COMMENT COUNTDOWN: City Council committee spends 2 hours hearing/talking about West Seattle-to-Ballard light rail

That’s the Seattle Channel video of this morning’s City Council Transportation and Public Utilities Committee meeting, almost two hours of which was spent on the West Seattle to Ballard light-rail plan, starting about 36 minutes in. The time was divided between two presentations – first, city staff explaining how they’re drafting official city comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement, so they can get those in before the April 28th deadline. Much of this presentation was given to the West Seattle/Duwamish segment’s Community Advisory Group last week (WSB coverage here). Here’s the slide deck that the city’s Calvin Chow, Marshall Foster, and Sara Maxana used today:

One major area of concern in what they’re drafting so far – they want ST to better address potential BIPOC displacement in Delridge, “more truth-checking with the community,” as Maxana described it. In council comments, West Seattle/South Park Councilmember Lisa Herbold underscored a point made that “scope reductions” – like dropping a station – should be discouraged unless there’s a very clear benefit in return.

That came up again in the second discussion, which also was partly a rerun from last week’s Community Advisory Group meeting – ST’s view of possible cost-saving measures, including possibly dropping the Avalon station. This presentation was given by ST’s Cathal Ridge. Here’s the slide deck he used:

In this discussion, Herbold reiterated that dropping Avalon would require a clear benefit such as more tunneling. She also stressed that no matter what, tunneling should be the preference for the West Seattle Junction end of the line, as elevated rail through “the heart of” The Junction would be undesirable. She voiced one other concern about dropping the Avalon station, wondering where its projected 1,200 riders would go, and wondering if that would make light rail less accessible for residents coming down 35th from areas such as High Point. Ridge said they projected that half the Avalon ridership would come to the station by bus, and they would likely ride to the Junction station instead.

WHAT’S NEXT: City staff will return to this committee May 17th; their comments on the DEIS, though, like everyone else’s, are due by April 28th and will be submitted by then. (Here’s how to comment.)

5 Replies to "COMMENT COUNTDOWN: City Council committee spends 2 hours hearing/talking about West Seattle-to-Ballard light rail"

  • East Coast Cynic April 20, 2022 (7:24 am)

    Smells like they’re dropping the Avalon station.  If so ST better not only ensure efficient passage to the Junction for those connecting on the 35th Ave SW buses, but ensure that people who live in buildings on Avalon have quick and efficient connection to Delridge or the Junction.

    Sounds like Herbold wants to have her cake and eat it too. An Avalon Station and a tunnel w/o elevated option, but I don’t think ST can get the $$$$ to do both.

  • Rob April 20, 2022 (1:00 pm)

    The link to the slide deck (https://cdn.westseattleblog.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/cityprez.pdf) results in a 403 / FORBIDDEN error.

  • Gregory Nickels April 20, 2022 (2:28 pm)

    Just to set the record straight, there is no “West Seattle-to-Ballard” light rail line. The Ballard line will continue south to Tacoma while the West Seattle line will continue north to Everett. These will be separate lines that intersect at several points for easy transfers.

  • Ed H April 21, 2022 (4:16 pm)

    I have to chime in that the suggestions of dropping the Avalon Station are short sighted and foolish. 35th is the main bus feeder for transit users from as far south as Westwood, and all the points in between such as High Point. Nobody seems to be tracking that High Point might lose their most convenient station and that there is capacity for more than 2,000 new apartments in the Triangle that are being planned to service the station; much more future growth potential than in the Junction and representing a huge number of potential riders. There are 516 gorgeous “Transit Utopia” apartments and a park-like streetscape already planned to set the stage for redevelopment of the Alki Lumber land and to kick off the rest of that future neighborhood. In the long run the Avalon station will probably be the busiest of the three unless we are foolish enough to eliminate it, and we will miss the opportunity to create an awesome new neighborhood in the Triangle if there’s no new station right next door. 

Sorry, comment time is over.