CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: Woman arrested, charged in three West Seattle business burglaries, and others (update: released)

By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor

A suspect has been arrested and charged in three West Seattle business burglaries – in addition to four others around the city. All but one were burglaries at pet-supply shops. The suspect is 27-year-old Teresa R. Scavotto, seen here in a photo from the charging documents:

The seven counts of second-degree burglary include April 16 break-ins in the West Seattle Junction, at Next-to-Nature (as reported here) and co-owned The Hydrant next door. All the other charges involve locations of All The Best Pet Care, including the West Seattle shop at 4722 Fauntleroy Way SW, which the charging papers say was burglarized on April 15.

Though Scavotto is alleged to have stolen two dog jackets from the local All The Best – detectives note she had a dog with her when she was arrested – her primary targets, investigators say, were the stores’ safes, from which she allegedly procured thousands of dollars in cash. Here’s a paragraph from the detective’s report included in the charging papers, describing her alleged MO:

… After reviewing the cases, I observed the following similarities. The same vehicle used in all 3 incidents. The same method of entry being that of breaking the front window and going in through there. Teresa immediately proceeded to look for a safe. Teresa then uses the same bright colored crowbar to try and pry a safe open or completely off. Despite Teresa wearing a face covering, the same body type and build can be observed in all 5 incidents.

The same hair type could be seen in one of the incidents, it is styled in dreads and blonde in color. This same hair color would then later be seen during (her) arrest. The same green vest in the last 2 burglaries would later be found in the stolen vehicle with money coming out from it. The angle grinder in the stolen vehicle which was consistent in the damage that occurred during the last two burglaries. The black sling style backpack that Teresa was wearing in one of the burglaries also being found in the driver seat of the vehicle. …

The “stolen vehicle” refers to a car through which she was traced when tracking technology placed it at a north Seattle storage unit linked to her – a storage unit in which some burglary loot was found, including jewelry stolen from The Hydrant. She was arrested at the storage site and then charged in the vehicle theft; jail records show she was booked on that case late in the day on April 16 – same day as the burglaries at Next-to-Nature and The Hydrant – and released one day later. She didn’t appear for arraignment and was arrested on a warrant for that May 3; she is still in jail today, in lieu of $55,000 bail, and was due for arraignment on the burglary charges today. The new documents say she has a criminal history in the past four years including theft, obstructing an officer, and carrying a concealed pistol without a license

8:29 PM: At today’s arraignment on both these charges and the auto-theft case, Scavotto pleaded not guilty, and Judge Nelson Lee granted her lawyer’s motion for release, provided she reports to the alternative program CCAP starting tomorrow morning. We found the documents in the car theft case; the Honda Civic in the case against Scavotto was one of seven vehicles prosecutors say were taken in an April burglary from Crash Champions at 4501 38th SW in West Seattle. No surveillance video reported in that case so Scavotto is not charged in that burglary, though detectives wrote that some car keys also taken in that burglary were found in the car she is charged with stealing. Her next hearing is scheduled for June.

36 Replies to "CRIME WATCH FOLLOWUP: Woman arrested, charged in three West Seattle business burglaries, and others (update: released)"

  • Well done May 11, 2026 (2:58 pm)

    Keep her locked up in her kennel. Well done SPD. Grateful for you. 

  • Lauren May 11, 2026 (3:55 pm)

    Quite surprised she could even fit through the window she broke at All the Best. 

    • Rude May 12, 2026 (2:54 pm)

      Fat shaming is unnecessary.

    • Taylor May 13, 2026 (2:05 am)

      You should be ashamed of yourself for posting this

  • WS4Life May 11, 2026 (3:57 pm)

    Procured? More like stole!

  • What about her dog? May 11, 2026 (4:06 pm)

    Excellent work, SPD!! keep her locked up. She doesn’t deserve to be out ruining businesses that work so hard and do so many wonderful things for our community such as next to nature.Where is her dog? I hope the Little Dog is OK.

  • anonyme May 11, 2026 (4:31 pm)

    I think there should be mandatory work requirements in jail, unless a prisoner is disabled.  And I don’t mean peeling potatoes in prison, I mean a job that benefits society. It seems like many criminals put more work into committing their crimes than it would to just get a job – especially if you’re using an angle grinder and taking apart walls while burglarizing a business.

    • Duck May 11, 2026 (6:34 pm)

      Able bodied prisoners are already required to work and are paid little to nothing. It is *literally* legalized slavery. Say you’re pro slavery with your whole chest next time, and maybe Google your hot take – or, you know, read the 13th amendment- before you post it.

      • fund public education May 11, 2026 (9:30 pm)

        oh, you want them to do jobs that “benefit society.” Like the ones who work alongside wildland firefighters, doing the same job, yet are unable to be hired by departments after their release. I’m sure that makes them feel positively towards their community and their country. Honestly, the fact that your take is underinformed is almost as annoying as the fact that it’s bad. 

        • anonyme May 12, 2026 (6:08 am)

          Actually, yes, firefighting is a perfect example.  And yes, I do think that they should be able to be hired upon release.  Prisons should be about reform, not about making better criminals, and reform involves humane treatment, education, accountability – and hope.  Any more paper tigers?

          • k May 12, 2026 (9:13 am)

            We have a presumption of innocence under the law.  Jail is mostly people who have been changed, but not convicted of anything.  You’re asking for people who have been not been convicted of a crime to be forced to work against their will.  That is slavery.  

      • Adam May 11, 2026 (10:02 pm)

        Is there a reason you’ve decided to completely lie in your response? Because I used to get into a lot of trouble, and there is ZERO work requirement in a city or county jail. It boggles my mind that you’d even think that’s the case as if you’ve literally NEVER talked to someone who has been arrested for a crime and kept in incarceration to await judgement, or to serve a crime after. I never served prison time myself and won’t speak to that, but you’re also not speaking to that because without a conviction that ends in a year and a day (or more) of time this woman wouldn’t see prison. TLDR: completely ignore Duck’s comment 

        • Duck May 12, 2026 (9:00 am)

          Here’s my source baby: https://www.bop.gov/inmates/custody_and_care/work_programs.jspbelieve it or not, the American justice system DOES still follow the philosophy of innocent until proven guilty, so yeah, they aren’t enslaving people who are waiting years upon years for sentencing. TLDR; don’t listen to Adam, he thinks personal anecdotes = facts 

          • occam May 12, 2026 (5:26 pm)

            You refer to the  federal bureau of prisons which is not applicable here.  That is for convicted people for federal crimes after trail. 

      • Rob May 11, 2026 (10:39 pm)

        It’s restitution, not slavery!

        • k May 12, 2026 (9:13 am)

          Restitution is ordered on conviction.  Most people in jail are awaiting their day in court and have not been convicted of anything.

          • anonyme May 12, 2026 (1:56 pm)

            To make a correction, I should have said prison, not jail.  However, there are people in jail who have been convicted and I do think they should be required to work – if only to take some of the burden off of taxpayers, who have not committed any crime.  That we know of.

        • Duck May 12, 2026 (9:14 am)

          Restitution is repaying victims. Slavery is requiring inmates to work for little to no money. 

      • anonyme May 12, 2026 (6:01 am)

        Duck, your reply is both contradictory and nonsensical.  You invoke the 13th amendment (which I have read, btw) and yet you clearly have not read it yourself.  It states “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted.”  And then you go on to say that the 13th amendment is wrong.  Which is it?  I agree with Rob, who rightly points out that restitution is not slavery.

      • What May 12, 2026 (7:40 am)

        Oh really? What work do the able bodied jailers do, specifically? 

  • RS May 11, 2026 (5:14 pm)

    I would looooooove to see these detectives testify about matching her “body type and build.” She missed masking up a critical identifying characteristic, which is her plumber butt. Hope that mortifying cross examination makes her reconsider her life of crime.

  • Shrey May 11, 2026 (7:32 pm)

    Is this the same lady? She stole a package from my front door. She also came with a dog. We stay in north delridge in west seattle

    • Tim May 12, 2026 (7:48 am)

      Please submit this photo and your statement to the police.

    • AT May 12, 2026 (10:28 am)

      No, yours doesn’t have dreadlocks

  • dwg May 11, 2026 (9:48 pm)

    Our judges, legislators and prosecutors should be ashamed of themselves. It’s unbelievable what you have to do to be held in custody. 

    • Bill May 12, 2026 (7:10 am)

      Anyone got links to specific laws? Agree this is much more severe than stealing toothpaste or food. Need to see how the law was written.  

    • k May 12, 2026 (9:17 am)

      Generally, if you harm a person they will try harder to hold you.  Ms. Scavotto has, so far, only hurt property, inanimate objects.  And yes, that theft does harm, but most theft in this country is perpetrated by white-collar criminals committing fraud, wage theft, and embezzlement.  Those people aren’t sitting in jail either.  Please remember that this person is being treated the same as (well, slightly worse, but generally the same) as the wealthy fraudsters who steal far more than she has gotten away with.  When you write your angry letters to politicians, make sure they understand you want justice for the while collar criminals who are doing the most harm to society.

      • dwg May 12, 2026 (10:33 am)

        that’s some pretty lazy whataboutism.

  • Juanita May 12, 2026 (7:57 am)

    So if she ducks out on reporting to CCAP as she did her initial arraignment, is there an enforcement mechanism in place to put her back in jail while she awaits her next hearing in June?  The only sympathy I have in this tale is for her dog and the businesses/peoples lives she has affected by her thievery.  Hopefully she arranges care for her pup in her absence.   

    • WSB May 12, 2026 (8:19 am)

      They’d issue a warrant. As for her dog, the charging documents from the April stolen-car case said it was turned over to Animal Control (Seattle Animal Shelter).

  • anonyme May 12, 2026 (2:00 pm)

    Is this the same female burglar who always had a dog with her, or another?  I feel bad for the dog; unlike its owner (presumably), the dog is innocent.

    • WSB May 12, 2026 (2:51 pm)

      No. That was a frequent car prowler who’d be much older by now.

    • dwg May 12, 2026 (9:07 pm)

      Jessica. She’s out and about and highland park as recently as this weekend, I’m assuming up to her old habits. 

Sorry, comment time is over.