leaves me nowhere to go for breakfast or lunch, since I never have time to leave West Seattle at that time of day.And the food! The incredible lemon ricotta pancakes with raspberry lemon curd. The gluten-free lingonberry Swedish pancakes. The endless variations on challah French toast. The fruit bar!  The awesome variety of egg dishes including locally sourced Beechers cheese!  With so many healthy, delicious choices for vegans, vegetarians, meat eaters, and gluten-free diners alike, I can bring a group and know that everyone will find something to love. It’s the only restaurant in West Seattle I know of that offers all of that, and I’ve always felt welcome knowing my vegetarian/vegan and gluten-free family members would be easily accommodated there.Sadly, I’ll be out of town next weekend, so we’ll have to squeeze in one last visit this week. It’s hard to accept that this may be my last Portage Bay meal, since I’m rarely outside West Seattle during the hours they atr open. Is there anything we can do to change the owner’s mind, or to convince her to try a different version of the café here?  Shirley there’s some kind of save?  Maybe they can open on Sundays in the Box Bar location this winter when the BB is closed and offer a Sunday brunch in partnership!

  • JS October 18, 2026 (1:29 pm)

    “Lack of indoor/outdoor seating” seems off. The rent costs are high everywhere but not sure why that matters if you stop paying rent for over a year! Funny the owner didn’t mention their commissary kitchen eviction in August and the local vendors who stopped delivering due to back payments or the employees late payroll. The West Seattle location was always busy especially on the weekends, inside and out. The staff was amazing, especially Yasmin and the manager Heather, she was the best and I will miss seeing her. The prices were high but they didn’t close for a lack of business!

Sorry, comment time is over.