Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

Editorials / Opinion


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Press Here

This news media blog explores the nexus between the press, the public and technology with two missions. One, to engage citizens in an online conversation about the role of the news media in their lives, in the hope that they will use and critique the media more effectively. And secondly to explore how the press can remain relevant, essential and accountable to citizens and communities.

Mike Fancher is Editor at Large of The Seattle Times.

E-mail Mike Fancher | 206.464.2330 | RSS feeds Subscribe | Blog Home

January 23, 2008 4:10 PM

Citizens are taking journalism into their own hands

Posted by Mike Fancher

Citizen Journalism is catching hold in Seattle and getting mainstream attention.

The West Seattle Blog was featured in a recent Seattle Times column by Danny Westneat, who called it "the most thorough chronicling of what's going on in a neighborhood I've ever seen." The blog was created by Tracy Record, who formerly worked at KCPQ Q13 but now works on the blog 18 hours a day, seven days a week. She plans to run it as a small business.

Sleepless in Magnolia, a community-action site, was featured in a story today by Times reporter Christine Clarridge. Magnolia residents use the site to share their stories of break-ins and car prowls, and to put pressure on Seattle City Hall to do something.

Sleepless isn't trying to be a business; in fact a note on the site says the citizen who started it decided he didn't like the clutter of the ads on the site so he is paying $20 a month to get rid of them. He wrote, "If you see my wife, tell her not to get mad :-)"

A group of 4th and 5th grade students in the Science/Technology Magnet program at Clark Elementary School in Issaquah sent an e-mail to me today explaining what they are doing to help the environment. They've posted an online video to "inform, educate, and inspire others to make be a positive eco-friendly influence in our community." They're working on a Web site that will consist of articles they've written to explain the importance of using eco-friendly products.

The small business, the community-action network and the class project are all examples of Citizen Journalism, people using new technologies to tell their stories.

Press Here to see a 15-minute video called "Citizen Journalism: From Pamphlet to Blog," which includes comments from people who are following this phenomenon closely:

* Lisa Williams says the best one-line description she's heard of Citizen Journalism is, "People who are non-journalists committing random acts of journalism." Williams should know. She is the founder of H2OTown.info, a robust news and community site for Watertown, Massachusetts.

* Bill Densmore, director of the Media Giraffe Project at the University of Maryland, appears in the video, saying there is a re-emergence of people being empowered by getting involved in journalism. "For a long time, you couldn't get involved with journalism because it was all big money, big outfits."

* Chris Daly, professor of journalism at Boston University, says the significance of what is happening is that it is in the hands of regular people. He says the future is being made today by millions of men and women in an uncoordinated way all around the world.

Steve Simpson isn't in the video, but he saw this coming when he was a graduate student in communications at the University of Washington in the early 1990s. He says he told his fellow classmates that anyone’s voice and opinion could be heard.

All they needed to do was open a Web site and hand out some flyers on the corner. As an example, I used my own education related Web site, www.edbriefs.com, opened as an experiment with $1,500 as a way to provide education news summaries to teachers who did not have time to read full articles. With little money, and even less business sense, I was able to have my voice heard.

"I have been publishing my newsletter for 12 years. The circulation has been as high as 100,000 when I published only news summaries and is now around 25,000 now that I publish only my own original education columns, as near as I can figure it out. I told my fellow grad students that anyone with an opinion and a few hundred dollars could be heard. They may not have access to the hundreds of thousands of readers big newspapers have spent a century building, but they can be heard. I think your new blog is another example of new media providing a voice at little cost." I


Simpson's advice to The Times:
"I wish you would decentralize. I wish you would break up your reporters and turn each of them loose. You will have to give up the safety and familiarity of the giant structure you now have, but you would still be The Seattle Times, just different...The WestSeattleBlog did it. I even did it with my little education voice, Ed.Net.

I don’t know what it would look like, but the marketplace of ideas is not found in your newsrooms and hallways. Turn your people loose, let them build their own networks of sources. A hundred trained journalists wandering around will provide readers with more powerful, timely, relevant small bits of news than any centralized publication ever could."


The full text of Simpson's e-mail to me follows:

Here is the full e-mail from Steve Simpson:

Mr. Fancher,

When I was a grad student at the University of Washington school of Communications, the most popular topic of debate was the elimination of a representative media due to large corporations buying up all of the newspapers, radio stations, television stations, etc. It seemed like every seminar turned into a group vilification of the giant media corporations and grieving over the loss of true objective, representative journalism. I listened to these students with respect, but every once in awhile I would point out to them that they were wrong. I told them then, in the early 1990’s, that anyone’s voice and opinion could be heard. All they needed to do was open a Web site and hand out some flyers on the corner. As an example, I used my own education related Web site, www.edbriefs.com, opened as an experiment with $1,500 as a way to provide education news summaries to teachers who did not have time to read full articles. With little money, and even less business sense, I was able to have my voice heard.

I have been publishing my newsletter for 12 years. The circulation has been as high as 100,000 when I published only news summaries and is now around 25,000 now that I publish only my own original education columns, as near as I can figure it out. I told my fellow grad students that anyone with an opinion and a few hundred dollars could be heard. They may not have access to the hundreds of thousands of readers big newspapers have spent a century building, but they can be heard. I think your new blog is another example of new media providing a voice at little cost. I was reading yet another story this morning about how newspapers are losing circulation and laying off staff, this one about the Los Angeles Times. It made me think about USA Today.

Do you remember how so many journalist argued that USA Today, with its graphics and shortened stories, was the dumbed down first step in the death of true journalism? They argued that USA Today was not journalism, but flashy entertainment. It may have been, but it grew to a huge circulation very quickly. Tracy Record started the WestSeattleBlog.com, a different but thematically similar publication. USA Today was different and profitable. The WestSeattleBlog is different and will probably be profitable. Even my little education Web site became profitable. Now we have smart phones, cell phone cameras, and a generation of what Marc Prensky calls “digital natives.” So many of Microsoft’s employees are transient that they set up buses and offices with wireless capability to allow employees to simply drop in for a few hours when they were in the neighborhood. Television news stations routinely ask viewers to send in tips and video clips that often find their way into the primary broadcasts. Why can’t The Seattle Times plan a similar dramatic transformation from a large organization into a collective of organized, trained journalists?

I have been reading the print edition of The Seattle Times for many years. I have even had my articles published in the editorial pages of your newspaper. I love reading my newspaper in the quiet of the morning with my coffee, but I am going to cancel my subscription. My daughter is an environmental scientist. I want to reduce my carbon footprint. I want to stop recycling the hundreds of pounds of paper I use for only about one hour each day and reduce the energy it takes to put that paper on my doorstep. I will remain a loyal Seattle Times reader, but I wish you would do the same thing I argued for in those long lost grad school seminars. I wish you would decentralize. I wish you would break up your reporters and turn each of them loose. You will have to give up the safety and familiarity of the giant structure you now have, but you would still be The Seattle Times, just different. USA Today did it. The WestSeattleBlog did it. I even did it with my little education voice, Ed.Net. I don’t know what it would look like, but the marketplace of ideas is not found in your newsrooms and hallways. Turn your people loose, let them build their own networks of sources. A hundred trained journalists wandering around will provide readers with more powerful, timely, relevant small bits of news than any centralized publication ever could. Anyway, that is one reader’s opinion.

I will be sorry to lose my printed Seattle Times, but I will continue to seek out Seattle Times journalism.

Regards,

Steve Simpson

Digg Digg | Newsvine Newsvine

Submit a comment

*Required Field



Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Posted by John Koehler, 7134426

10:05 AM, Jan 25, 2008

It seems to me that an inherent part of decentralization of reporting is giving the citizen a voice, and that voice is heard, at least in part, right here in the blogs. You need not go any further than the Husky football blog, however, to see that such a path can quickly lead to radicalization of opinion leading to the worst fanaticism. I love participating in my community. I dispise when extremists use guerilla tactics to hijack discussions. A middle path is needed to keep discussions on topic, relevent and reasonably balanced. Ancient Greeks had immediate verbal feedback to the individual standing upon his/her soapbox. The web gives complete anonymity and the ability to create multiple false identities.

Posted by TR from WSB

11:02 PM, Jan 26, 2008

To one point in Mr. Simpson's e-mail to Mr. Fancher: "Wandering around" is a key phrase. This is how we find a lot of what we report on our site, in addition to reader tips and online research. But it has to be informed "wandering around" with context - know your community, know your "beat" well enough to know when you are seeing change - a business closing, a business opening, a land-use-notice sign going up, a road closure, the list goes on. I worked in "conventional media," print as well as broadcast, for a quarter-century. The mistake I and most of my co-workers made in so many newsrooms, good and bad, was that we didn't make time to "wander around." I am working hard now to make up for squandered time!

Recent entries

Apr 30, 08 - 10:00 PM
-- 30 --

Apr 29, 08 - 02:20 PM
It's time for Press Here to press on

Apr 25, 08 - 03:55 PM
A "welcome ad"? I don't think so.

Apr 18, 08 - 11:30 AM
Technical fouls in the Sonics fan forum

Apr 15, 08 - 04:10 PM
Citizen journalism may be a bitter pill for some

Advertising

Marketplace

Advertising

Advertising

Categories
Calendar

May

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Browse the archives

April 2008

March 2008

February 2008

January 2008

Blogroll and links

Advertising

Buy a link here