$30 million claim filed by family of man shot and killed by police outside Southwest Precinct

(WSB photo, March 2025)

A local law firm has announced that it’s just filed a $30 million claim against the city on behalf of the family of the man shot and killed by police outside the Southwest Precinct a year and a half ago. Attorneys Mark Lindquist and Angus Lee allege in their news release that “Seattle police officers were negligent, used excessive force, and violated the Americans with Disabilities Act, among other state and federal causes of action arising from the preventable death.” The shooting happened on March 19, 2025, after 36-year-old Andrew Seay was encountered in the parking lot on the west side of the precinct. His wife had called 911 earlier to say he was in the area of The Home Depot next door and in crisis. According to the law firm’s summary, officers tried to get him to leave the lot, and he “would follow directions, and then turn and meander. … While meandering, Mr. Seay pulled out a folding pocketknife. He moved toward officers, then stepped back and away. Officers told him to drop the knife. Mr. Seay appeared confused, turned and moved around a patrol car. He continued to meander for more than a minute. A supervisor directed an officer to deploy (a “less lethal” device).” The law firm says that happened just seven seconds later, and while Mr. Seay moved away from that device, he moved toward the officer who subsequently fired his gun four times – the only officer to shoot – an officer who they say was 35 feet away, outside the “21-foot reaction-distance benchmark.” Attorney Lindquist is quoted as saying, “Mr. Seay’s death could have been prevented if officers had used a Taser, or used the less lethal launcher without delay, or followed Seattle’s own polices on de-escalation.” The news release also notes, “The King County Prosecutor declined to file charges, but the standards in a criminal case are far different than a civil action. ” What’s just been filed (see the document here) is not a lawsuit, but a potential step toward one – the city has two months to consider it, and if they deny the claim, a lawsuit could be filed.

39 Replies to "$30 million claim filed by family of man shot and killed by police outside Southwest Precinct"

  • Joy September 30, 2026 (1:46 pm)

    I hope the family gets what they deserve and they can move on with their lives comfortably!

  • Bobonalki September 30, 2026 (1:52 pm)

    I’m sure the family would much rather have Andrew back than the $30 million.  

    • John October 1, 2026 (5:06 am)

      Zero chance they win that lawsuit. Get real 

      • Derp October 2, 2026 (9:44 am)

        They will win this one with no problem.  A cop shoots the guy from 35′ for a folded pocket knife. This will settle out of court for more than 30m. You need to get real. Chicken cop shooting from 35′, you get serious. 

  • Oerthehillz September 30, 2026 (2:39 pm)

    So today this would have been handled by the CARE team instead of police? Just curious if CARE staff are equipped with tasers or some other means to get control of someone with a knife. 

    • WSB September 30, 2026 (3:13 pm)

      Not in a situation with a weapon.

  • Alki September 30, 2026 (3:14 pm)

    Keep suing the city you know they’ll pay, time for more property taxes

  • Common sense September 30, 2026 (3:40 pm)

    A stumbling man with a folding pocket knife who is 35 feet away from an officer is not an imminent threat to the officer. I hope that officer is no longer on the force. 

    • WSzombie September 30, 2026 (10:44 pm)

      So by your logic, snipers shouldn’t support SWAT teams because “the threat isn’t imminent”. “Common sense”, right, ok. 

      • Pete October 1, 2026 (7:46 am)

        Grow up. All over the world, police forces regularly disarm people with knives without shooting them. We can obviously do much better as a society than what happened here. 

    • ltfd October 2, 2026 (11:41 am)

      Disagree.

  • CarDriver September 30, 2026 (3:44 pm)

    For those decrying what the police did I have a question.If someone unknown to you clearly having a mental health or drug fueled issue comes after you what would you do- other than run away and hope that they don’t shoot? SPD used to offer ride along. If they do would be very educational to see what goes on in the real world and not from your recliner behind double locked doors.

    • Lauren September 30, 2026 (5:36 pm)

      What you’re describing — someone coming after you with a gun — is not at all what happened here. 

    • AMD September 30, 2026 (6:03 pm)

      I have been in the situation you described.  The man was walking down the sidewalk swinging a chain before wrapping it around his fist and swinging AT me.  He hit me in the arm.  I moved along.  I was fine.  He continued to swing his chain at a tree when I was no longer in his way.  I wasn’t armed at all.  I probably could have ducked into the coffee shop nearby and avoided the punch in the arm, but he was clearly not experiencing the same reality I was, so I thought I could just dodge him.  If he had a knife I would have made sure there was space between us.  That opportunity existed.  The man did not have a gun.  A knife is not a threat from 35 feet away.  I am decrying the police because I, a rando person with zero crisis training, should not have better crisis management skills than a supposedly trained and well-paid police officer. 

      I also have personal experience with this particular officer after a much less serious incident.  He wasn’t doing his job well or following department protocol for that incident either.  People in any profession are capable of being bad at their jobs, and police are no exception.  Instead of making it a political cause to defend bad cops, maybe we should actually start holding them accountable so the city isn’t paying out 8-9 figures’ worth of lawsuits every year.

      • JohnFrey September 30, 2026 (10:43 pm)

        This is crazy, my grandmother was actually paralyzed by that same chain wielding man. She mentioned how she saw a man swinging a chain at a tree a few  moments after swinging at people. She unfortunately happened to be his next target and got assaulted, leaving her with several cracked vertebrae.Did you just do nothing to help the situation? Crazy to just pretend a dude swinging a chain at people is an easy walk around. Shameful.

    • T Rex October 2, 2026 (2:29 pm)

      THANK YOU, CAR DRIVER!  Glad to see there are other folks who do not hate the police the way many do, yet I am guessing that they would also be the first to complain if THEY needed a police officer and one was not available. My best friend in another state is a crisis responder, and trust me, she has seen things none of us want to see.  And she would NEVER respond to something like this without a police officer.  Folks who are experiencing a mental crisis are very unpredictable; they are also NOT afraid to harm others and are very capable of doing. As sad as the stories are, it will happen at times that there is no other choice. 

  • Nate September 30, 2026 (4:31 pm)

    Maybe people need to take responsibility for their own actions and quit blaming the police doing their jobs. This man broke into a secure sight and was told to leave and refused to do so. 

    • Brian October 1, 2026 (6:11 am)

      It is not the job of the police to murder citizens because they’re inconvenienced by their presence. 

      • Nate October 2, 2026 (6:45 pm)

        Use of force and murder are two different definitions. The officers used necessary force to make subject to comply. The result of the force was he succumbed to his injuries. The lawyers and judges will decide that.

    • Derp October 1, 2026 (9:05 am)

      He didn’t break in, he climbed the fence.  He was told to leave and was doing so.  You have no compassion for anyone or anything. I hope you don’t have a crisis and need help. The cop who shot this guy should have been fired and then tried for murdered.  Come on,  a pocket knife and you are a trained, Supposedly, police officer and you are scared of a folder pocket knife. At 35′ away.  

      • Nate October 1, 2026 (4:01 pm)

        Climbing a fence is breaking in. Also you don’t know me well enough to make those kind of statements.

  • Dp September 30, 2026 (4:52 pm)

    I’m sorry, but the officers only have seconds sometimes to decide what to do. He started coming at them. They don’t know what he’s going to do. They did what they had to do. The suit shouldn’t go through. Officers go through these trainings and you don’t know what they will do. 

  • Dad September 30, 2026 (5:01 pm)

    I have seen the video, it’s an extremely sad and unfortunate occurrence and also clearly a justified use of deadly force by the officer.  I hope people in Mr. Seay’s situation get the care they need. 

  • Time to say no September 30, 2026 (10:22 pm)

    The city should take action and challenge these extreme lawsuits. 

    • k October 1, 2026 (6:27 am)

      The city is a party to the lawsuit.  They challenge every suit when they answer the summons.  They keep losing because they keep putting cops with histories of not following SPD protocol on patrol, fail to hold police who are bad at their jobs accountable time and time again, and fail to protect the people of Seattle in doing so.  What’s extreme is shooting a man to death who called 911 to ask for help, instead of actually helping him.

      • Canton October 2, 2026 (6:23 am)

        Verifiable proof?…

    • WSzombie October 1, 2026 (11:16 pm)

      To avoid public backlash, insurance usually settles out of court. The family will probably get 5-10% ($1.5-$3 million)  from insurance that was paid for with our tax dollars. 

  • David French September 30, 2026 (11:36 pm)

    The city shouldn’t give this family a dime. These attorneys are ambulance chasers. Google “Las Cruces PD knife attack video” and see how quickly and deadly a knife attack is. Warning: the officer dies in the video. 

    • Pete October 1, 2026 (7:49 am)

      What an odd reply. Posting a link to a totally different set of circumstances doesn’t really help your rather worrying argument. 

  • Steve September 30, 2026 (11:42 pm)

    They are not gonna win that one. I watched the video.

  • Rocky October 1, 2026 (8:41 am)

    I can’t believe some of the people in the comments are my neighbors. Very disappointing.

  • Pookie October 1, 2026 (11:15 am)

    He pulled a knife and charged at officers. I sure the hope the jury sees this for what it was. A justified shooting. 

  • Lagartija Nick October 1, 2026 (12:34 pm)

    It’s frightening how many people here believe that “snipers” “SWAT teams” and shoot first are normal aspects of policing. 40 years of fear propaganda has clearly done it’s job. Remember folks, comply or die isn’t freedom.

    • WSzombie October 1, 2026 (11:19 pm)

      Who said snipers were “normal policing”? You ever see hostage situations where a guy has a knife or a gun held against a child? Unique situations call for unique solutions. My point was that just because YOU aren’t in immediate danger doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to protect someone who is. 

  • MKN October 1, 2026 (2:21 pm)

    30 million would go a long way to have beds available for those experiencing a mental health issue.  There’s simply not enough help available for people in crisis.

  • Mike October 1, 2026 (2:31 pm)

    Watch the video, note the guy with knife charged the police less than the full length of the 16.5′ police cruiser.  That’s way shorter than 21 feet, which only takes a guy with a knife 1.5 seconds.  16.5′ is less than 1.5 seconds to react before getting stabbed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tueller_Drill

    • ltfd October 2, 2026 (11:45 am)

      True. Thank you.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.