WEST SEATTLE CRIME WATCH: ‘Prolific offender’ in jail after Monday foot pursuit

(Reader photo, Monday)

Back on Monday, that large police response drew attention in the 4700 block of 46th SW. Emergency radio indicated that, after officers chased him on foot, a man was taken into custody on suspicion of violating an anti-harassment order. We’ve been researching the case since then – it’s going through Seattle Municipal Court, and that system has a lag for document availability. But now we’ve confirmed that the suspect, 31-year-old Casey Carlstedt, is charged, and the file includes the police report detailing what officers say happened that morning:

Officers responded to a reported order violation at the Safeway supermarket located at 4754 42 Av SW. A staff member called 911 because a known suspect (Carlstedt) was in the store, and she believed that an order was in place that prevented him from being there.

(He) is a known prolific offender in the William Sector area – specifically in the Admiral and Alaska Junction areas. Carlstedt is familiar to most patrol officers in the precinct as well as many business owners and staff. (He) is also on the (City Attorney’s Office) High Utilizer list.

As (an officer) arrived in the area, she saw A/Carlstedt near the intersection of 42 Av SW / SW Alaska St. (She) stopped her patrol car and told Carlstedt to “STOP.” Carlstedt fled on foot and led officers on a foot chase over several blocks and across multiple busy roadways. Carlstedt fled through residential yards to escape (the officer). He ignored repeated commands to “STOP” and was told more than once that he was under arrest. Carlstedt yelled that he was not violating an NCO while fleeing from police. … Carlstedt was eventually detained on the 4700 block of 46 Av SW.

Checking the system, officers say, they found an anti-harassment order prohibiting Carlstedt from being within one mile of a particular person’s home, and they say he “was seen well within 1 Mile of that address.” He was arrested and booked into jail. The City Attorney’s Office has since charged him with violation of a court order and obstructing a public officer (gross misdemeanors), and he has pleaded not guilty. A document from Wednesday indicates that Municipal Court Judge Willie Gregory set bail at $7,500, though on the jail docket, it’s listed as twice that, possibly because he is listed as having another order-violation case pending. (We’re looking into that.)

BACKSTORY: Our previous mentions of Carlstedt include a 2021 case in which he was accused of using “bear mace” on a man who confronted him during an alleged car-prowl attempt, a 2020 case that was a lot like the current one, and multiple 2017 cases.

20 Replies to "WEST SEATTLE CRIME WATCH: 'Prolific offender' in jail after Monday foot pursuit"

  • Lock Em Up Already August 30, 2024 (6:17 pm)

    He’ll be out in 24 hours.

    • WSB August 30, 2024 (6:23 pm)

      He’s been in for four days so far.

  • Roddy3 August 30, 2024 (8:09 pm)

    No photo available of this guy?

  • Mike August 30, 2024 (8:16 pm)

    Is there a pic of this guy?

    • Beepee August 30, 2024 (11:39 pm)

  • 1994 August 30, 2024 (9:35 pm)

    Safeway may have a photo of him on their wall of shame,  in their no trespass lineup of photos.

  • I love hockey August 30, 2024 (10:01 pm)

    Judge Gregory plays hockey. Man’s awesome. No joke. 

  • Steve August 30, 2024 (10:50 pm)

    That guy is bad news. Very familiar with him since I work for one of the companies. Glad he’s off the street for a little while at least.

  • 47th Resident August 30, 2024 (11:10 pm)

    Know this guy well in North Admiral. Blond buzz cut, young and tall with sun tanned face. He sat outside my house one day and asked if I saw police coming. Always gives off unsafe / unpredictable energy.

  • Kravitz August 31, 2024 (5:55 am)

    This guy is a major problem. In the bear mace case a couple years ago, I spotted him hanging around the Rite Aid bus stop after recognizing him from posts about the incident on Nextdoor. Never was I so happy to call the police and watch them arrest the guy. He’s a career criminal with no care for anyone. 

  • Keep Him August 31, 2024 (9:25 am)

    Not to mention the guy is an absolute creep. Creeped on me when I was an underage girl in really off putting ways, I am now 28. Yuck. 

  • Monica August 31, 2024 (10:12 am)

    I noticed Casey was back in North Admiral again. I thought to myself, “alright, it’s not safe to walk here until he’s arrested next time.” I’ve seen him sitting in the middle of California Ave with traffic going around him. He looks like he’s ready to try and piss someone off.Just some background on him. I was dropping off clothing at the donation bin late one night in front of the 7-11 in North Admiral. He watched me get out of my car and open up the trunk hatch. Then he started sprinting toward me—probably trying to carjack me or worse. I beat him to the door and closed and locked it. He tried opening the door but couldn’t get in. The trunk hatch was still closing and he raced around to try and climb in, I started driving—directly onto Admiral Way (thankfully no cars) and he wasn’t able to climb in the back fast enough. Honestly one of the scariest moments of my life. Of course, he was still on the streets after that.Please watch out for him. I’m so disheartened to see him on the streets again and I’m very fearful of what he might do to the next person.

  • Meryl August 31, 2024 (2:09 pm)

    Thank you SPD! 

  • Gordon August 31, 2024 (6:10 pm)

    The individual described and named is the same one I mentioned during the first “in person” public meeting after Covid, at the SW SPD Precinct.  I was the one who mentioned the “one man crimewave” during that meeting, recorded by the WSBlog.  I am one of at least three people with current court orders against him.  He has been an on-going problem in our neighborhood for over a decade now, and his actions are escalating.  Despite his denial of violating NCO’s, he was served and is aware of his status.  He holds very cogent conversations in his defense on scenes, but claims to be homeless and is usually seeking drugs.  His last listed address I saw is in Auburn, but he remains here causing a myriad of problems for us.  His previous offenses include assaulting Police Officers.  Also, theft, possession of stolen property, erratic driving (when he has a vehicle), DUI, assault, harassment, and last year he was lighting fires in our neighborhood. Thank you Safeway Manager and SPD.

  • WSR September 1, 2024 (5:49 pm)

    The man I saw running around the neighborhood being chased by police was a 30-40 yo, pale Caucasian male with dirty blonde or light brown facial hair and little hair. Either shaven or balding. No distinctive facial features but clearly running from something. Glad to see they caught him since I was unable to get the officer’s attention to direct her towards him as I was heading down the hill. 

  • Concerned, citizen September 1, 2024 (7:28 pm)

    I’m praying that the judge keeps in mind the safety of our children and community when sentencing this person who is out of control and apparently does not know the difference between right and wrong. Aside from all the crimes he has committed he led the police in a pursuit, which put them at risk of injury and people around them.  It also terrorized the community.

    • K September 1, 2024 (8:40 pm)

      The judge will follow the law, not their feelings.  I’m praying that you gain an understanding of Washington State Law as it pertains to holding suspects and sentencing them after conviction.

      • Byron James September 2, 2024 (11:00 pm)

        @k. Judges have a great deal of discretion and latitude when it comes to sentencing. 

Sorry, comment time is over.